The Use Of Drugs Based On The Best Judgement Argument Essay

The Use Of Drugs Based On The Best Judgement Argument Essay

Length: 786 words (2.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

When a state is neutral between different concepts of the good life, then it should not prohibit the use of drugs based on the best judge argument. Which says that people are the best judges regarding what is in their best interest in pertaining to the good life (Caney 463). Individual should be allowed to partake in recreational drugs because a neutral state allows them the autonomy to make decisions free from coercion, which helps shape a person’s personal identity.
The first argument to support the idea that governments should not prohibit the recreational use of drugs based on the best judgement argument, is that for a government to truly be neutral regarding different concepts of the good life, then they should fully support a person’s autonomy. Autonomy can be considered one of the highest pleasures regarding the concept of the good life, this is because it allows a person to make the necessary decisions in their life to help establish their concept of the good life. Autonomy will allow a person to decide if recreational drug use is necessary. This decision process for some would include the temptation and the action of trying different recreational drugs, and to some the enjoyment. While others will dislike or find the recreational use of drugs unnecessary. However, an individual will be unable to know what their opinion on recreational drug use is, without experimentation.
Experimenting with life is only experienced through autonomy, because people must have the freedom to try new things and make decisions. However, some experiments might lead to bad decision, they are necessary to truly understand what the good life entails. If a government is promoting neutrality towards the good life, but begin to prohibit recreation...


... middle of paper ...


...own individuality. This individuality is what ultimately makes human beings different from animals, because it is a personal identity that makes one unique and establishes their own concept of the good life. This is a necessary so one may live a fulling life, because without the ability to make mistakes and learn from them an individual will just become a part of the masses, like an animal following his master.
In conclusion, based on the concept of the best judgement argument, a government who is participating in neutrality regarding the concept of the good life should not hinder a person’s ability to choose and participate in recreational drugs. This is because prohibition hinders a person, and coerces their personal identity, and view on the good life. While, recreational drug use may not be for all, it is an allowable decision in the creation of the good life.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Judgement Of Taste Is Based Solely On Opinions And Feelings Essay

- The judgement of taste is based solely on the opinions and feelings of the person affected by the object being viewed. This judgement is and can only be completely objective depending on individual feeling. Based on person judgement, the opinion formed while viewing a subject does nothing to contribute to the area of teaching or learning since the sentiment appeals to the senses. Only our personal interest to an object will determine our reactions and emotions felt from its existence. Beauty can only be determined by a person’s own personal feelings....   [tags: Sense, Emotion, Judgment, Aesthetics]

Better Essays
1048 words (3 pages)

Essay on The Judgement Of The Judgment Seat Of Christ

- Paul says that “all of us must appear before the judgment seat of Christ, so that each may receive recompense for what has been done in the body, whether good or evil” (2 Cor 5:10; cf. Rom 14:10). We know very little about what to expect on the final judgment, however it is assured in Romans 2:5 that God is righteous and fair in his judgment. People will be judged according to principles and laws that have been clearly established and made known to everyone (Rom 2:15), God will not discriminate....   [tags: Jesus, New Testament, Last Judgment, Heaven]

Better Essays
729 words (2.1 pages)

Should Judgement Of People 's Intelligence Be Based On Their Knowledge Or Their Wisdom?

- Should judgement of people’s intelligence be based on their knowledge or their wisdom. While those with broader spans of knowledge have all the answers because of logic, they might not be able to see past the trivial facts they believe to become wiser and more enlightened. Some might be able to see the true reality they are in, but most are not able to grasp these ideas. Two of J.D. Salinger 's characters, Teddy from a short story of the same name, and Franny Glass, from the book "Franny and Zooey", both realize and have begun to “see” in terms of detachment and spirituality....   [tags: J. D. Salinger, Franny and Zooey]

Better Essays
984 words (2.8 pages)

