Thomas Hume's Views on Miracles

1124 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Critical assessment of miracles

There are different types of miracles and they exist to those who have a reason to believe in them. Thomas Hume believes that miracles are not real. He says that there is a reasonable explanation behind all “miracles” and a logical way to explain them. Survivors of almost unimaginable circumstances on the contrary equate their very survival to some sort of phenomenon or miracle. On one hand there is a philosopher with rational knowledge on why miracles do not exist, but then on the other hand there are survivors who link their endurance of a life and death situation on a miracle of some sorts. Miracles exist to those who need for them to exist, and that in turn means they exist. The more a person has gone through, the more that they need to believe in miracles. It is a great feeling knowing that there is some kind of supernatural force that is looking out for you.
A miracle is defined as, “a surprising and welcoming event that is not explicable by natural or scientific laws and is therefore considered to be the work of a divine agency.” (Webster's Dictionary ). According to Hume, “ A miracle is a violation of the laws of nature.” (Hume 76). Hume believes that, “Nothing is esteemed a miracle if it ever happened in the common course of nature.” (Hume 76). He uses an example of a man in seemly good health suddenly dying. While, “it is no miracle that a man, seemingly in good health, should die on a sudden, “ (Hume 77), it could be considered a miracle to those who have to deal with the loss. If someone is in good health then, it is a very surprising and that is in part what makes a miracle a miracle. Sometimes an untimely death is unexplainable and a wonder all in one. Maybe the pain of losing someone without any warnin...

... middle of paper ...

...d, but managed to survive is miracle enough and it does not need justification of any kinds.
Whether or not one personally believes in miracles is a personal choice, a choice that should not be dictated by anyone or anything. The more a person goes through, the more supernatural forces that they believe in. Sometimes it is living life and going through tough experiences that make people wonder how they ever survived. When there is no logical answer, then one has found that they have lived through a miracle, It is not a topic that one can simply state it either is or is not. It is something that a person has to feel internally and can be the answer.

Works Cited
Hume, David. An Enquiry Concening Human Understanding. Hackett Publishing Company, Inc, 1977.

I Shouldn't Be Alive. .

Webster's Dictionary . 2014. .

Show More
Related

  • Miracle On Ice A Miracle Essay

    744 Words  | 2 Pages

    Miracles. An event that happens that cannot scientifically and logically be explained. Miracles tend to happen in the most unexpected ways. Even though many people tend to not believe in miracles, for different reasons, I, however, believe that miracles happen every day to different people all over the world. Miracle on Ice was truly and definitely a miracle. How is it possible for a group of college kids to overcome the challenge of beating a full, grown, experienced, USSR team? It’s not. It’s a miracle.

    Read More

  • David Hume: On Miracles

    1899 Words  | 4 Pages

    ... Egyptians close behind. As the bible explains the miracle takes place the Red Sea splits leading the Israelite’s to freedom. As the Egyptians were crossing the sea it closed it’s gates and let them drown with in the waters of the sea. In justifying whether Hume would discredit this miracle he would definitely see how one may say it is a miracle, but again would have a hard time validating the testimony of the miracle. Again we see the pattern of the fact that there is no one to testify for the event. We can only view this as a truthful experience through our belief in God and the bible. It is what we are taught to believe through religious texts, and our house of worship. It is the individuals perception of reality and what he or she believes to be a valid event. In conclusion, a miracle is actually based on an individuals own perception of past and present experiences. The belief in a miraculous event tends to have no real evidence through mans hope, it tends to be something better through our expectations. I can not debate the belief of a miracle. There is no right or wrong belief. It is viewed through our own individual perception and faith, our existence and sense of reality.

    Read More

  • David Hume's Argument Against Belief in the Existence of Miracles

    1988 Words  | 4 Pages

    One of the most important aspects of Hume's argument is his understanding of probability. Hume states that belief is often a result of probability in that we believe an event that has occurred most often as being most likely. In relation to miracles this suggests that miraculous events should be labelled as a miracle only where it would be even more unbelievable for it not to be. This is Hume's argument in Part 1 Of Miracles, he states that if somebody tells you that a miracle has occurred you do not have to physically go out and look at the evidence to determine it, all you really need to do is consider the concept of the miracle and if it is a violation of the laws of nature, we have to reason in acco...

