This Is Water a speech by David Foster Wallace Essay

This Is Water a speech by David Foster Wallace Essay

Length: 964 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In David Foster Wallace’s graduation speech, This Is Water, he uses logical and emotional appeals to discuss the importance of critical thinking. Wallace uses the term “conscious” to signal critical thinkers, while those who do not think critically are referred to as “unconscious.” Wallace’s main argument is that a person has the choice to think critically and should do so every day. Wallace’s analysis of consciousness and unconsciousness focusses too heavily on the logical and emotional appeals and ignores the possible ethical arguments that support the development of conscious societies, such as activism. In doing so, Wallace favours the self-interested members of the audience and alienates those who favour altruism, limiting the scope of his argument.

In This is Water, Wallace effectively uses logical reasoning and the parable of the religious man and the atheist man to explain how consciousness is a choice, not an unalterable state. To do this, Wallace states that in many cases, “A huge percentage of the stuff that I tend to be automatically certain of is, it turns out, totally wrong and deluded.” Using logical reasoning, Wallace’s own admission reminds his audience that they are also often wrong, as, logically, humans are not perfect and make periodic mistakes. Once he establishes that people can be wrong, he returns to the parable of the two men and claims “…the exact same experience can mean two totally different things to two different people, given those people's two different belief templates and two different ways of constructing meaning from experience.” This idea is familiar to his educated audience, as he claims it is one of the primary foundations of a liberal arts education. Thus, Wallace uses his audienc...


... middle of paper ...


... pedagogical arguments, such as teaching a person how to critically think, to ignore the ethics of their dogma and focus on superficial emotional appeals and easily understood logical appeals. By ignoring ethics in pedagogical arguments, the argument becomes less about teaching and more about explaining a certain viewpoint, focussing less on whether this is the right viewpoint and more on the author’s personal reasons supporting it. Second, in This is Water specifically, analysing this speech causes the writer to not only become a critical thinker like Wallace wanted, but also extend Wallace’s arguments in directions that he failed to properly explore, like activism.



Works Cited

Foster Wallace, David. "Plain old untrendy troubles and emotions.” The Guardian. Guardian News and Media, 20 Sept. 2008. Web. 6 Feb. 2014. .

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Speech : Speech By David Foster Wallace

- Commencement speeches are often a sending off to the graduates by a highly regarded person, and is suppose to have a purpose. The purpose of the speech is to: motivate, inspire, encourage, provoke, a call to action, and to give hope to the graduates as well as congratulate them on their achievements. Often the speaker is someone who is famous or have been successful in their life. In regards to how the speech is given, it usually starts out with the speaker congratulating the class. They will typically try to relate to the audience by making fun of themselves to lower them to the graduates level....   [tags: Commencement speech, Graduation, God, Speeches]

Better Essays
1008 words (2.9 pages)

The Commencement Speech By David Foster Wallace

- The commencement speech given by David Foster Wallace in the autumn of 2005, is a very deep speech that examines the whole idea of a Liberal Arts education at an extremely deep and intellectual level. In the 22 minute long speech Wallace talks about how higher education not only teaches you to think but “how to exercise some control over how and what you think.” (Wallace). Wallace later in his speech stresses the importance of this level of thinking by saying “if you cannot exercise this kind of choice in adult life, you will be totally hosed” (Wallace) What he means by saying this is that if you cannot think at a higher level and make sense of real world problems your life will become meani...   [tags: Mind, Thought, Universe, Graduation]

Better Essays
1260 words (3.6 pages)

`` This Is Water `` By David Foster Wallace Essay

- What makes You. You. Have you ever stopped and thought, “ what would i do if my kid had a disability?” Or ever question  why you act a certain way or if you 're strong enough. In the Articles “Notes From a Dragon mom, What we hunger For  and the speech “ This is Water”  These authors all share there thoughts on what makes a person act the way they do. In  the speech “This is Water”, by David Foster Wallace , Wallace shows many reasons on why everyday behavior is based off of a person 's education....   [tags: Mind, Psychology, David Foster Wallace, Hunger]

