U2 vs Negativland: Copyright Law Violation? Essay

U2 vs Negativland: Copyright Law Violation? Essay

Length: 1690 words (4.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

I overturn the decision of the lower court that Negativland violated copyright law.
Although it may be perceived that music is a free market based on the love of music, others may argue it is based on profit. In the article “U2’s double trouble,” the band Negativland proclaims that Island Record’s, U2’s record label, only concern in the lawsuit is, “to control the marketplace” (139). Negativland believes Island is trying to control what music is being made and sold. Island is so focused on profit that they are limiting the musical market.
I agree with Negativland that Island Records is only concerned about the profits they would receive from controlling the market place. Music is created to induce emotion, not only to make money. Seeing as there are only so many ways an instrument can be played, it will not be long before songs will sound similar. The similarities between the two songs should flatter the original composer because their work has inspired a fellow artist to produce a similar sound. Composing and making music is a craft that should be shared and used to help influence or inspire other people, not for anyone person to control. As a result, the decision that Negativland violated copyright law should be overturned.
At first glance, it might not appear like it, but the lawsuit between the two bands is actually about censorship. In “U2 Negativland the Case From Our Side”, the band Negativland asserts that the song they created was, “a parody, satire, social commentary, and cultural criticism” (147). The band is expressing that their song is a work of art and has every right to be sold like U2’s song. In removing Negativland’s song, U2 and Island Records are censoring the public from hearing ...


... middle of paper ...


...vic sampled, copied, and created a parody from Michael Jackson’s song “Beat it”. Weird Al copied everything from Michael’s video including his hairstyle and the scenery throughout the video. However, even though the song “Eat it” was almost identical to the song “Beat it”, fans knew the difference between what was made by Michael and what was made by Weird Al. Negativland’s song has even less similarities with U2’s song than Weird Al’s song had with Michael Jackson’s. It is because of this that it can be assumed fans of U2 would be able to tell the difference between Negativland’s choppy, techno sampling style from U2’s heartfelt ballad.
Putting concrete limitations and rules on what an artist can and cannot use when expressing their opinion of another artist’s work is unconstitutional. If we put a price on the freedom of speech, we place a fine on our liberties.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Stealing The Hard Work Of Stars Essay

- ValadezGiovannysecondroughdraftWp4 Stealing the hard work of Stars "Hello" by Adele is a recent hit song widely heard and played since its release in October. Adele is known for her powerful voice and inspirational breakup songs. The songs that artists like Adele create are used to make a living. When people download illegal music online or use the music of other artists and not pay for the song, one is essentially stealing the artist 's hard work. In 1991, when the case of the music groups Negativland/U2 occurred, it was a chance for an artist to fight for what was theirs....   [tags: Copyright infringement, Copyright, Anti-copyright]

Powerful Essays
1601 words (4.6 pages)

Copyright Laws Are A Form Of Governance Essay

- Copyright laws are a form of governance designed to protect the intellectual property of authors, inventors, and other individuals creating innovations or inventions. Intellectual property consists of published and unpublished books, manuscripts, paintings, music works, sound recordings, movies, choreographic works, architectural works, sculptures, and even pantomime works among others (Copyright Works, 2012). The World Intellectual Property Organization states that: "Intellectual property (IP) refers to creations of the mind, such as inventions; literary and artistic works; designs; and symbols, names and images used in commerce" (What is Intellectual, n.d.)....   [tags: Copyright, Property, United States copyright law]

Powerful Essays
1050 words (3 pages)

Essay on Copyright And Copyright Of Intellectual Property

- Imagine if you will, you just finished reading an amazing article and want to share it with your colleagues, you copy a section and send it out in an email. Did you just commit copyright infringement. Did you just violate someone’s rights as the creator of that intellectual property. To better understand what copyright is you must first understand the difference between copyright, public domain and fair use. Another important aspect to the copyright debate is the definition of intellectual property....   [tags: Copyright, Trademark, Intellectual property]

Powerful Essays
1495 words (4.3 pages)

