Alternative Treatments to the Classical Alcoholics Anonymous Abstinence Approach are More Effective for Treating Individuals Convicted for an Alcohol Related Crime
In this paper I am going to discuss the extreme importance of finding a variety of effective treatments for individuals with an alcohol problem. My focus will be on offenders that committed a violent crime under the influence of alcohol. I will focus on the importance for society to treat these individuals effectively and describe and compare different treatment approaches to the classical Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) treatment. Furthermore I will evaluate in how far this treatments are more appropriate for treating these individuals. To address this topic I suggest that alternative treatments to the classical AA abstinence approach are more effective for treating convicts that are sentenced for an alcohol related crime.
Alcohol abuse is related to several violent behaviours like homicide, suicide, sexual violence, and partner abuse (Buddie, 2004). The costs related to alcohol related disorder and crime amounts to 7.3 billion pounds only in England and Wales each year (controlled drinking goals for offenders).
Despite of this striking evidence alcohol treatment methods are still extremely underprovided, especially for offenders. In UK prisons probation services have been found to have a “significant lack of provision” for treating inmates with alcohol problems. (Treating Alcohol-Related Violence Intermediate Outcomes in a Feasibility Study for a Randomized Controlled Trial in Prisons).
AA abstinence approach:
The most common and accessible intervention at the moment is the Alcoholics Anonymous treatment which has several downsides, especially in r...
... middle of paper ...
...r kind of intervention that does not require them to stay completely away from alcohol, but teaches them responsible and moderate drinking behaviour. It is especially important to find a combination of alcohol based interventions that also involve reducing aggression and violence. The safest conclusion is to say, that a one size fits all treatment is unrealistic because of the big variety between individuals. Therefore it is necessary to also find a large variety of treatments that are suitable to each individual and their own drinking behaviour. To come back to my initial thesis statement I think that I gave convincing arguments for it but it is probably not possible to see it that black- and white because people differ in their attitudes and drinking patterns so for some of individuals the AA abstinence approach does work best, but definitely not for everybody.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- As humans, we all yearn to be free, yet we are trapped by expectations, responsibilities and standards placed upon us by the modern world. Alcohol creates freedom and vulnerability for individuals oppressed by the dynamics and speed of everyday life especially in very developed ‘high class’ nations. Alcohol particularly creates this freedom for individuals in disenfranchised populations, where expectations from a foreign “sophisticated” ideology overwhelm the people of the once free nations. And because alcohol creates a free and youthful state of mind, it becomes fetishized.... [tags: Alcohol ]
2159 words (6.2 pages)
- ... While alcohol is consumed responsibly by some there are still many who drink excessively and for that reason alcohol related problems are widespread In England and Wales. The pros and cons of alcohol consumption Pros The benefits of alcohol come from reasonable drinking, and most of the risks come from extreme consumption of alcohol. Even though reasonable drinking can contribute to certain cancers and other health related issues the risks are often more important than the benefits for people at high risk of those malignancies and for that reason moderate drinking can cause more harm than good when lead to excessive consumption.... [tags: liver diseases, behavior]
1757 words (5 pages)
- There have been negative views associated with drinking alcohol such as the negative consequences individuals may experience, which range from long term health problems for example: liver disease and strokes, to short term social problems such as anti-social and deviant behaviour and more prominently crime. The Criminal Justice Act 1967, s.91(1) states [Any] person who in any public place is guilty, while drunk, of disorderly behaviour is guilty of an offence. The Licensing Act 1872, s.12 states that it is an offence to be ‘found drunk in any highway or other public place, whether a building or not, or on any licensed premises.... [tags: health, crime, violence]
1655 words (4.7 pages)
- White-collar crime, specifically computer crime, is becoming more popular as computers become more readily available. Crimes using computers and crimes against computers are usually committed without fear of being caught, due to the detachment of the offender from the victim. Computer crime is defined as, “Criminal activity directly related to the use of computers, specifically illegal trespass into the computer system or database of another, manipulation or theft of stored or on-line data, or sabotage of equipment and data.”(1).... [tags: Internet Crime Essays]
2353 words (6.7 pages)
- Alcohol Addiction Treatment/Prevention In 2010, a total of 25,692 people died of alcohol-induced causes in the U.S.; dependent and non-dependent use. The death rate for alcohol-induced causes for the total population increased from 2.7% from 7.4 in 2009 and 7.6 in 2010. The adjusted death rate for males in 2010 was three times the rate of females, (Murphy, 2010). An estimated 23.5 million age 12 and older needed treatment for an illicit drug or alcohol abuse problem in 2009 according to The National Institute on Drug Abuse.... [tags: substance abuse, alcoholism]
813 words (2.3 pages)
- PROHIBITION IN AMERICA The Rights of Individuals vs. the Responsibilities of a Nation "The 18th Amendment to the United States Constitution prohibited the manufacture, sale, transport, import, or export of alcoholic beverages” . This historical, yet short era, known as “Prohibition”, set an example that is still referred to today. As people scrambled all around the country trying to illegally obtain alcohol, the country was once again in a state of chaos. As part of a Christian based temperance movement, prohibition began as an effort to limit the consumption of alcohol and other intoxicating substances for the betterment of the country.... [tags: alcoholic beverages, american culture, laws]
1603 words (4.6 pages)
- Approaches to crime prevention have emerged over time and are demonstrated in different solutions, practices, and policies executed by law enforcement, courts, corrections, family, and community. Some of the dominant approaches to crime prevention currently used by law enforcement, courts, corrections, family, and community are: situational crime prevention, crime prevention through social development, crime prevention through environmental design, community crime prevention, reduction of recidivism, and policing.... [tags: Law Enforcement, Communications Strategy]
1659 words (4.7 pages)
- What Alcoholism & Alcohol Abuse is all about. Alcoholism is a very serious disease, which can cause illness, death, injuries, schooling problems, family breakups, and crime. It is a proven fact the alcohol kills more people than any other illegal drugs combined. Yet alcohol courses freely through American society, from college bars to corporate lunches. In a recent article from a journal named: The Scientist it is stated "Technology shows alcohol abuse changes brain's molecular programming and circuitry." Alcohol is a quick fix that will hurt us all in the long run.... [tags: Papers]
852 words (2.4 pages)
- Alcohol and Drug Abuse Alcohol and drug abuse is one of biggest problems in United States today. It is not only a personal problem that dramatically affects individuals' lives, but is a major social problem that affects society as whole. "Drug and alcohol abuse", these phrases we hear daily on the radio, television or in discussions of social problem. But what do they mean or what do we think and understand by it. Most of us don't really view drug or alcohol use as a problem, if that includes your grandmother taking two aspirins when she has a headache or your friends having few beers or drinks on Saturday night.... [tags: Drug Abuse, Substance Abuse]
1345 words (3.8 pages)
- The Government's Fight Against Crime “The planned introduction of identity cards proves, if further proof be needed, that this government is committed to the crime control model of criminal justice” In every nation the authority and dedication of the government towards doing its work is challenged again and again.... [tags: Papers]
1045 words (3 pages)