    Read More

  • Miracles In An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding By David Hume

    1310 Words  | 3 Pages

    In An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding by David Hume, the idea of miracles is introduced. Hume’s argument is that there is no rational reason for human beings to believe in miracles, and that it is wrong to have miracles as the building blocks for religion. It is because the general notion of miracles come from the statement of others who claim to have seen them, Hume believes that there is no way to prove that those accounts are accurate, because they were not experienced first-hand. In order to believe a miracle, the evidence should be concrete, and something irrefutable. When there is any sort of doubt to a miracle, Hume says that any evidence that can be contrary to the proof of a miracle is merely evidence that the miracle did not happen, and it should be disproved. The only way a miracle can be proven is from the testimony of the person who had witnessed it, while any evidence against the miracle is something that defies the laws of nature. It falls upon the reputation of the witness to prove whether or not he or she actually observed a miracle, because a miracle can only be plausible when it is more likely than the opposing laws of nature. Hume’s reasoning in favour of miracles being insufficient events are also explanations as to why he believes miracles are not probable. First is the idea that human beings are not honest enough to be able to have possibly witnessed a miracle. Next is that human beings want to believe in the supernatural, and that desire allows us to believe in things that could never happen, simply because it would be wonderful and fantastical if that miracle actually did occur. Thirdly, the people who usually report sightings of a miracle are those who are uncivilized, or unsophisticated, so they ...

    Read More

  • What Is C. S. Lewis Arguments Against Supernaturalism

    443 Words  | 1 Pages

    All of the arguments made for Supernaturalism create the opposing side to Naturalism and help to explain the areas that Naturalism does not. The main argument for Supernaturalism that Lewis uses is the Supernaturalist belief that one thing exists on its own and has produced the framework of space and time, which he calls Nature. This belief counters the Naturalist belief that “time is going on of its own accord”. Unlike this belief, Supernaturalists believe; because there is an ultimate being who created everything, the Natural is not always what springs up of its own accord. Through a supernatural being or beings, occurrences like miracles can happen. Lewis shows through his argument that true nature can only be completely described through the Supernaturalist point of view, of which there is One Self-existent Thing that created nature. Even though miracles may never in fact interfere with the natural system God has created, miracles, though not common and not substantially provable, cannot easily be dismissed as never having occurred. Overall Lewis affectively created two plausible arguments that go against Naturalism and support the Supernaturalist belief

    Read More

  • David Hume: Compatibilism And Hume

    1937 Words  | 4 Pages

    Megan Darnley PHIL-283 May 5, 2014 Compatibilism and Hume. The choices an individual makes are often believed to be by their own doing; there is nothing forcing one action to be done in lieu of another, and the responsibility of one’s actions is on him alone. This idea of Free Will, supported by libertarians and is the belief one is entirely responsible for their own actions, is challenged by necessity, otherwise known as determinism. Those championing determinism argue every action and event is because of some prior cause.

    Read More

  • Young Earth Creationism

    1329 Words  | 3 Pages

    ...d many to reject the accuracy of the scriptures. In conclusion, if you can believe Genesis 1:1, then the rest of the scripture is easy. All the miracles and signs or even the resurrection does not come close to the significant power and miracle of all of creation being formed just by God’s word from nothing.

    Read More

  • David Hume on the Existence of Miracles

    1462 Words  | 3 Pages

    In this paper I will look at David Hume’s (1711-1776) discussion from the An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, Section X, Of Miracles regarding whether it is a reasonable assumption to believe in the existence of miracles. I will first discuss why the existence of miracles matters and how miracles relate to our understanding of the laws of nature. Secondly, I will look at how Hume argues that it is never reasonable to believe in miracles. I will then provide objections to this argument which I feel support the idea that belief is not only reasonable but a necessary condition for a faithful life.