Copyright Law And Standards For Ensuring Compliance With Legal Obligations With Copyright Holders

- Both McCormick and the PPMI identify that staff and learners need education about copyright law and standards to ensure compliance with legal obligations and to protect copyright holders. Understanding the law enables users to make risk management decisions, as well as minimizing the impact they have on lawful activity. In my own setting, I believe that a number of ‘Landsdowne Road Agreement’ hours could be allocated to facilitate professional development courses for school employees regarding copyright legislation....   [tags: Copyright infringement, Copyright, Anti-copyright]

Powerful Essays
1360 words (3.9 pages)

Photo Sales and Copyright Law Essay

- Maybe there is a flaw in the photo industry itself. Is today's model of licensing and sales of photographs viable. How best to sell your photos. Will open resources photo stocks increase supply growth up until the number of pictures will not reach a level where photographers could not even very cheap to sell good photos and make money on those that sell. Theoretically, this horrible scenario is likely to become reality. Already Shutter stock alone offers more than 5 million photographs, which do not require payment of royalties, and, as stated CEO John Orangey, each month the number of new revenue in the millions....   [tags: Copyright]

Powerful Essays
1114 words (3.2 pages)

Copyright Law At National And International Levels Essay examples

- Introduction Intellectual property is the legal term for an idea or knowledge that has been expressed in tangible form. Copyright is a subset of intellectual property, providing the legal framework intended to protect a creator 's original ideas, theories and concepts. It permits the right to publish, copy, or reproduce any original literary, dramatic, musical, or artistic work. In return, creators of such works receive remuneration for, and protect the integrity of the works that they have created....   [tags: Copyright, Intellectual property, Statute of Anne]

Powerful Essays
1034 words (3 pages)

Essay about Copyright Law

- Introduction Just two decades ago, saying “copyright” to teachers most likely conjured images in their minds only of the fine-print notice in the front of a textbook. Today, with a world of Web 2.0 technology at their fingertips, copyright issues for teachers can be confusing and complex. Add to that an ever-increasing emphasis on technology literacy in our states’ education standards – forcing teachers to incorporate applications and resources that may be uncharted territory to them – and the waters get even murkier....   [tags: Ethics, Copyright Infringement]

Powerful Essays
990 words (2.8 pages)

Copyright Infringement And Fair Use Essay

- Copyright Infringement and Fair Use: Using Resources Legally to Further Knowledge Since the inception of the Internet, copyright laws have become unclear. Sharing material online has led to an unfortunate amount of piracy of copyrighted works, intentionally and unintentionally. Understanding how to navigate the murky waters of copyright infringement is essential, especially in the field of education. Teaching students to understand the difference between copyright infringement, and fair use can help to alleviate the adverse effects of copyright violations, which occur all too often in our society....   [tags: Copyright, Copyright infringement, Anti-copyright]

Powerful Essays
1597 words (4.6 pages)

Contract Law and Music Copyright Essay

- COURSEWORK FOR CONTRACT LAW (MUSIC*) *On what basis does the inclusion of samples of a recording made by *Pink Floyd constitute an infringement of copyright. In civil law regarding copyright, there are two types of infringement; primary and secondary. Primary is concerned with the unauthorised use of copyrighted works and secondary would involve the dealing or making commercial use of such infringing copies. In the music industry, an infringement of copyright often consists of an existing piece of music being used by an artist without permission from the person or company who own the rights to the original music or recorded sound....   [tags: Legal Law]

Powerful Essays
1677 words (4.8 pages)

Essay about Piracy Of Copyright

- Piracy Of Copyright Introduction: The world today has entered into an era of instant communication. A person sitting in the remotest corner of India can enjoy live performance taking place in the far away places like America or Africa, thanks to electronic (parallel) media. Telephone and fax have made it possible to communicate oral or written messages across the globe within seconds. The computer-aided communication technologies such as E-Mail and Internet have added altogether a new dimension to today's communication process by making it more speedy, informative and economical....   [tags: Copyright Laws Piracy]

Powerful Essays
1090 words (3.1 pages)