The Myth of Equality

The Myth of Equality

Length: 800 words (2.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
In his article, “The Myth of Equality” written in August 2010 in his official blog, Patrick Buchanan, an American conservative political commentator, suggests that equality will never be achievable here in America when it comes to personal skills and abilities (par. 8). He points out the inequality that is evident in the American professional sports where only those who are considered “good” are thriving (par. 6-7). Buchanan reveals that the standardize test that is given to students proves that there is a disparity in education among racial groups (par. 16). He infers that here in America, because we vary in our capabilities to perform at something, inequalities among racial groups are almost the standard and it is demonstrated in several institutions.
One organization where inequality among racial groups is established is in the American professional sports system; where only those who demonstrate excellence in the sport flourish. Buchanan interprets statistics reported by columnist Walter Williams to conclude that black male athletes dominate majority of the popular sports such as the NFL and the NBA (par. 5). Furthermore, Buchanan reveals that no one complains when Hispanics and Asians who make up a good percentage of the population are not visible nor pursued after in this organization (par. 2).
The enactment of standardizes testing given to students to measure their academic abilities and supposedly will close achievement gap only prove that the battle to the end achievement gap between racial groups is a failure. Buchanon elucidate statistics of the results from the national test under the “No Child Left Behind” program to infer that there is a huge gap between white students and black students (par. 19). On the same note, New Yorks state test scores reveals a large imbalance in academics between different racial groups (par. 16)
For Buchanon, here in America, the notion of equality among racial group will never be attained. This is because we as an individual, whether it is academic or athletic, are all different in a great deal of way. We respond to situation differently.
There is always some sort of competition that is constantly occurring and it is certainly true that only those who exhibit excellence will be superior over the rest of the population. Although Patrick Buchanan’s essay proves the notion that equality among races when it comes to academic is in fact a myth, he failed to illustrate other influences that drive America in to racial inequality.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Myth of Equality." 123HelpMe.com. 23 Feb 2020
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=222004>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

America: Myth Of Equality Essay

- America: Myth of Equality To many, the Unites States serves as the ideal model of democracy for the modern world. Yet, how truly worthy is America of this status. Although it has been said that, “Equality is as American as baseball, hot dogs, and apple pie,” one must be extremely critical when analyzing such a statement. By taking a historical perspective to the question of how “equal” American equality actually is, it is simple to recognize how problematic the “Land of the Free” mentality can be....   [tags: essays research papers]

Research Papers
1311 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on The Myth Of Common Core Equality By Valerie Stratus

- Another, challenge that can rise from CCSS is the grading format of the standards that makes it a greater challenge based on their inability to perform at the grade performance. In The Washington Post article “The Myth of Common Core Equality” by Valerie Stratus, explains the challenges student are faced with common core, and how it is unfortanetly increasing the educational gap. Stratus explain how minorities are performing poorly in common core test, “When a student score in the Below Standard category of 1, there is a good chance that her or his answer were mere guesses, or the test was so difficult, they simply gave up” (Strauss)....   [tags: Critical thinking, Education, Thought, Learning]

Research Papers
822 words (2.3 pages)

The Equality Myth Essay

- It's pretty hard to tell what does bring happiness. Poverty and wealth have both failed. --Kin Hubbard, Sociologist The Great Gatsby written by F. Scott Fitzgerald is as much a novel about social hierarchy as it is about class-consciousness. Throughout the novel we are bombarded with images of extravagant wealth and shuddering pauperism with the elite upper class using those around them as stepping-stones to their own selfish happiness. The novel makes a point to differentiate between classes within classes especially how the sociology of the wealthy differs within itself....   [tags: American Literature]

Research Papers
642 words (1.8 pages)

Gender Stereotypes and the Beauty Myth Essay

- Dewing and Foster has proposed that a unisexual beauty myth may result in sexual equality. Therefore the purpose of this assignment is to investigate the impact beauty has on men and women. Thus, I look at how and why gender stereotypes and the beauty myth exist. Furthermore, I am also going to investigate how traditional beliefs of masculinity have changed. In addition, I also discuss the consequences that arise for men and women, because of the beauty myth. Lastly I will discuss the interrelation between gender and age and how double standards apply for ageing men and women in society....   [tags: sexual equality, femininity, masculinity]

Research Papers
1059 words (3 pages)

The Afro-Cuban Struggle for Equality Essay

- The Afro-Cuban Struggle for Equality Introduction During the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the island of Cuba was in the process of emerging from a Spanish colony to an independent nation. Freedom from Spain, however, was not the only struggle that Cuba was experiencing at this time. After having been oppressed by slavery for several centuries, Afro-Cubans, who had joined the fight for independence in large numbers, were demanding equality in Cuban society. Nevertheless, whites, especially in the elite, continued to initiate discriminatory practices against them....   [tags: Cuba Equality Racism Essays]