Ethical Judgement and the Production of Knowledge Essay

- Ethical judgment is not a definite restriction for the method and production of knowledge in art field, but it does relatively limit the production of knowledge in the natural science fields. Since the ethical judgment is an authority in a majority of people’s notion and mind, people tend to follow ethical standards and harder to develop the further knowledge. In addition, reason is one of the ways of knowing and moral principle is a crucial factor that shapes the pursuit of knowledge. The extreme cases in the natural science and in distinctive areas of knowledge violate the reason that undermines the moral obligation....   [tags: Essays on Ethical Judgement]

Better Essays
994 words (2.8 pages)

The Argument Against Decriminalization Of Drugs Essay

- 1. Explain the arguments for and against the decriminalization of drugs in the U.S. The points of interest for decriminalization of medications in the U.S is that it would lessen assets the administration cost by disposing of consumptions on forbiddance authorization, for example, anxieties, arraignment, and detainment. The cash can rather be supported towards treatment for all clients, drug counteractive action, and wrongdoing control in different ranges. Correctional facility and jail would be cleared of the individuals who have been captured and charged for ownership and utilization of medications this would likewise chop down the stresses and exchanging of AIDS, in return for drugs....   [tags: Drug addiction, Recreational drug use, Drug]

Better Essays
1073 words (3.1 pages)

Franz Kafka's Judgement Essay

- Franz Kafka's Judgement This short story of Franz Kafka is really a challenging one to interpret but apparently there are some contextual clues that enables us to draw some logical conclusions out of the story. Firstly, we should handle this story in terms of human relationships; there are 3 kind of relationships represented in the story. The first is the relationship between George (the main character of the story) and his friend in Russia; the second is George's relationship with his fiancée and the third is his relationship with his father....   [tags: Kafka Judgement Essays]

Free Essays
1146 words (3.3 pages)

Essay Analysis of Franz Kafka's The Judgement

- Franz Kafka's The Judgement depicts the struggle of father-son relationships. This modernistic story explores Georg Bendemann's many torments, which result from the bonds with both his father and himself. Furthermore, the ever-present and lifelong battle that Georg has been fighting with his father leads him to fight an even greater battle with himself. Ultimately, Georg loses the struggle with himself by letting go of his newly found independence and instead, letting external forces decide his fatal outcome....   [tags: The Judgement by Franz Kafka]

Better Essays
1600 words (4.6 pages)

Legalization of Drugs Argument Essay

- Legalization of Drugs Argument Man, as a creature, is inherently bored. Since the dawn of time, it has been the natural instinct of man to find alternative methods to enhance his being. The many means by which man has turned to include sex, gambling, and the consumption of substances beyond the requirements of nutrition. The consumption of substances can be further broken down into legal and illegal substances. The question then becomes, who are we to place labels on certain substances by deeming them legal and prohibit others by creating penalties for their use....   [tags: Drug Prohibition Regulation Legal Argumentative]

Better Essays
3263 words (9.3 pages)

Legalizing Drugs Essay

- Legalizing Drugs Drug legalization is an enduring question that presently faces our scholars. This issue embraces two positions: drugs should not be legalized and drugs should be legalized. These two positions contain an array of angles that supports each issue. This brief of the issues enables one to consider the strengths and weakness of each argument, become aware of the grounds of disagreement and agreement and ultimately form an opinion based upon the positions stated within the articles. In the article “Against the Legalization of Drugs”, by James Q....   [tags: Illegal Drugs Narcotics]

Better Essays
1323 words (3.8 pages)

Essay about Judgement

- Judgement People can often be treated and judged in a less than equal manner before people even know the true nature of the person, such as the way that the Finch children think that Boo Radley is some kind of a monster. Or the way people call Atticus Finch is called a nigger-lover. One of my most favorite quotations is that of Martin Luther King Junior. "I have a dream, that one day my children will be judged not by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character." People should make judgements of the person's character, not by their appearance, race, religion, sexuality, and morals....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
633 words (1.8 pages)