    Read More

  • Miracles

    1288 Words  | 3 Pages

    Miracles are capable of happening to anyone around the world and there is no way of telling when they are going to happen. They do go against what the laws of nature state but that doesn’t mean that they are not possible and you do not need to believe in God in order for them to happen to you. Even though they do appear in the Bible that does not mean God is the only reason why they occur. Miracles do happen in every day life, but they are completely unpredictable because if they were predictable they would not be called miracles they would be considered ordinary events that could be explained by sciences. Miracles can be objected, but many people have also claimed to witness them in their own lives. A miracle is an unexpected event that can’t be explained by natural or scientific laws and is the work of a divine agency.

    Read More

  • Hume's Ideas on Cause and Effect

    684 Words  | 2 Pages

    Cause and effect is a tool used to link happenings together and create some sort of explanation. Hume lists the “three principles of connexion among ideas” to show the different ways ideas can be associated with one another (14). The principles are resemblance, contiguity, and cause and effect. The focus of much of An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding falls upon the third listed principle. In Section I, Hume emphasizes the need to uncover the truths about the human mind, even though the process may be strenuous and fatiguing. While the principle of cause and effect is something utilized so often, Hume claims that what we conclude through this process cannot be attributed to reason or understanding and instead must be attributed to custom of habit.

    Read More

  • Analysis of The Age of Reason by Thomas Paine

    677 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...ot be accomplished by man himself. Paine on the other hand believes “there is no such thing as a miracle” (Timmerman and Hettinga 104). Paine says that it is easier to believe that a man is telling a lie than to believe in a miracle. In a way, I do agree that it is much easier to believe that a man is telling a lie than to believe in a miracle; however, I know what God is capable of doing, and I know that He is performing miracles every day.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of David Hume's Dialogues Of Natural Religion

    1190 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Part II of David Hume’s Dialogues of Natural Religion, Demea remarks that the debate is not about whether or not God exists, but what the essence of God is. (pg.51) Despite this conclusion in Part II, in his introduction to the Dialogues Martin Bell remarks that the question of why something operates the way it does is quite different from the question why do people believe that it operates the way it does. (pg. 11) This question, the question of where a belief originates and is it a valid argument, is much of the debate between Hume’s three characters in the Dialogues. (pg. ***)

    Read More

  • Faith, Reason, and Imagination

    2008 Words  | 5 Pages

    Faith and imagination is all about truth and the belief in a higher power beyond man himself. Faith and imagination binds the power of God’s existence. However, in lack of evidence and that which is unforeseen; consequently, if we know the value of life and understand that which is right and wrong; it truly acknowledges God’s presence among us. when people reference a “miracle” has happened; most people that hold faith as a powerful source don’t just assume the miracle came out of nowhere without some concept of a divine attribute connected to faith. A miracle is not an act based purely on a violation of natural law, but an act of God’s law and his true existence. And if man is to find his true purpose of his existence and fulfilling his life, he must adopt faith and reason.

    Read More

  • David Hume´s Philosophy

    889 Words  | 2 Pages

    David Hume was a Scottish philosopher known for his ideas of skepticism and empiricism. Hume strived to better develop John Locke’s idea of empiricism by using a scientific study of our own human nature. We cannot lean on common sense to exemplify human conduct without offering any clarification to the subject. In other words, Hume says that since human beings do, as a matter of fact, live and function in this world, observation of how humans do so is imminent. The primary goal of philosophy is simply to explain and justify the reasoning of why we believe what we do.

    Read More

  • Do You Believe in Miracles?

    2431 Words  | 5 Pages

    Let me ask you a question, do you believe in miracles? Or, more appropriately, do you consider, that in today’s scientific era, it is illogical to relate a fact out of common sense, to one that would establish a witness for the intervention of a supernatural being? Here’s a moment to think a about it. Let me guess, you’re sitting there trying to make up your mind. Don’t worry; you’re not the first person that does not believe in miracles. In the past, some two centuries ago, Scottish philosopher David Hume did not believe either. And probably you have good reason not to either. But, let’s not diverse.

    Read More

More about Thomas Hume's Views on Miracles

Open Document