Towards a Methatheory of Budgeting Essay

Towards a Methatheory of Budgeting Essay

Length: 1134 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Top-down budgeting is listed in Towards a Metatheory of Budgeting as a normative theory of budgeting. Normative theories are defined as complete theories of budgeting that incorporate the budget, appropriations, preparation, and decision events. Normative theories are not intended to describe what occurs in the budgeting process but prescribe considerations for future implementation as a best practice (Williams & Calabrese, 2011). However, with the evolution of organizational complexity, top-down budgeting has become a positive theory. Positive theories explain an observation of the budgeting process and attempt to analyze why that behavior exists as an aspect of organizational culture (Williams & Calabrese, 2011). Top-down budgeting is not a desired best practice and therefore not a normative theory, because the methodology does not include key stakeholders in decision making. Top-down budgeting is used as a way to save time, centralize decision making, and limit the amount of controls given to lower levels of the organization. As organizations become flatter and remove excessive layers of management to become more nimble, the centralization of budget decisions has evolved (George, 2012). The traditional top-down budgeting approach is dated. Under the category of positive theory, top-down budgeting is a descriptive theory that explains an aspect of the budgeting process. It is an observation of practice. In an evolved definition, decisions from leadership are not the end of a process. Instead, they are a factor considered in the decisions for a final budget and department goals.
Top-down budgeting is also explanatory, as there is a description to how and why the budgetary behavior exists. According to Business Knowledge Source, ...


... middle of paper ...


...g - An Instrument to Strengthen Budget Management* | ASIP Asociación Internacional de Presupuesto Público. Retrieved January 19, 2014, from http://www.asip.org.ar/en/content/top-down-budgeting-instrument-strengthen-budget-management

National Priorities Project. (n.d.). National Priorities Project. Retrieved February 27, 2014, from
http://nationalpriorities.org/budget-basics/federal-budget-101/federal-budget-process/

Ryan, P. (2011, December 7). A Brief History of Budgeting in the Nation's Capital. The Federal
Budget Process. Retrieved February 25, 2014, from http://budget.house.gov/uploaded files/bphr

Kavanagh, S. C. (2011). Zero Base Budgeting Modern Experiences and Current Perspectives.
Chicago, Illinois: Government Finance Officers Association.

Williams, D., & Calabrese, T. (2013). Towards a Metatheory of Budgeting. Economists
International , 1, 178-207.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Description Of The Line Item Budgeting

- Line-item Budgeting Line item budgeting categorizes various expenses and places them in list format on a document for budgetary purposes. This type of budgeting is considered the heartbeat of budgeting due to the systematic method by which it controls revenue and expenses, this is made evident when Tyer and Willand (1992), pointed out “Statutory or administrative controls could be imposed on the transfer of funds from one-line item to another, or between broad categories of expenditure.” According to Schick (1971), “line item budgets were attractive to legislative officials because they did not focus explicit attention on substantive policy issues or choices.” Advantages/Disadvantages An...   [tags: Budget, Budgets, Zero-based budgeting]

Strong Essays
840 words (2.4 pages)

The Fundamentals Of Capital Budgeting Essay example

- Chapter 10 focuses on the fundamentals of capital budgeting and why these decisions are the most important investment decisions made by the firm. The overall goal of capital budgeting decisions is to increase the value of the firm. With this objective, the financial department must strategically select which investments will create the most value for the firm. These capital investments are essentially the primary source of revenue generation for firms. These capital investments are essentially investment projects with three different classifications: independent, mutually exclusive, and contingent projects....   [tags: Net present value, Investment, Capital budgeting]

Strong Essays
701 words (2 pages)

The Advantages and Disadvantages of Budgeting as a System of Organisational Control

- The Advantages and Disadvantages of Budgeting as a System of Organisational Control A budget is a short-term financial plan of income and expenses expected over a certain period of time (usually one year) used to achieve a businesses objective. Budgeting can be useful for exercising control over a business because of its nature as a representation of a plan. Control is generally viewed as making events conform to a plan. As a budget is represented as a plan, allowing events to conform to it seems to be an obvious way to try and control the business....   [tags: Budgeting Budget Planning Organization]

