Health care and what people are legally allowed to do with their bodies have created controversy galore throughout history. A particular point of debate is the topic of birth control and the government. A dangerous couple, it raises the question of who should have control over contraceptive laws and what controls involving them should be put in place? Currently, under the Obama Administration, the Affordable Care Act and “Obamacare” have been created. One of the sections of this new plan creates a mandate which requires private businesses to provide insurance that covers birth control costs. The government should not be able to force businesses, and therefore the American people, to pay for birth control via health insurance because it violates the First Amendment and would create a financial burden for an already struggling country.
The Constitution states that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…” (U.S. Const, Amend I). While forcing businesses to provide birth control is not a direct violation of this part of the First Amendment, it is still a violation. Religious freedom is not limited to churches, mosques or other religious organizations, nor is it limited to acts of worship (Rivkin and Wheland). Therefore it seems fitting that corporations should be able to live out their beliefs on contraceptives. Another piece of legislation that this violates is the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. The goal of this act was to protect against government actions that would target or burden religious activities or practices (Rivkin and Wheland). It is clear that forcing businesses to cover something tha...
... middle of paper ...
Howell, Tom, Jr. "Supreme Court to Decide Obamacare Birth Control Mandate." The Washington Times. Washington Times, 26 Nov. 2013. Web. 1 Jan. 2014.
Matthews, Merrill. "The Government on Birth Control." Forbes. Forbes.com, 4 Aug. 2011. Web. 1 Jan. 2014.
Rivkin, David B., Jr., and Edward Whelan. "Birth-Control Mandate: Unconstitutional and Illegal." Wall Street Journal (2013): n. pag. Web. 1 Jan. 2014.
Weigel, George. "The Mandate War." National Review 21 May 2012: n. pag. Ethics and Public Policy Center. Web. 1 Jan. 2014.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Stating the obvious, no one can choose the gender they are born with. It is possible to change genders through extensive surgery once you are older, but you cannot choose how you are born. Maybe one day there will be the technology and science that provides that possibility, but today it does not exist. It is no new topic, but government mandated health care is something to be addressed. Though people’s opinions go back and forth and there is no leading side, many people have heard of the topic of government mandated birth control.... [tags: Birth control, Pregnancy, Sexual intercourse]
919 words (2.6 pages)
- Health care and what people are legally allowed to do with their bodies have created controversy galore throughout history. A particular point of debate is the topic of birth control and the government. A dangerous couple, it raises the question of who should have control over contraceptive laws and what controls involving them should be put in place. Currently, under the Obama Administration, the Affordable Care Act and “Obamacare” have been created. One of the sections of this new plan creates a mandate which requires private businesses to provide insurance that covers birth control costs.... [tags: health issues, obamacare]
1080 words (3.1 pages)
- There is a war waging right now. Not just a military expose of hand to hand combat like that going on overseas, but also within our own democracy. It was made even more famous when eminent political talk show host Rush Limbaugh scrutinized and very publically humiliated a Georgetown student due to their very different viewpoints on birth control. It’s an issue that since its birth several decades ago, and has caused countless debates among religious entities, politicians, families, and physicians.... [tags: Contraceptives, Birth Control Essays]
1942 words (5.5 pages)
- Contrary to popular belief, the notion of “birth control” has been around for centuries, going back to the days of Aristotle who is thought to be the first person use different herbs and oils as spermicides (www.pbs.org). In an age where pregnancy prevention and contraception is extremely prevalent, it is interesting to think of a time where it was just as prevalent, but preformed without the medicines and modes of contraception we use today. Despite the history that surrounds the controversy of “birth control,” which is still relevant to this very day, the amount of women who partake in contraceptives is astounding.... [tags: Contraceptives, Birth Control Essays]
1229 words (3.5 pages)
- Today we have one of the biggest debates going on in America. The debate is whether teenagers should or should not have a prescription to get birth control. This debate can go either way. I believe they should not need a prescription to receive birth control because of three things: how it effects the woman and her body, pregnancy rate, and the government. Birth control is very common in our world especially in this day and age, but did you know that doctors and physicians say it is safe enough for a woman to take without having a prescription.... [tags: Birth control, Pregnancy]
731 words (2.1 pages)
- 1946 saw the birth of the Baby Boom era with more than 3.8 million babies born in that year alone.The baby boom lasted until 1964, when we saw a drastic decrease in births. This sudden and very beneficial decline could in part be attributed to the availability of birth control. Birth control, otherwise known as “contraceptives,” are very useful to many women (62%). While birth control is seen by many as a great advantage, those who disagree with it still view contraceptives as taboo or a violation of a sacred right.... [tags: Abortion, Birth control, Pregnancy]
1778 words (5.1 pages)
- The universal availability of a broad variety of birth control options has important effects on public health practice. There is controversy about insurance payments. In the situation, contraceptives for women will be covered including, screening for diabetes, counseling about sexually transmitted diseases and breastfeeding support. Insurance will not cover contraceptives for men, though. These preventive services apply for women only. Many feel that it is unfair that insured women may receive free contraceptives because they felt as if it was sex discrimination.... [tags: Pregnancy, Birth control, Abortion]
1930 words (5.5 pages)
- Contraceptive techniques have been traced back to Ancient Egypt, Greece and Rome. The modern movement of birth control began in Great Britain where the writings of Thomas Robert Malthus stirred interest in the problem of overpopulation. The first birth control was founded in 1878 in Amsterdam by a woman called Aletta Jacobs. Aletta and Margaret Sanger were advocates of birth control so they were trying to develop clinics and promote birth control. In 1914, Margaret Sanger was arrested for publishing information about birth control in her magazine Women Rebel.... [tags: Contraceptives, Birth Control Essays]
1473 words (4.2 pages)
- The aspect of sex and the use of birth control were touchy issues in the early 20th century. Sex was only for married couples that wanted to have children. The idea of sex before marriage was crazy. Because of all the beliefs about sex being only for procreation and not for pleasure birth control was not needed. There was one major event and one key person who are responsible for making the use of birth control acceptable in America. The major event being World War I. In World War I there was a lot of usage of whore houses by the French and English soldiers.... [tags: Contraceptives, Birth Control Essays]
1637 words (4.7 pages)
- Some believe contraceptives should be available at cost to those who can afford them, available to legal adults who cannot, and/or available to students through public schools. Some religious traditions, based on their view of reproduction, oppose birth control availability for everyone. There are religious traditions that oppose women's autonomy, and as such, are especially opposed to contraceptives for women. Some who oppose sex outside of marriage believe that distribution of condoms in schools encourages adolescent sexual activity.... [tags: Contraceptives, Birth Control Essays]
350 words (1 pages)