Tingle begins his article by refuting David Bartholomae’s “Inventing the University”, effectively based on his own social tragedy with the working and middle class. Tingle instantly increases his credibility on the subject as he has experience in both the working and middle class, “Both of my own educational experience as a member of the working class and of the pedagogy I employ as a teacher of writing with middle-class students”, proving he has experience with both classes and is more credible than Bartholomae. The working class home is also brought up in a distinctly different culture then the middle-class home,”At the dinner table my parents did not encourage me to elaborate upon my subjective intent.”, Tingle provides his own experience to elaborate the idea that the working class is brought up differently, to which hinders their creativity and personal thoughts. Furthermore, Tingle provides his own experience in high school with a working class school that limited his own creative writing based on the teacher 's expectations, “The teachers at my working-class high school gave assignments in the way working-class parents gave orders.”, based on this quote, Tingle explains that the working class schools operate in such a way that limits the student 's own ability’s s...
... middle of paper ...
...together. Furthermore, Tingle goes on to add yet another personal note about his family, “during his years working for the post office, one of my brothers was encouraged by management to join their ranks”, and goes on a tangent and seems to lose his focus on the argument itself. Although, Tingle has made effective arguments by taking a personal approach; however, Tingle loses credibility and uses stories that adds little to no credibility.
Tingle Uses his own personal experiences, and ethos to persuade the fact the middle and working class are separated by culture rather than their own intuition. However, Tingle lacks the effectiveness from his personal experience and ethos arguments by venting meaningless stories and arguments. Overall, Tingle expressed his opinion strongly and effectively with the exception of his tangents and ineffective citations and stories.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- During my analysis of the article “The Vexation of Class”, it quickly became evident that the author, Nick Tingle, investigates his vexation by making numerous comparisons to David Bartholomae’s “Inventing the University”. Tingle analyzes Bartholomae’s article in terms of its assumptions made in reference to class, such as how the student writer must become someone whom they are not. Within the clear conversation of his vexation experienced growing up in a working-class household, as well as the effects and struggles that students endure when being a member of a working-class school, Tingle’s use of pathos holds effective throughout the article.... [tags: Middle class, Social class, Working class]
1194 words (3.4 pages)
- Inventing Not Done Right: Rhetorical Analysis in Nick Tingle’s “The Vexation of Class” The working class stays working and the middle class stays being middle. Author Nick Tingle, wrote “The vexation of class”, he argues that the working class and the middle class are separated educationally based on culture and the commonplace. Tingle uses his own personal experiences and Ethos, to effectively prove his point about the difference in class based on culture ; although, Tingle also falls short by adding unnecessary information throughout the article that weakens his belief entirely.... [tags: Middle class, Working class, Social class]
796 words (2.3 pages)
- Nick Hitchon, a boy from a middle class, was a farmer’s son from Yorkshire Dale in rural England. Form the series it is understood that he was not well privileged boy growing up. His parents did have much money. However, nick has ideological beliefs than a culture or pattern of living based on artifacts. At early age he was interested in moon and stars. His ambition did not fall short as he started his journey at age 14 when he joined boarding school. Besides his educational life, his attitudes towards life such as girls, sex, and politics seems was rather narrow.... [tags: Social class, Working class, Married in America]
1070 words (3.1 pages)
- The stories of Nick Cassavetes The Notebook (2004) and Richard Curtis About Time (2013) are both similar yet different in their own ways. The Notebook is an American romance drama film starring Rachel McAdams and Ryan Gosling that was extremely successful not only in American box office but also shared great worldwide success. This film exemplifies the struggle between love and social class. Two young lovers have to face social class boundaries and put their loves on the line. The approach that this movie trying to make is a relevant topic in the world we inhabit today and undoubtedly contributed to this film’s success.... [tags: Social class, Working class, Sociology]
2008 words (5.7 pages)
- Nick Hornby's High Fidelity In Nick Hornby's High Fidelity, the main character, Rob, relates music to every aspect of his life. He utilizes music as an escape from his anxieties regarding his failing record store, relationship, and sense of self. Music provides Rob with the inspiration that keeps him going: Records have helped me to fall in love, no question. I hear something new, with a chord change that melts my guts, and before I know it I'm looking for someone. (169) Music prompts Rob to isolate himself, hold an unrealistic view of people and sabotage his relationships.... [tags: Nick Hornby High Fidelity Music Essays]
955 words (2.7 pages)
- In every country there are several classes of society. The classes of society are divide into four groups. The groups are the lower class, working class, middle class, and upper class. The social classes are like a totem pole starting with the low or poor class on the bottom then the working class then the middle class, and then the upper or owner class on top. The two biggest classes we have here in united states is the working and middle class. In 1998 the lower class is consisted of 5%. The working class is made up of 45%.... [tags: Middle class, Social class, Working class]
991 words (2.8 pages)
- Growing Up in About a Boy by Nick Hornby About a boy is a novel which follows the lives of two people: Marcus and Will. Marcus is a strange kid who struggles with growing up, he is in need for acceptance outside of his own family, he is searching for his own identity, he is a victim of constant bullying and is suffering with his lack of parental care. Will is the complete opposite to Marcus. He is a 36 year old who is in his own extended childhood, he is searching for his identity not wanting to lose his youth, he ‘prides himself on his cool’ and simply can’t find a way to grow up.... [tags: About Boy Nick Hornby Analysis]
1011 words (2.9 pages)
- Are people born into the social class they are now and “stuck” there for the rest of their life or are they able to work hard and change in which social class they fall into. In America there is 3 social classes. Upper class, those who don’t really work but still have money, middle class, those who have jobs in offices, and the lower class, those who work for everything. But social classes aren’t always just defined by the amount of money they have but their morals as well. I believe that with enough work and determination a person is able to grow and change their social class and my mother’s story is one of the many that have succeeded in doing so.... [tags: Social class, Middle class, Working class]
1088 words (3.1 pages)
- The narrator of The Great Gatsby is a man from America named Nick Caraway. He not only narrates the story but portrays himself as the book’s author. Whilst we as the reader make our way through the passage, it is effortless to forget the important fact that The Great Gatsby is first of all a book about a man writing a book; therefore we are not observering this scene first hand, although it seems on the surface as if we are; Nick Caraway is merley recreating events for us, filtering them through his own sense of connotation, and filling them with his own perception.... [tags: Classic Literature]
1930 words (5.5 pages)
- What is amazing about Leeson’s activities is the fact that he was able to accumulate such staggering losses without the management of Baring’s noticing. Leeson had various roles to play within BSS; he was the general manager, the head trader and the head of the back office. Usually different people perform these tasks, but Baring’s management failed to see the conflict of interests befalling one undertaking multiple roles . Leeson had control over both the trading desk and the clearing and settlement function eliminating the necessary checks and balances usually found within trading organizations, a clear violation of a fundamental principle of risk management.... [tags: Barings Debacle Nick Leeson Management]
1471 words (4.2 pages)