Strong Essays
1978 words (5.7 pages)

Essay on Performance Budgeting

- This paper examines the benefit of performance based budgeting as a practical theory of efficiency for government programming. Confronted by fiscal limitation and demand for improved public services, government agencies are utilizing the budget as a means to elevate government accountability and efficiency, rather than simply as a means for distributing funds and controlling expenses. Performance based budgeting has been defined as a system wherein managers are provided with the flexibility to utilize agency resources as required, in return for their commitment to achieve certain performance results....   [tags: American Government, Budgeting Initiatives]

Free Essays
617 words (1.8 pages)

A Budgeting Guide for Local Government: The City of Rock Hill Budgetary Funds

- The City of Rock Hill has multiple budgetary funds. They have reported up to nine individual governmental funds, which include General Fund, SW TIF Fund, Street Bond Fund, and Capital Projects Fund (City of Rock Hill 2013, 6). The city also maintains other funds that are combined into one single fund called “other governmental funds,” which makes it easier to budget (City of Rock Hill 2013, 6). Within the other governmental fund category are the Police Training Fund, Asset Forfeiture Fund, Sewer Lateral Fund, McKnight Crossing TIF Fund, and the NW TIF Fund (City of Rock Hill 2013, 51)....   [tags: performance budgeting, general funds]

Strong Essays
2389 words (6.8 pages)

A Line Item Budget Is The Most Simplistic And Common Budgeting System Used By Organizations

- A line item budget is often referred to as the most simplistic and common budgeting system used by organizations. A line item budget is a budget that contains line items of expenditures for analysis, authorization, and control. A line item budget usually contain expenditures such as office supplies, salaries, travel and utilities (Mckinney,2015). Line item budgeting is designed to simplify an organizations spending. It shortens the budgetary planning process because it is builds upon the organizations preceding fiscal budget....   [tags: Budget, Budgets, Zero-based budgeting, Management]

Strong Essays
1122 words (3.2 pages)

Incremental Budgeting Essay examples

- The purpose of this essay is to evaluate how “Incremental budgeting is still the most popular form of budgeting because it works”. Firstly, this essay will explain the different types of budgeting. Secondly, the essay will compare and contrast incremental budgeting to zero-based budgeting (ZBB) and rolling budgeting. Finally, this essay will conclude to say where incremental budgeting is not the most popular form of budgeting. Incremental budgeting is a traditional way of budgeting. It is budgeting process that uses previous year’s budget or the actual performance, which incremental amounts are added or subtracted to the new budgeting period....   [tags: Economics]

Strong Essays
1437 words (4.1 pages)

Budgeting Essay

- Budgeting Budgeting is the systematic method of allocating financial, physical, and human resources to achieve an organization’s strategic goals. Budgets are utilized by for-profit and non-profit organizations to monitor the progress towards the goals, assist in the control of spending, and help predict cash flow for the organization. The central challenge that budget developers encounter is predicting what the future holds for the internal business and external factors. Reading the future is something that can never be done with perfect precision....   [tags: Finances Accounting Budgets Essays]

Strong Essays
3561 words (10.2 pages)

Budgeting Essay

- Budgeting Properly focusing the planning process on the organizations' strengths and weaknesses will help the organization to achieve its strategic and financial goals. A critical part of this strategy includes the budgeting process. According to the text "A budget quantifies future financial plans and budgeting is the process of planning, in financial terms, the organization's activities and the results of those activities" (Marshall 2004). Some of the purposes of budgeting include helping to plan work effectively, assisting in allocating resources, and aiding in controlling resources during the budgeting period....   [tags: Business Analysis Budget Strategy]

Free Essays
1392 words (4 pages)

Essay Budgeting

- Budgeting Some businesses turn deaf ears when it comes to the issue of "budgeting." Businesses have made significant break through in the areas of sales and marketing, but they have not succeeded in the area of budgeting. Budgeting is more important today in businesses than ever before. Competition is intensifying and take-overs are becoming very common. The winners in this type of business environment will be those organisations that minimize wasteful spending and maximize the productivity of their resources....   [tags: Business Accounting]

Free Essays
1868 words (5.3 pages)