Better Essays
835 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on The Theory Of By David Foster Wallace

- David Foster Wallace, the author of This Is Water, mentions a theory about oneself in his commencement speech. The theory consists of oneself to think that I am the center of the world. And also my quick needs and feelings are what ought to decide the world 's priorities. However, Wallace claims that this is the automatic, unconscious way of adult life that many may choose to follow and not be aware of it. I agree that my way of life shouldn’t just be about me, but about others as well. It’s important to think about others because Wallace claims that it’s essential to open up your mind to think about others around you....   [tags: Mind, Consciousness, Awareness, Thought]

Better Essays
1101 words (3.1 pages)

Analysis Of David Foster Wallace 's ' Hunger Of Memory ' Essay

- Too many bright students merge into higher educations, astonished by the “bad grades” they receive. It’s also not until their first couple of bad grades that they realize that the cause is very much likely to be embedded in their dialect of writings. Similar to Richard Rodriguez ideas, David Foster Wallace provided a significant discussion about Standard written English as well as the teaching of various English varieties. In ‘Authority and American Usage’, Wallace managed to explore most of the different dialects in English....   [tags: English language, Dialect, Language]

Better Essays
1099 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Plato 's Allegory Of The Cave

- Plato’s allegory of the cave is an attempt to depict the idea that position of the man in the universe that he exists in is fatal. In a dialog Sokrates is trying to convince Glaucon to his point of view on the physical and mythical world. Generally speaking the thought is that all we see, the world we exist in is just an illusion, just a shade of what is really true. Plato believed that to achieve full awareness of true reality man has to free himself from earthbound matters and joys. This antic writing has inspired many generations of philosophers and is still considered as precious source of knowledge....   [tags: Plato, Mind, Thought, David Foster Wallace]

Better Essays
1157 words (3.3 pages)

Freedom Comes Within And Without Essay

- Blaise A. Broussard English 1001 Section Final Draft Submission 10/11/15 Happy Swimming Freedom comes within and without. Internally, freedom within is the idea of free thought and reasoning with the ability to decide the perception of life that’s most appealing. However this internal freedom within is often hindered by the external limitations on the out of body freedoms without. To obtain a happy sustainable sense of free thinking, mankind must practice the correct freedoms within and the freedoms without....   [tags: Personal life, Life, David Foster Wallace]

Better Essays
1198 words (3.4 pages)

This Is Water: Synthesize the Essays by Freire and Wallace

- “This is Water” is an essay that originated from a commencement speech that was delivered by David Foster Wallace at the Kenyon College on May 21, 2005 (Wallace 14). Wallace’s speech has gained a lot of acknowledgment because of its practical advice that navigate day-to day adult life. Additionally, the speech seems to be prominent as it contains various advices that one can put into account in day to day life. The main subject of the entire speech is to bring the entire graduating student’s attention to their negative thoughts....   [tags: ethos, logos, pathos, paulo freire]

Better Essays
1267 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on A Degree is not Enough

- A degree shows your school education level, but it isn’t a certificate of your actual intelligence. David Foster Wallace made his commencement speech at Kenyon College in 2005 pointing out that we all have a default setting that holds us back from greatness. Simply having a degree does not mean that you know how to think; which is half of your intellectual ability. Everyone is pre-programmed from birth to believe that the world revolves around them; that they’re the center of the universe. Having this self centered world view is normal; this is the way that everyone is preset to think at birth....   [tags: intelligence, wallace]

Better Essays
548 words (1.6 pages)

A Speech On The Cerebral Penitentiary

- The Cerebral Penitentiary “About all a commencement speaker can really do is to suggest a couple of things that [he or] she believes really matters.” Sue Monk Kidd stated this while addressing the graduates of Scripps College. On May 21, 2005 Kenyon College graduation welcomed David Foster Wallace, an American novelist, for their commencement address. A prime example of Kidd’s statement, Wallace stated in address that “suicide’s [victims] are actually long dead before they pull the trigger” (Wallace 4)....   [tags: Graduation, Commencement speech, Liberal arts]

Better Essays
929 words (2.7 pages)