Value Pluralism and Absolute Moral Judgments Essay

Value Pluralism and Absolute Moral Judgments Essay

Length: 1552 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Widespread and deep moral disagreements are persistently resistant to rational solutions and thus allow for continuing debate over the validity of moral judgments. This paper will discuss prominent positions regarding whether moral judgments may be true and false in an absolute sense or a relative sense, in light of the diverse and intense disagreement in moral judgment. This paper will defend the pluralistic conclusion that if there are not specific universal values, there is at least a minimum value of humanity without which a society could not survive. Moral judgments may be true and false in the absolute sense of this minimum.
There are two main categories to classify different positions regarding moral judgments. Normative Moral Relativity is the view that the truth or falsity of moral judgments is not absolute, but is relative to the convictions, practices, or traditions of some group of persons such as a society or culture. This answers the question “How should I live?” by saying that one should follow the values of your society or culture. Richard Shweder, in his “The Astonishment of Anthropology”, defends an anthropological relativism that stresses the importance of tolerance and moral diversity. Shweder’s position allows for difference in moral opinion among different cultures. Terence Tanner’s anthropological view, in his “Human Rights, Human Difference”, is like Shweder’s in it appreciation for diversity, however Tanner calls for “transcultural” principles of justice or, allowing people to be different so long as they allow other to be different as well.
Moral Objectivity is the view that morality would be objective only if moral judgments are ordinarily true or false in an absolute sense, many moral judgments are ...


... middle of paper ...


...f value of humanity, leaving moral basics up to the individual culture. Thomas Aquinas defended a version of Moral objectivism, claiming that natural law is universal and that disagreements regarding the universal natural law can be explained by mistakes, developing understanding of that universal natural law or the need for divine intervention. Martha Nussbaum examines different daily and universal human experiences in which most people must participate. Through this examination Nussbaum defends a version of Moral Objectivism, this one heavily supported by Aristotle, that there is indeed a single objective account of the human good based on our common humanity. However, it is Isaiah Berlin’s version of pluralism and his clear demand for a minimum value of humanity that fully encompasses the true relationship between cultures and thus the nature of moral judgments.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Value Pluralism and Absolute Moral Judgments Essay

- Widespread and deep moral disagreements are persistently resistant to rational solutions and thus allow for continuing debate over the validity of moral judgments. This paper will discuss prominent positions regarding whether moral judgments may be true and false in an absolute sense or a relative sense, in light of the diverse and intense disagreement in moral judgment. This paper will defend the pluralistic conclusion that if there are not specific universal values, there is at least a minimum value of humanity without which a society could not survive....   [tags: normative moral relativity, moral objectivity]

Powerful Essays
1552 words (4.4 pages)

Essay about The Truth Of The Gospel Of A Pluralist Society

- ... Each of us should have a personal faith of our own.1 Cleverly, in response to this dichotomy, Newbigin uses the claim of science on fact to show that scientists use an agreed upon set of assumptions, like Christianity, to make claims to truth. These assumptions become the lens through which we observe the world. The Christian lens is the Gospel through which “the Christian community is invited to indwell the story, tacitly aware of it as shaping the way we understanding, but focally attending to the world we live in so that we are able to confidently, through not infallibly, to increase our understanding of it and our ability to cope with it.” Christians are invited to be a part of a c...   [tags: Christianity, Jesus, Pluralism, God]

Powerful Essays
1280 words (3.7 pages)

Religious Pluralism Is Not A Plausible Philosophical Position Essay

- I begin by describing the Hickean account of religious pluralism. Essentially Hick aims to explain religious plurality through the shared salvific experiences and values of the Real. I then give Hick’s conception of what the Real is and how it relates to major religions. Hickean religious pluralism faces what I consider to be fatal criticisms with regards to the nature of the Real, the result is that either the Real is contradictory or fails in its explanatory value. I, therefore, conclude that Hickean religious pluralism is not a plausible philosophical position....   [tags: Religion, God, Religious pluralism, Christianity]

