The Role of Power in Obedience Essay

The Role of Power in Obedience Essay

Length: 1389 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

To Obey or Disobey: The Role of Power in Obedience

People’s decision to obey or disobey the law is based on how much power (in its various
forms) they perceive the law to have behind it. The power of coercion is one maintained by every
government in human history: the power to punish. The power of legitimacy is a much more
subtle power: the power to appear as an authority and let others presume that you know best.
While enforcing law, authorities will exercise both these powers. Both powers underscore
government and society’s ability to control us and to get us to obey.
Why do we obey? Stanley Milgram’s Obedience to Authority, a series of experiments in
which subjects were told to administer what they believed to be high-voltage electric shocks to
people who they thought were experimental subjects, shows us the disturbing extent of people’s
obedience in the face of power. Whereas it was hypothesized that few of the subjects would
actually shock their supposed experimental subjects, the actual experiments showed a
“disturbingly high level of compliance with authority figures despite the apparent pain evinced
by the false experimental subjects.” (Cover 223) Even when the false experimental subjects
(actually just a tape recording of responses) screamed with supposed agony, the vast majority of
the subjects, although showing some hesitation and concern for their “victims”, still nevertheless
shocked them again and again at the behest of the authority, even after the “victims” had gone
silent. (Cover 223) The almost blind obedience of these subjects was due to the power of
legitimacy and expertise they perceived the authority figures behind the experiment to have. The
2
authorities were able to impose their will ...


... middle of paper ...


...human, we will
always retain our freedom of thought and our decision to obey or disobey.
5

Works Cited
Cover, Robert M. “The Violence of Legal Acts.” Before the Law: An Introduction to the Legal
Process. Eds. Bonsignore, Katsh, d’Errico, Pipkin, Arons, Rifkin. Boston: Houghton
Mifflin Company, 2002. 223.

King, Martin Luther. “Letter from Birmingham Jail.” Before the Law: An Introduction to the
Legal Process. Eds. Bonsignore, Katsh, d’Errico, Pipkin, Arons, Rifkin. Boston:
Houghton Mifflin Company, 2002. 158-162.

Kropotkin, Peter. “Law and Authority.” Before the Law: An Introduction to the Legal Process.
Eds. Bonsignore, Katsh, d’Errico, Pipkin, Arons, Rifkin. Boston: Houghton Mifflin
Company, 2002. 158-162.

Tyler, Tom. “Why do People Obey the Law?” Introduction to Legal Studies: A Reader. Ed.
Thomas Hilbink. Amherst: Collective Copies. 475-495.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Obedience to Authority by Stanley Milgram Essay example

- Stanley Milgram’s 1963 studies into obedience have provided important and shocking insights into the power of authority. The study set out to discover how obedient people really are. Debate and controversy have surrounded the study since the results were first published. Predictions made by psychologists before the experiment proved dramatically inaccurate. The experiment led volunteers to believe they were administering increasingly painful and dangerous electric shocks to another volunteer for the purposes of a study on memory....   [tags: Obedience to Authority, 1974]

Powerful Essays
2398 words (6.9 pages)

Conformity and Obedience in Society Essay

- Conformity and Obedience in Society The desire to be accepted and belong to a group is an undeniable human need. But how does this need affect an individual. Social psychologists have conducted numerous experiments and concluded that, through various forms of social influence, groups can change their members’ thoughts, feelings, and behavior. In her essay “Group Minds,” Doris Lessing discusses our paradoxical ability to call ourselves individuals and our inability to realize that groups define and influence us....   [tags: Social Roles Obedience Conformity Essays]

Free Essays
939 words (2.7 pages)

The Experiments On Obedience Conducted By Stanley Milgram Essay

- The experiments on obedience conducted by Stanley Milgram shed a previously unforeseen light on human nature and the evil tendencies therein. Since it was conducted, many professionals have reviewed Milgram 's work and inserted their own opinions into the work. One of these many is Ian Parker, who, in his article titled "Obedience," critiques Milgram 's experiment with other professionals, thus stating that the experiment is corrupted and false in almost any way conceivable. Later, Parker states that the comparison asserted by Milgram to the Holocaust is quite a stretch, asserting that the Holocaust was nothing even near what was studied by Milgram (Parker 97)....   [tags: Stanford prison experiment, Milgram experiment]

