Although Niewyk presented these interpretations in depth, his criticisms of Weiss's long history approach and Friedlander’s scientific interpretations are flawed. In reaction to Weiss’s argument, he proposes the question, “If Germans harbored such intense loathing for the Jews, why were no substantial steps taken against them before Hitler came to power in 1933?” Friedlander’s argument is met with the supposition that “only the Jews were singled out by the Nazis for total annihilation and warn against anything that might detract from the particular dimensions and characteristics of the Jewish tragedy.”
The problems with these critiques are that Niewyk ignores Germany's previous attempts at sterilization legislation in 1923 and the influence of foreign eugenic legislation and restrictions on the Nazi government. He also pays little attention to the evidence that shows the Nazi regime also strategically targeted individuals...
... middle of paper ...
...eiss, “Anti-Semitism Through the Ages” Ed. By Donald Niewyk, The Holocaust: Problems in European Civilization (Boston, Massachusetts:Wadsworth, 2011), 12.
“Police decree on identification of Jews, 1 September 1941” Ed. By Stackelberg and Winkle. The Nazi Germany Sourcebook: an anthology of texts. (New York: Rutledge, 2002), 154
Harry Friedlander, “The Opening Act of Nazi Germany” Ed. By Donald Niewyk, The Holocaust: Problems in European Civilization (Boston, Massachusetts:Wadsworth, 2011), 45.
“Minutes of the Wannsee Conference, 20 January 1942” Ed. By Stackelberg and Winkle. The Nazi Germany Sourcebook: an anthology of texts. (New York: Rutledge, 2002), 345.
“Minutes of the Wannsee Conference, 20 January 1942” Ed. By Stackelberg and Winkle. The Nazi Germany Sourcebook: an anthology of texts. (New York: Rutledge, 2002), 348.
Niewyk, The Holocaust, 10.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Because of anti Semitism, Nazi propaganda, and the rise of Hitler’s message, the citizens of Germany embraced the Nazi Regime believing the allegations against the “unwanted Jews;” therefore, they were bystanders to the Holocaust by yielding the party power to move forward and annihilate the Jews. The German citizens made Jews their scapegoat for their economic and political problems. People like the Germans find others to blame other than themselves.This helped create Anti Semitism. David Downing suggest that, Jews were viewed as “ Christ killers”.... [tags: Holocaust Essays]
1564 words (4.5 pages)
- Introduction: The Holocaust was an event that took place in Germany which means ‘sacrifice by fire’ in Greek; many murdered Jews were the consequences of this terrible action caused by Adolf Hitler. According to the website United States Holocaust Memorial Museum (USHMM) it states that “The Holocaust was the systematic, bureaucratic, state-sponsored persecution and murder of six million Jews by the Nazi regime and its collaborators.” This terrific slaughter was a racial and discriminatory oppression for the Nazis to the minorities.... [tags: Nazi Germany, Adolf Hitler, The Holocaust]
1798 words (5.1 pages)
- The Holocaust is a period of history known widely as the extermination of the Jewish race and other minorities that occurred in Germany during World War II. For years, there has been a debate among historians on whether the Holocaust was an idea created by Hitler or if it was one that emerged from the Nazi party ranks. These two differing ideas became known as intentionalism and functionalism and have both gained support among historians. Intentionalism holds Hitler accountable for the actions taken against Jews and believes that the Holocaust originated from him rather than the Nazi party.... [tags: Nazi Germany, The Holocaust, Germany]
901 words (2.6 pages)
- Most social scientists have been overlooking the growth of social scientific concept of genocide. Sociologists argue that holocaust is an illustrative case of the destructive side of modernity. Comparing the two genocides, Armenian Genocide and the Holocaust, will support the theory. Because of modernity, people started recognizing when genocide is committed. Modernity has both, good and bad impacts on humanity. The good side of it is that people started labeling genocide as a new issue, instead of categorizing it as warfare and they demanded justice.... [tags: Nazi Germany, World War II, The Holocaust, Germany]
1186 words (3.4 pages)
- What possible reason can someone have for supporting or participating in the genocide and murder of millions of innocent people. During the period of the holocaust, the German peoples participation or indifference’s towards state sponsored genocide and murder could have been an effect of racism, national pride, and peer pressure. To begin with, Racism had a big effect in the genocide and murders in Germany. According A Teacher's Guide to the Holocaust, it states that “ It was the explicit aim of Hitler's regime to create a European world both dominated and populated by the "Aryan" race.... [tags: Holocaust Essays]
875 words (2.5 pages)
- While the Germans and the rest of the world were focusing on World War I, many innocent people experiencing a different type of nature. They were subjected to being publicly humiliated, shaved and branded, and placed in tormenting concentration camps. Persecution and Emigration, Origins of the Holocaust, Fighting Back and Anne Frank are all big roles during this time period. No one will ever know the exact feeling of the trauma people were facing and how many people were actually killed. During the time of the Holocaust, Jews were not the only victims of murder.... [tags: WWII, nazism, the Jewish question]
1160 words (3.3 pages)
- Generally speaking, if one were to ask an American if they know what the holocaust was, most of the time they would produce a somewhat correct answer. One could also infer the individual would speak broadly about WWII, genocide, Nazi and Adolf Hitler. For those who do not know, The Holocaust was a mass genocide that targeted many groups deemed by the Nazi party to be subhuman(also referred to as Untermensch) such as Roma(Gypsies), Poles, People with Disabilities and Russians. However when hearing the term “Holocaust” or “NAZI” one group in particular is almost always brought to mind, Jews, and for good reason.... [tags: Adolf Hitler, Nazi Germany, Nazi Party, Judaism]
1722 words (4.9 pages)
- The Holocaust was a deplorable event in history. Millions of people were annihilated. This was a eventuality of antisemitism. Germans were considered to be "superior" from the Jewish people. However, the racial separation was not only aimed toward Jews, but to Gypsies, Slavic, disabled people, and others. The word "Holocaust" origins from Greek, meaning "a sacrifice consumed by fire." (Merriam Webster Dictionary) This title is usually given to occurrences where genocides are most likely to happen.... [tags: nazi, germans, antisemitism, ghetos]
1024 words (2.9 pages)
- Rousseau argues in his Discourse on the Origins of Inequality that inequalities are created by social construction. Naturally, inequalities do not exist, but because man creates boundaries and distinguishes one another, political and moral inequalities are created. Since the 18th century, during Rousseau’s time, the history of inequalities have changed, and ideas of imperialism, racism, and sexism have shifted between then and the 20th century. Private property was a leading cause of inequalities according to Rousseau.... [tags: World War II, Nazi Germany, Slavery, World War I]
891 words (2.5 pages)
- Holocaust Survivors Who survived the holocaust. What are their lives like today. What has been the government's response towards those who survived after World War II. Have the survivors kept their faith. How has the survivors next generation been affected. The survivors of the holocaust were deeply effected by the trauma they encountered. This unforgettable experience influenced their lives, those around them, and even their descendants. When the infamous Hitler began his reign in Germany in 1933, 530,000 Jews were settled in his land.... [tags: Essays Papers]
1277 words (3.6 pages)