Powerful Essays
1594 words (4.6 pages)

The Effect Of Temperature On The Temperature Of Degrees And At Which All Particle Motion Stops ( Absolute Zero )

- ... Assemble a hot bath, add 4-5 coins to the glass beaker. Add about 400 mL of tap water and put your thermometer in the beaker. Put the rubber stopper into an EMPTY, dry test tube. Gently (low) heat water on the stove top to a simmer (gentle boil). Allow the temperature to equalize for at least 5 minutes. Record the temperature of the hot water bath (T1). Using your tongs quickly flip the test over into the ice water bath. Turn the burner off. Wait about 5 minutes. Equalize the level of water in the test tube with the level of water in the container, and place finger over the rubber stopper in the test tube to keep the water in when you invert the test tube....   [tags: Temperature, Celsius, Absolute zero, Fahrenheit]

Powerful Essays
1096 words (3.1 pages)

Ethical Judgments and the Production of Knowledge Essay

- Humans are rational and emotional creatures whose intellect allows for the evaluation of behaviors and actions. These evaluations help humans rule over actions and create ethical judgments. Ethical judgments dictate over what should be done and restrict the way of being of individuals. Ethical judgments have an impact in the methods available in the production of knowledge, but are not considered hindrances since they affirm the principles of human morality and are needed to judge knowledge claims....   [tags: The Stem Cell Debate]

Powerful Essays
1232 words (3.5 pages)

The Height Of Males Between Age Between 20 And 24 Essay

- ... This could be due to people moving into the area because of its proximity to the city and several colleges including Camden County Community College, Rutgers, Rowan and Stockton University. Since 1900 the states with the largest population increase by percentage were Washington, California, Florida, Arizona, and Nevada. By absolute value, however, the states with the largest population increases were Illinois, New York, Florida, Texas, and California. It is difficult to conclusively say why the populations in Nevada, Arizona, Florida, California and Washington increased more than other states....   [tags: Population, Demography, Absolute value]

Powerful Essays
1074 words (3.1 pages)

The Ethical Dilemma of Defining Moral Absolutes Essay

- When our ancestors began to develop cognitive thought, they began to compare themselves to one another in an attempt to decide what is morally permissible behavior, and what is not. Although, our global community has grown to be very large, and culturally diverse these same moral debates still linger in today’s society. Fundamentalist believe that there are absolute moral codes that apply to all societies. Inherently the fundamentalist view sounds like an ideal view that all cultures should respect....   [tags: moral absolutes, fundamentalist, relativism]

Powerful Essays
1272 words (3.6 pages)

The Evils of Absolute Power Essay

- The Evils of Absolute Power The above statement was written by a liberal called Lord Acton, he is what is commonly called a classical liberal. Classical liberalism was pre-Twentieth century liberalism, before it was revised because of the progress in industrialisation. However, the consistent central theme of liberalism in both forms (classical and modern) is individualism....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
585 words (1.7 pages)

Absolute Essay

- An elephant was brought to a group of blind men who had never encountered such an animal before. One felt a leg and reported that an elephant is a great living pillar. Another felt the trunk and reported that an elephant is a great snake. Another felt a tusk and reported that an elephant is like a sharp ploughshare. And so on. And then they all quarreled together, each claiming that his own account was the truth and therefore all the others false (traditional parable). None of the accounts that the blind men made about the nature of the elephant are absolute truths, nor are the accounts false....   [tags: essays research papers]

Powerful Essays
1009 words (2.9 pages)

Pluralism Essay

- American Pluralism In Federalist No. 10, James Madison stresses that “measures are too often decided, not according to the rules of justice and the rights of the minor party, but by the superior force of an interested and overbearing majority.” Madison philosophized that a large republic, composed of numerous factions capable of competing with each other and the majority must exist in order to avoid tyranny of majority rule.# When Federalist No. 10 was published, the concept of pluralism was not widely used....   [tags: Federalist Papers pluralistic theory]

Free Essays
1378 words (3.9 pages)