Powerful Essays
731 words (2.1 pages)

The Power of Situation in The Milgram Experiment Essay

- The power that a situation can have on a person is simply incredible. This power of situation and obedience go hand in hand, people get caught up in a situation because of the obedience they were taught as children. In society obedience is the key, allowing things to run smoothly and helps to prevent chaos. But in some instances that obedience can over take and cause a person to do things that they normally wouldn’t; whether it be following orders to an extreme extent or even doing things that people would consider to be inhumane....   [tags: lucifer effect, obedience, milgram experiment]

Powerful Essays
1779 words (5.1 pages)

The Theories Of Obedience And Disobedience Essay

- The concepts of obedience and disobedience are evident from the beginning of one 's life. Young children are born with the tendency to do things that are against what they are told or what they know they should do. They don 't have to learn how to disobey; it is an innate behavior. This struggle between obedience and disobedience carries on throughout our lives. There are three major factors that can cause obedience and disobedience; authority, social pressure, and situations. Each of these vastly impact an individual 's behavior and cause them to act in ways they would normally not....   [tags: Stanford prison experiment, Milgram experiment]

Powerful Essays
1152 words (3.3 pages)

The Dilemma Of Destructive Obedience Essay

- How does your text explain the dilemma of destructive obedience. What factors play a role in destructive obedience. Destructive obedience has been very detrimental to mankind. With such instances as Holocaust or the genocide headed by the Hutu government against the Tutsis, but the question that comes up is “why does people conform to destructive obedience. Baron & Branscombe explains the dilemma of destructive obedience in four sections as to why a person may partake in destructive obedience in the first place....   [tags: Sociology, Social psychology, Persuasion]

Powerful Essays
1111 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about The Theories Of Obedience And Disobedience

- In order to understand the phenomena of obedience and disobedience, it is essential to understand the causes of these behaviors. The first and most common cause of both obedience and disobedience is authority. Countless examples demonstrate the significant impact of authority on a person’s behavior. The Milgram Experiment, conducted in 1963 by a Yale psychologist, was a prime illustration of how authority can greatly influence the actions of an individual. In the Milgram Experiment, there were two volunteers who were assigned the roles of either the “teacher” or the “learner.” The teacher would ask the learner a series of questions and if the learner answered a question incorrectly, the teac...   [tags: Stanford prison experiment, Milgram experiment]

Powerful Essays
723 words (2.1 pages)

The Between Authority And Obedience Essay

- The Power of Authority The relation between authority and obedience has been a topic of questioning for a number of years. Psychological studies such as the Milgram Experiment and Stanford Prison experiment have found a strong connection between authority and obedience, indicating an individual’s likelihood to obey heightens when their sense of morality and rationality is confronted by a figure of authority. The controversial Milgram experiment demonstrated how an individual can easily be influenced to partake in amoral behaviour when instructed my an authoritative figure....   [tags: Stanford prison experiment, Milgram experiment]

Powerful Essays
1225 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Obedience and Conformity

- Obedience and Conformity Both obedience and conformity involve social pressure in obedience the pressure comes from behaving as you are instructed to do; whereas in conformity the pressure comes from group norms Behaviour in obedience is determined by social power, whereas in conformity it is influenced mostly by the need for acceptance. In nearly all societies, certain people are given power and authority over others....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
521 words (1.5 pages)

Essay about Authority and Obedience

- Authority and Obedience Thesis: We consciously or unconsciously obey authority in all walks of life on a daily basis. Obedience is when there is legitimate power, there is pressure to comply. Compliance with that which is required by authority; subjection to rightful restraint or control. Authority being the legal or rightful power; a right to command or enforce obedience on another. This essay shall discuss, explore and evaluate the explanations as to why people obey authority....   [tags: Psychology Stanley Milgram]

Powerful Essays
2295 words (6.6 pages)