Essay PreviewMore ↓
Michael Hyde’s (1993) essay about the publication of “It’s over Debbie” in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) describes a doctor committing a form of “direct intervention” euthanasia. The account of the doctor’s patient assessment followed by the euthanasia caused “intense media coverage” that led to lawsuits about the doctor’s identity (Hyde, 1993, p. 595). The text contains brisk elements and details that summarize the patient and “cuts like a scalpel through the personhood, the life and times, of a patient” (Hyde, 1993, p. 601). This controversy is interpreted by many parties creating multiple discourses. The medical community views direct intervention euthanasia as striking at the “’very moral center’” of its Hippocratic tradition (Hyde, 1993, p. 593). The editor of JAMA Dr. George Lundberg, who decided to publish the account, responded to criticism by arguing that the text allows conversations to start (Hyde, 1993, p. 559-600). The account is also factually disputed calling into question its truth or fiction. The morphine dosage given to Debbie should not have ended Debbie’s life in minutes as the account stated but hours (Hyde, 1993, p. 603-4). All of these varying messages and reactions lead to an interpretation of the text “filled with uncertainty...an essential rhetorical ingredient in what the story is doing-how it means” (Hyde, 1993, p. 598). This uncertainty is a key point within the text. Without uncertainty the ability for Debbie’s story to allow “inviting,” and dialogue would not be possible (Hyde, 1993, p. 605).
Michael Hyde and Sarah McSpiritt’s (2007) essay on the Terri Schiavo controversy emphasizes the rhetoric of perfection, and how it influences the controversy. They define perfection as “a ‘god term’ an ultimate standard meant to define states of ‘completeness’ that can be used to direct us toward the good, the just, and the true” (Hyde & McSpirrit, 2007, p. 153). Perfection creates a deeper calling beyond the self towards others “affirming our freedom of choice” that happens every day (Hyde & McSpirrit, 2007, p.
How to Cite this Page
"Three Essays on Death." 123HelpMe.com. 19 Feb 2020
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Death is universal—every culture, community, and person has experienced it since the dawn of mankind. Civilizations from all across the world, in every stage of history, have dealt with death and established unique and meaningful traditions for the dying process. Throughout this paper, I will analyze the death rites of three specific ancient cultures, the Egyptians, Vikings, and Aztecs. Each of these societies emphasized the importance of death, developing unique traditions and funerary rites. The Egyptians focused on the afterlife, building massive burial structures for their Pharaohs and even mummifying deceased individuals.... [tags: Ancient Egypt, Egypt, Embalming, Death]
979 words (2.8 pages)
- In these three essays rhetorical interpretation moves away from the neo-Aristotelianism where “standards [of judgment] are sanctioned by the fact that they produced certain desired effects in audiences” to a polysemic, postmodern reading of texts (Black, 1978, p. 73). These readings highlight artifacts that focus on death but at the same time celebrate contestation in living. Michael Hyde’s (1993) essay about the publication of “It’s over Debbie” in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) describes a doctor committing a form of “direct intervention” euthanasia.... [tags: Essay Critique]
1299 words (3.7 pages)
- “Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard” by Tomas Gray begins in the evening time; it’s not quite night time yet. He tells how he goes out day after day to the churchyard to find inspiration to write his poems. He sits and ponders on who these people were and noticed they were all probably poor. In an indirect way he refers to them as nobody’s. Then he wonders what someone would put on his tombstone after he has passed away. He begins to tell us what he would expect his tombstone to say and presents to us three messages about death.... [tags: Renaissance, plague, Tomas Gray, England]
903 words (2.6 pages)
- Invention is the division of rhetoric that rhetors use to find arguments. The three approaches to invention are kairos, stasis theory, and the topic method. I am going to apply them here to support my belief in the near-death experience. When speaking to an audience, I must use kairos. I have to take into consideration what information is relevant to my audience. From there I can develop a persuasive argument on the near-death experience. Here I will give some examples of the points I need to make when arguing from a kairotic stance.... [tags: Near-death Experience Speech]
825 words (2.4 pages)
- Breast Cancer Name Institution Breast Cancer Cancer is the principal cause of death internationally and aches 2 of every three families. Breast cancer is the most common diagnosed cancer especially in women. More than one million incidences arise worldwide yearly (Mayo Clinic, 2013) The minute it comes to breast cancer there are few areas that you should look at to comprehend, and be alert of. These areas involve knowing the basis and risk elements, detection and prevention, the effects on the victim’s stamina, outlooks of recovery, and to sum up your treatment alternatives.... [tags: Cancer, Breast cancer, Chemotherapy]
1113 words (3.2 pages)
- As an MHS twelfth grader and a student in Sociology, I humbly impart my standpoint to the Justice System regarding the case on whether or not to abolish capital punishment. There is indeed a present case as of today that one US state had declared their petition on permanently removing death penalty in the entire United States. I believe that this is a very callous appeal – one main reason we have capital punishment is to develop a sense of morality as well as protection within the whole society, not to put such great emphasis on the criminals who deteriorate the rest of civilization.... [tags: Capital Punishment, Death Penalty]
1738 words (5 pages)
