Trudeau’s Overreaction to the October Crisis in Quebec Essay

Trudeau’s Overreaction to the October Crisis in Quebec Essay

Length: 2274 words (6.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Throughout history, the actions of governments have always been debated; however, occasionally there are certain events which spark much controversy, both at the time of the event and by historians today. One of these controversial acts was the invocation of the War Measures Act in 1970, an act which suspended the civil liberties of Canadian citizens. In October 1970, in what became known as the October Crisis, the Front de libération du Québec, (commonly known as the FLQ) which was a French Canadian organization advocating independence from Canada, kidnapped two politicians. This initiated a series of events, one of which was the invocation of the War Measures Act by Prime Minister Pierre Elliot Trudeau. Many historians argue that Trudeau was justified in invoking the War Measures Act because the October Crisis ended shortly after the Act was invoked. However, this argument is invalid as justification; primarily because the War Measures Act was an extreme overreaction by Trudeau, as the threat of the FLQ was largely small-scale, and the demise of the FLQ was impending with the rise of the Bloc Quebecois. Furthermore, the Act may have inspired Quebecers who favoured separatism, as they saw the government desperately employ the most extreme measure to stop the FLQ. Finally, the War Measures Act suspended the civil rights of citizens within a democracy, violating the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

The Front de libération du Québec was founded in 1963 during the “Quiet Revolution”, and for seven years, they carried out several minor bombings, with few FLQ members involved in each of the bombings, as they were relatively small scale. However, the Canadian government took little notice of these actions until Oct...

... middle of paper ...

...e to power in Quebec. This indicates that Quebecers supported non-violent methods in order to achieve independence for Quebec, rather than the violent methods of the FLQ, also indicating that the efforts of the FLQ would have been subdued by the Parti Quebecois. The death of Pierre Laporte was another unfortunate occurrence as a result of the War Measures Act which could have been avoided, yet some still believe his death is not related to the invocation of the War Measures Act. Justification is required for all actions which spark debate, and in events where the justification is provided under false pretences, someone must be held responsible. In this case it remains the Trudeau government. Trudeau may have had an admirable political career in which he made many wise decisions, however, the invocation of the War Measures Act in October 1970 was not one of them.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Nationalism in The Trudeau Era Essay

- The argument: No. We are not anti-American; we have always been nationalists with contradictions throughout. We carry contradictions in us; we can be nationalists and North Americans at the same time. Canadians are sceptical about the United States, yet at the same time we admire, are dependent upon, and want to compete with the Americans. When the United States flexes their muscles, claws at our existence, or when we are sceptical of their policies, we become nationalists seeking to protect our national interest....   [tags: The Trudeau, Canada, United States]

Powerful Essays
1294 words (3.7 pages)

The Trudeau And The Canadian Government Essays

- For the Trudeau government one of the biggest, if not the biggest, provincial priority for the federal government was the issue of Quebec sovereignty. This becomes readily apparent in Peter Gossage and J.I. Little 's An Illustrated History of Quebec and while it focuses on Quebec provincial history from a Quebec perspective, Gossage and Little, describe the relations between the provincial Quebec government, under Premiers Jean-Jacques Bertrand and Robert Bourassa, and Trudeau. Gossage and Little point out as well that despite the fact that Quebec had a larger, and more urban, population than the prairie provinces, the fact that Trudeau himself was from, and educated in, Montreal, meant that...   [tags: Quebec, Canada, René Lévesque, Pierre Trudeau]

Powerful Essays
841 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on The Trudeau Vs. Trudeau Government

- With all things in life there is a simple truth of do what you believe and say what you want. In essence that can be reduced to as talk is cheap and with the Trudeau government talk is not only cheap but also on discount. As a whole the Liberal government has spent most of their time in office contradicting what they had said with their actions. Therefore the Trudeau government makes a mockery of Aucoin because of their habit to claim improvement, but through their actions cause harm to Canada. Like his father, Pierre Trudeau, Justin Trudeau has an agenda based on his own ideals and that of his companions that will be pushed regardless of the results it may have on the rest of Canada....   [tags: Canada, Pierre Trudeau, Liberal Party of Canada]

Powerful Essays
1107 words (3.2 pages)

