Essay To Show or Not to Show?...That Is The Question

Essay To Show or Not to Show?...That Is The Question

Length: 948 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

When showing a movie that is based on a piece of literature to high school students, the person showing the movie should take in consideration of several aspects that affect the student. If the movie does more harm than good, it should not be shown for the good of the student. These aspects must be acknowledged especially when deciding if the 2007 movie version of Beowulf is acceptable to show to East Juniata high school seniors. Mr. Benner should not show this to the high school seniors because it does not follow the plot line as close as possible, parts of the movie can disgust some of the students, and it is possible that the movie could deride the actual poem.
Every movie director does have the poetic license when reviving a newer version of a piece of literature, however, what the director does in this movie is far from that. Not only has the director, Robert Zemeckis, made the usual subtle changes we expect when literature is adapted to film, but the plot and character descriptions also has been altered significantly. Grendel is not Hrothgar's child nor is the dragon is not some malignant offspring of Beowulf and Grendel's mother, both portrayed this way in the movie. In the actual poem, Grendel is described as being a descendent of Cain, the first murderer, cursed by God. He is the embodiment of evil and darkness. The dragon becomes angered when a thief steals from his treasure hoard. He seeks revenge on the Geatish people - Beowulf's subjects - and causes Beowulf to take his men to the dragon's cave for his final battle. Having Angelina Jolie portray Grendel's mom in the movie was not the best casting for this part. Grendel’s mother takes the form of a gorgeous woman who emerges dripping wet and naked from the water....


... middle of paper ...


...le, the movie can offend some of the students, and it is possible that the movie could be ridiculing the actual poem. Because of these factors, it distorts the seniors’ perspectives of what Beowulf’s true story line is. Students are not likely to go and research what Beowulf is about due to how they view this movie, which, in turns, restrains their views on epic poetry now and maybe even in the future.


Works Cited

"Beowulf (2007)." Box Office Mojo. IMDB Co. Web. 17 Feb. 2011. .
"Maturity (psychological)." Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia. 2 Feb. 2011. Web. 15 Feb. 2011. .
"Satire | Define Satire at Dictionary.com." Dictionary.com | Free Online Dictionary for English Definitions. Web. 15 Feb. 2011. .

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Analysis Of The Movie ' The Truman Show ' Essay

- The Truman Show engenders question on the authenticity of behavior and virtue in the face of pervasive voyeurism(which I will refer to in an exclusively non sexual manner). The Truman Show expostulates that an unaware participant in this perverted voyeurism, no matter the level of cognizant awareness, is still inauthentic because of the pervasive manipulation by Cristof and his cronies and the willing deception by Truman Show 's costars. These factors engender a contrived scenario that forces Truman to act in an expected manner—rather than natural--much like the intrusive Mr....   [tags: Reality television, The Truman Show]

Better Essays
2280 words (6.5 pages)

Reality and the Movie "The Truman Show" Essay

- The reality of the world and the truth of it is questioned everyday, especially when something goes wrong. This is shown in the Truman show, when Truman finally starts to question the reality of the world and the truth of the people that surrounds him. So we need to ask to following questions to understand what the film is essentially about. Firstly, do we agree with the statement- We accept the reality of the world which we are presented. Secondly, what messages is the director trying to give us about modern society....   [tags: Truman Show, reality, ]

Better Essays
1041 words (3 pages)

Essay on The Truman Show : An Unusual Type Of Reality Television Show

- The Truman Show, starring Jim Carey, is a movie about an unusual type of reality television show starring a Truman Burbank in a 14 hour a day television show that is all about his life. The show began when Truman Burbank was born and has been running for almost 30 years. Truman has spent his entire life in a large dome that is made to look like the real world, including weather, sky, stars, a sea, and his hometown, Seahaven. The town is equipped with 5,000 cameras so that Truman will always be seen on the TV show “The Truman Show” at any time of the day from inside his home to anywhere in town....   [tags: Reality television, The Truman Show, Television]

Better Essays
1556 words (4.4 pages)

