Compensated organ donations – one of the most controversial issues we have today. The scarcity of organ donations in America is the main reason there is a sudden diversion of possible source of organs. Beginning with donations of organs from cadaver to living donors, different strategies sprung just to reduce the said shortage; as a result of this quest, sale and paid organs is one of the approaches that gathered too much attention from the public. The controversy of paid organ donations entered the limelight when the state of Wisconsin offered incentives to the living donors. This law, which was created in the year 2004, grants tax deduction and repayment of donation expenses such as travel cost and lost earnings. Historically, neither property right to human corpse nor license to remove and transfer the organs of a cadaver is evident in the universal law. Hence, when transplants became possible, there were no legal systems that would allow individuals to donate their organs upon death for the purpose of transplants. To resolve this problem, UAGA or Uniform Anatomical Gift Act was publicized in the year 1968. This act grants individual the right to choose before death whether their organs will be donated or offered for transplants. In case, the individual can no longer decide because of his condition, the relatives have to right to decide for him. UAGA openly deals with organ donations but it is silent with the issue of sales and compensated organs. Buying and selling of organs remained unclear after the National Organ Transplant Act (NOTA) was approved in 1984. It improves the system of voluntary organ donation and prohibits the commercial markets of organs by turning it into a federal crime. Experts say that the ...
... middle of paper ...
...ro, L. (2003). Commodification and exploitation: arguments in favour of compensated organ donation.
Ghods, A. (2004). Governed financial incentives as an alternative to altruistic organ donation. 1.
Hansmann, H., & Harris, S. (1989). The Economics and Ethics of Markets for Human Organs. Organ Transplantation Policy: Issues and Prospects, 2.
Monahan, B. (2008). Should Organ Donors &/or Their Families Be Financially Compensated?. 3.
Monti, J. (2009). The Case for Compensating Live Organ Donors. Competitive Enterprise Institute, 3.
Rutecki, G. (2008). Commodities Trading or Gift Exchange: Where will tomorrow’s organ donors come from?. The Center for Bioethics and Human Dignity,
Shapsay, S. (2009). Commodification, Exploitation, and the Market for Transplant Organs.. InBioethics at the Movies. Baltimore, Maryland, United States: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The shortage of organ donations for transplants is an ongoing problem in the United States. The number of individuals in need of organ transplants greatly exceeds the number of authorized and registered organ donors, both living and deceased. Furthermore, the waitlist for individuals in need of transplants continues to grow every day3. In other words, the supply of organs does not meet the demand for them, and there is an ongoing debate as to how to address this issue. Concerns about individual autonomy and informed consent also play a large role in organ donation.... [tags: Organ donation, Organ transplant, Legal death]
1477 words (4.2 pages)
- A Giving Heart In the schoolyard, a match of tug of war has ensued. Each side’s participants have desperately clenched onto the rope, gained as much footing as possible, and every muscle in their bodies are clenched. When one seems to gain ground, the other begins to pull back even harder striving to prove they are the strongest. In life many situations can be found back in the roots of that schoolyard, one side grimacing at the other because they are not apart of what they call acceptable. In the world of organ transplants and donations, the same tug of war match is underway.... [tags: Organ transplant, Organ donation, Legal death]
1218 words (3.5 pages)
- Within the United States, an archaic system is in place that costs roughly thirty American lives every day; this system is the organ donation process. Waiting lists can potentially involve thousands of different patients in need of a vital organ to prolong their lives; however, some of these patients never have the opportunity to receive a kidney or a lung due to the lack of donations. Other nations have found a way to eliminate these long, waiting lists, including Iran, by providing citizens with an incentive to donate: money.... [tags: Organ transplant, Organ, Organ donation]
715 words (2 pages)
- Introduction A. I want your body, ok not your body just your organs. B. The need for organ and tissue donation is increasing and the people on the lifesaving transplant list need your help. About a year ago, I had the privilege of, meeting a man who was in his late sixties, a real jokester, and a person who really enjoyed life. He was a person that could make you smile even if you were in the worst of moods. Well, when I met this man he had been on the liver lifesaving transplant list for almost two years.... [tags: Organ transplant, Organ donation, Organ, Liver]
799 words (2.3 pages)
- All people in the world can choose to save a life, but not everyone will. Organ donation is when organs are surgically removed from one person’s body and given to another’s. Some organs like the kidney can be donated when people are still alive. However, an easy way for people to be an organ donor is to register for when they die. By donating organs when people die many lives can be saved. Everyone has the option to be one. Finally, all people should choose to be an organ donor when they die because it saves lives their family can be positively impacted, and medical advancements can be made.... [tags: Organ transplant, Organ donation, SAVE]
723 words (2.1 pages)
- The first successful organ donation was in the last 50 years (7), and since then institutions have set up many regulations and processes that have saved many lives by allowing people to donate their organs, but government policies in the United States have set up laws that prevents individuals to make choices about their own bodies. When a person is in need for an organ due to being extremely ill for having a failing organ, doctors assess whether or not that person is eligible for a transplant (7).... [tags: Organ donation, Organ transplant, Organ, Hospital]
1317 words (3.8 pages)
- Back in 1954 Dr. Joseph Murray and Dr. David Hume preformed the very first successful organ transplant that utilized a living donor ("History of Organ Donation & Transplants | New York Organ Donor Network," 2015). That miraculous event shows how far medical miracles have gone, and are continuously going. Organ transplants are permitting people to live longer and healthier lives. The only issue is that there is just not enough supply to meet the amount of demand. People should become organ donors, and be allowed to donate if they choose, because it can save lives and help to put an end the black market on organ sales.... [tags: Organ transplant, Organ donation]
1317 words (3.8 pages)
- The organ transplant list has grown to exceed 120,000 in the United States and continues to grow everyday (Organ Donation: is an opt-in or opt-out System Better). There is a growing demand for organs for people in need as eighteen people die everyday waiting for an organ transplant (organ donation: is an opt-in or opt-out system better). The US is looking for ways to increase the donation rate. One of the proposed ways to raise the donation rate is the opt-out or presumed consent option. The opt-out system is different than the opt-in system the United States currently uses where nobody is presumed an organ donor unless they specifically ask to be.... [tags: Organ transplant, Organ donation, Legal death]
1037 words (3 pages)
- I am an organ donor, are you. Organ donations can help many people around the world, all you have to do is tick a little box at your local Department of Motor Vehicles (D.M.V.). People do not ask to have organ failure, they just do. Who are we to deny someone else the chance to live, if all we have to do is just share our organs when we are finished with them, we can not take them with us so what are you going to do with them. Lives may come and go, but organs can be passed on to the next person in need.... [tags: Organ transplant, Organ donation, Legal death]
1177 words (3.4 pages)
- 18 year old, Domonique Smith, also called Nikki, was lying in an ICU hospital bed fighting her last battle. Before Nikki knew she wasn’t going to live much longer, she had a conversation with her mom, telling her she wanted to be an organ and tissue donor. Once Nikki passed away, her heart was transplanted into her life-long friend, Tanisha Basham, through a process called directed donation. Along with Tanisha, Nikki helped three other people, so she saved four people’s lives (Marketwire). According to Gift of Hope Organ and Tissue Donor Network, 2015 was a better year than any other for saving lives through organ and tissue donation.... [tags: Organ transplant, Organ donation, Heart, Organ]
1472 words (4.2 pages)