The October Crisis: Do You Have a Permit for That Freedom? Essay

- The purpose of government is to create peace and order to maintain a functioning society. Legislation from the federal government of Canada is to do exactly that, but at what point does the law over state its presence and harm the people it attempts to protect. The October Crisis that occurred in 1970 under the Trudeau government is one such contentious issue: while it may have been supported by some it was highly criticized for damaging human rights in a democratic society. Essentially martial law was produced and the effects of the October Crisis caused a developed nation to take a step backward in their work to create and maintain a safe, functioning democratic state: a democratic state b...   [tags: canada, government, legislation, decision]

Powerful Essays
2627 words (7.5 pages)

Jean Trudeau And The Liberal Idea Of Canada Essay examples

- In his memoirs, published in 1993 and only two years before the second referendum in 1995, Trudeau states: "Separatism died in 1976, but its funeral was the referendum of 1980." This would come to be reflective of many Trudeau 's policies; where he would implement them based on ideology, be faced with public backlash, and then be forced to revise his policies based on pragmatism. This mixture of ideology and pragmatism is also reflected James and Robert Laxer 's, The Liberal Idea of Canada. This work was written during Pierre Trudeau 's second term in 1977, the Laxers ' focus less on Trudeau and more on the federal Liberal Party....   [tags: Canada, Quebec, Pierre Trudeau]

Powerful Essays
903 words (2.6 pages)

The Independence Of Quebec And Quebec Essay

- Other Quebec nationalists looking to instigate a separate nation of Quebec instead chose to take a more radical approach to the cultural debate. One famous group was the Front de Liberation du Quebec, also known as the FLQ . The FLQ first emerged in 1970, and quickly entered the national spotlight with a series of terrorist attacks in hopes of rallying the people of Quebec. Instead, their actions created a state of terror and panic with the people of Quebec and English Canada instead viewing them as a threat....   [tags: Canada, Quebec, Pierre Trudeau, October Crisis]

Powerful Essays
1016 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about Trudeau’s Imposition of the WMA in Canada

- ... The manifesto stated that there are “100,000 revolutionary workers, armed and organized. ” This statement was one of the major factors in the implementation of the WMA. This is because the high number stated by the FLQ caused anxiety in Canadians especially the police as they were uncertain the number was accurate. The chief of the Montreal police, Marcel Saint-Aubin, stated that, the police of Montreal could not handle maintain peace and order in Quebec as well as so investigations regarding the FLQ....   [tags: quebec, freedom, security]

Powerful Essays
1279 words (3.7 pages)

The Cuban Missile Crisis Essay

- ... Neither man was irrational enough to desire an all-out nuclear war. The Cuban Missile Crisis was the hottest moment of the Cold War. The complexity of Crisis makes the subject difficult to discuss and analyze without leaving out major milestones crucial to the story. I found it to be most beneficial to the telling of the story to focus on a particular day of the Crisis and thoroughly analyze the events of the day and its relevance to the debacle as a whole. The climax of the crisis arrived on Saturday October 27th....   [tags: USSR-US relations in October 1962]

Powerful Essays
2016 words (5.8 pages)

Essay about Pierre Elliott Trudeau

- Unlike the United States, with its generalissimo politics-Washington, Jackson, Grant, Eisehower- the martial arts have been conspicuously absent from Canadian politics. But there in one exception: in 1968 Pierre Elliot Trudeau became the first Canadian leader to bring the gunslinger-Lone Ranger ethos to Canadian politics. Trudeau introduced to Canada the refined art of single combat; it was the politics of "Doing It My Way"-the politics of going my way or being left behind. Single-combat confrontation implied much mor than the loner or renegade in power, and far far less than the shaman black tricks of Mackenzie King....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1537 words (4.4 pages)

October Essay

- October Jennifer stopped running through the forest after doing so for what seemed like eternity. She had no idea where she was, why she was here, or who was chasing her. All she knew was that running for so long of a time made her very hungry. Desperately, she looked around for something to eat, and her eyes settled on a tall apple tree. Jennifer picked a couple and ate them as she leaned against a maple tree while watching mother nature take its course. She could see the sun was setting through the bright red leaves of the forest trees....   [tags: Creative Writing Essays]

Free Essays
1312 words (3.7 pages)