Essay on The First Open Ended Question

- The first open-ended question revolved around fractions. In particular, this question aligns with the Australian Curriculum Year 4 content descriptor ‘ACMNA077: Investigate equivalent fractions used in contexts’, under the ‘Fractions and Decimals’ section of the ‘Number and Algebra’ strand (Australian Curriculum and Assessment Reporting Authority [ACARA], 2014). The question involves creating fractions based on slices of a pizza. With all the fractions being out of twelve, Emma had the opportunity to think of multiple answers....   [tags: Question, Answer, Writing, Interrogative word]

Better Essays
1030 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about Analysis Of Truman 's ' The Truman Show '

- 2762462 Cheryl King English 1301 August 7, 2015 The Truman Show He’s unaware of it, but Truman 's entire life is part of an enormous TV show. Executive producer Christof coordinates The Truman Show, a televised show of Truman’s life shot by secret cameras hidden everywhere in the town. Christof attempts to control Truman’s life, even making his love, Sylvia, disappear from the show and replacing her with Meryl. Truman is honest, and innocent which made him locked behind a life of repetition. In his rebellion of his normal routine he notice that the whole town revolves around his life....   [tags: The Truman Show, Peter Weir, Andrew Niccol]

Better Essays
835 words (2.4 pages)

Allegory and Truman Show Essay

- Allegory and Truman Show The Allegory of the Cave has many parallels with The Truman Show. Initially, Truman is trapped in his own “cave”; a film set or fictional island known as Seahaven. Truman’s journey or ascension into the real world and into knowledge is similar to that of Plato’s cave dweller. In this paper, I will discuss these similarities along with the very intent of both of these works whose purpose is for us to question our own reality. In his Allegory Plato shows us how a man ascends from the darkness of a cave to the light of the outside world....   [tags: Allegory Cave Truman Show Essays]

Better Essays
780 words (2.2 pages)

Examples Of The Reality In The Truman Show Essay

- Truman Show VS. Reality The film “The Truman Show”, centers on the life of Truman Burbank, an insurance salesman, who unknowingly is the star of the most popular live show in television history. At birth, Truman is legally adopted by a major television network to be the unknowing star of a live television series, that follows his 24 hour everyday, since he was born, that is watched by an audience of millions all around the world, through a mass amount of hidden cameras. Christof, the main figure behind the concept of the Truman Show, constructs an artificial world, called Seahaven, around Truman, but in reality is just an extremely large television set....   [tags: The Truman Show, Metaphysics, Reality]

Better Essays
1188 words (3.4 pages)

Essay about Truman 's The Truman Show

- How Philosophy Relates to “The Truman Show” Truman, the main character of “The Truman Show” exists on the set of a television show, where he has existed his entire life, starring himself as the main character. Truman believes that he is simply leading a normal life, because the director and all of the actors on the show work hard to make it seem like reality, to make the show as realistic as possible to fool Truman. However, certain events start taking place which causes Truman to question his reality....   [tags: Reality television, The Truman Show, Television]

Better Essays
787 words (2.2 pages)

Breaking Bad: How the Show Deals with Gender and Violence Essay

- In many ways the inception of the television has been a growing phenomenon in our history, cultivating many moments that changed the view of how we preserve what influences us and how we become who we are. The television has since become so important in people’s lives showcasing films, news, shows, commercials, etc. estimating a whopping 96% universal presence in U.S. households (David Croteau, 2014) one can wonder if what is shown in television is a product of the environment or the product of the viewer....   [tags: popular television show analysis]

Better Essays
1213 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on The Urban Question

- In Urban Studies two schools of academic thought answer the “urban question”: the ecological and urban political economy schools. Because the “urban question” allows us to ask how we can address and understand urban inequalities in American cities, I will argue that to fully grasp the “urban question” one should take a perspective that composition of society and space as mutual. First, I will develop a working definition of “the urban question”. Second, I will write on the ecological school’s view of the “urban” question and how their vista explains but inadequately addresses urban inequalities....   [tags: Politics, Social Issues, Informative]

Better Essays
2129 words (6.1 pages)