Research Papers
1403 words (4 pages)

The Myth Of Australia Is A Classless Society Essay

- The myth that Australia is a classless society is still, till this day, circulating. With education opportunities differing, depending on your status in society and socioeconomic background, not all Australians share the same opportunity of education. Whether being a middle class citizen or an “elite” or from working class, all education opportunities offered, will be influenced by your financial status and hierarchy in society. Power can influence the outcome of an individual’s life. Ford states “As a child who had dropped in from a parallel universe of purchased educational opportunity and order, I had no idea why such difference existed, nor of its consequences”....   [tags: Social class, Working class, Sociology, Wealth]

Research Papers
1006 words (2.9 pages)

The Myth Of Black Violence Essay

- Recently it has been commonly said that America is making progress to reach racial equality, and it is believed that soon the treatment of the whole population will be equal regardless of one’s race. Although, in the academic and artistic circles, racial equality is very doubtful and not a consensus. In the photograph above, a black man is being assaulted by a white cop during a peaceful protest that happened in London for race equality. While the aggression happens, the other cops just look at it without acting, as if it was normal and they were not liable for their actions....   [tags: Black people, Race, White people, African American]

Research Papers
1730 words (4.9 pages)

Essay on The Myth and the Limit

- Rolling a boulder up a hill and watching it roll back down again. Quite a gruesome fate, is it not. It is what Sisyphus got for deceiving the gods. In some versions of the myth, he was the founder and king of Corinth, in others, he was a knave – the most cunning one (he could also have been both, it is no secret that political power and banditry are not incompatible). Fighting for his life and freedom, he angered the gods and ended up in Tartarus, condemned to accomplish the meaningless task he is famous for; thus, for eternity....   [tags: freedom, anarchy, Albert Camus, punk movement]

Research Papers
1363 words (3.9 pages)

The Myth Of The Prometheus Essay

- It is in our human nature to generate new ideas, explore new possibilities and even push the boundaries of science in an attempt to make new discoveries. Prometheus, the creator of humanity is most well known for stealing fire from Zeus in order to help humans develop into a more intellectually advanced society. Prometheus loved humans so much that he was willing to suffer eternally so that they could have a better life on Earth. This shows that Prometheus was morally just in his decision to disobey Zeus because he only wanted to help the human race in their evolution into a more stable and advanced society....   [tags: Prometheus, Frankenstein, Percy Bysshe Shelley]

Research Papers
1328 words (3.8 pages)

The Afro-Cuban Struggle for Equality Essay

- The Afro-Cuban Struggle for Equality I. Introduction: The legacy of slavery and the legacy of systematic racial discrimination imposed on Afro-Cubans are grim realities that are imbedded in Cuban societal and cultural fibers. Despite the abolition of slavery in 1886 and its gaining of independence in 1902 Cuban society, politics, and ideology have been haunted with the specter of the ‘race issue.’ According to Aline Helg, "the myth of Cuban racial equality has proved remarkably enduring, even since the revolution of 1959" (p....   [tags: Race Racial History Historical Cuba Essays]

Free Essays
1507 words (4.3 pages)


It is only right to argue that Patrick Buchanan’s essay is only presenting the results of a problem and not the cause of it. He failed to incorporate factors such as socio-economic status and immigration background, which in someway affect the success of an individual. He states that the New York state test program was a total failure in terms of closing the achievement gap between racial groups (par.12). He also reports that 40 percent of black students and 46 percent of Hispanics students achieved standards in math compared to 75 percent white and 83 percent Asians. According to Diane Ravitch, former secretary of Education, majority of the students who will score below standards are the students from poor or minority communities where large number of children are poor and does not speak English (par. 6).
The “No Child Left Behind” directly aggravates racial inequality in our society. For one, it has failed to accomplish its goal to increased student learning and close the achievement gap. Furthermore since schools city schools curriculum such as the one in New York focuses more in state test, ignoring the student’s culture and interest, thus result in the students being kept in grade or perhaps force those students who did not meet the standards out of school in order to increase the ratio of students passing. The policy also in indirectly intensifies racial inequality in our society. It shifts our attention from focusing on fixing the actual problems that affect students such as poverty, unemployment, and housing, to list a few, to focusing on how to improve test scores.
Standardizes testing also exacerbate inequality in our society by only favoring those who are in someway are excellent in English, math, or whatever subject it may be. What about those immigrants that knows nothing about the history of America? or the Grand Canyon. What about those who just migrated in America and can barely speak English? For Amy Chua who migrated here in America along with her parents grew up only speaking their native language Chinese at home (253).
Buchanan’s notion of inequality in America is almost the norm may be valid, however he not only fails to show the definite reason in why inequalities among racial groups are the standards in America but he also fails to elaborate more on policies that make the idea of Equality really a myth.

Return to 123HelpMe.com