- Chapter three talk about how Ann and her family had a hard time while being America first foreign missionaries in Burma. First page of chapter three talked about elephants stomping the prisoner to death while the king lounged on his cushions and watched. What I don’t get about this sentence about the elephant stomping on people is how you as a king could be that evil and just watch an elephant that weight 12,000 pound stomped on people while doing nothing about it. I keep it that the people are prisoner, but they are human too they just made some terrible mistake.... [tags: Prison, The Prisoner, Death, Fuller]
1013 words (2.9 pages)
- Another poem with a central theme of death is “Because I could not stop for Death”. This first line in the poem is a clever one “Because I could not stop for Death-/He kindly stopped for me” (Madden). It implies that the speaker did not have a choice regarding her death so Death (personified) came to her. Stanza three reads, “We passed the School/…We passed the Fields of Gazing Grain-/ We passed the Setting Sun-” (Madden). The carriage containing the speaker, Death, and Immortality passes through seemingly ordinary places.... [tags: Death, Life, Afterlife, Cleanliness]
1054 words (3 pages)
- This article studies the phenomenology of death and near-death experiences. It emphasized that death is noted to be more of a psychological process rather than a physical one. Tassell (2013) states that there 's been a discovery of three prevalent characteristics of the NDE- “loss of the fear of death, psychological sequelae, and complex conscious abilities.” These focus points give guidance as to implications for the understanding of death. The article focuses on NDE’s in order to target the psychological processes that are associated with these experiences.... [tags: Death, Afterlife, Near death experience]
917 words (2.6 pages)
- Sophocles’s Antigone is a play revolving around the concept of death that takes place in the world of the living. The play begins in the shadow of the death and destruction wrought by the brothers Eteocles and Polyneices. It ends, as one would expect of a tragedy, with the king, Creon, grieving over three tragic losses that have decimated his family. The titular character has an especially unique relationship with the two contrasting elements of life and death. For most of the play, she exists in a state of “limbo” between the two.... [tags: Death, Life, Creon, Oedipus, Sophocles]
1188 words (3.4 pages)
Carole Blair, Marsha Jeppson and Enrico Pucci, Jr. (1991) read the Vietnam Veterans Memorial as a form of postmodern architecture showing how “multivalent readings are not just possible but that they are necessary” (Blair, Jeppson & Pucci, 1991, p. 573). These multiple readings then are structured to have‘incredulity towards metanarratives’ (Lyotard, p. 565). The memorial itself is more than the black granite with the names of the dead, but the surrounding flag pole, mementos, visitors, other memorial sites, and The Three Soldiers (Blair, Jeppson & Pucci, 1991, p. 574-575). This reading calls into question authorship because such diverse elements cannot have a singular author (Blair, Jeppson & Pucci, 1991, p. 575). With no single author to interpret and show how the text means, rhetorical critics must “deauthorize its authors…to expect multiple, possibly strongly divergent, readings” (Blair, Jeppson & Pucci, 1991, p. 574). The other ways that the memorial functions against metanarratives is that it has no base (p. 575), names like any gravestone (p. 575), a mirror-like surface that constantly shifts (p. 574), and a black finish to counter the glory of other monuments (p. 576). These different elements function to embrace the different elements that the Vietnam War caused. The multiple parts “inscribe a history, forming a space of cooperative conflict and commenting on each other’s statements” (Blair, Jeppson & Pucci, 1991, p. 577). The contestation culminates “in the two sides being endlessly articulated rather than transcended” (p. 578). Ultimately this polysemic reading of the memorial causes the authors to invite the reader into new assumptions about criticism asking the audience to “remove the critic’s tasks of forming a text, of becoming the authorizing voice” (Blair, Jeppson & Pucci, 1991, p. 583).
In these three essays there are the deaths of Debbie, Terri, approximately 59,000 soldiers and modernist readings. The first three had more of a bang to them; the final death of modernism feels more like a whimper. It is the final death that I want to focus on because that the others speak in multiple ways for themselves. Each of these essays encourages the reader to continue controversy in ways that do not curtail the marginalized (Hyde, 1993, p. 607), invite public debate and deliberation (Hyde & McSpiritt, 2007, p. 174), and have the critic become “interventionist rather than a deferential, if expert, spectator” (Blair, Jeppeson and Pucci, 1991, p. 583). Each of these exhortations occurs in the final paragraph of the essay. As if the urge of postmodernism is to cherish ambiguity that can arise. Another example that shows how multiple readings are essential is the death of Daniel Sotomayor. Sotomayor was an AIDs and gay rights activist in the 1980s and early 1990s in Chicago. His tactics to convey his message were radical: taking over buildings, having very extreme protests and writing very angry, hostile articles (Williams, 2010). One reading of his life is that his intense form of politics allowed many people to finally acknowledge the perfection in them despite the very hostile views of the general public. To interpret and acknowledge Sotomayor’s life would be impossible without including another view that attacked him as being either a degradation to humanity or far too political. A rhetorical critic would have to show the views that were opposed to Sotomayor in order see what his life was about. The contestation of his legacy is important. His death by AIDs is also not as clearly distinguishable as simply as “since he died of AIDs, I should do something.” Another reading places his death in time to show how it highlighted one of his key messages: the government is not doing enough to educate the public and research treatments for AIDs. His death shows a movement toward action and at the same time shows the lack of action by other parties. It is another example of how one single reading and view of a text limits how the text means.