A debate that always seems to raise its ugly head when the issue of "foreign labor" is discussed concerns the types of jobs that immigrants take and whether they are actually taking these jobs away from American workers. I look at it as jobs they are "left with", not ones they are taking. The debate always shows an American family that has been displaced or lost their livelihood because they can no longer compete with cheaper labor. In reality the jobs that the immigrants get are the most undesirable, strenuous and dangerous ones. The only American workers that they compete with are the unskilled ones. I intend to explore if immigrants "taking" American jobs, if they are only taking the jobs that Americans don’t want or are they being forced to take certain jobs in specific industries.
As seen in Cooper’s article; The Heartland’s Raw Deal: How Meatpacking is Creating a New Immigrant Underclass, we see how companies have taken advantage and exploited the workers willing to work for less. These companies have tapped into the supply of labor that is willing to work for less than union wages. As a result of the de-unionization of the meat-packing industry, companies that were paying union wages as high as $30,000 a year were able to turn right around and hire all new workers for as little as $6. per hour. This is a big difference in pay for the same exact work. Sure, many American workers were willing to do the work, just not for the minimal wages. The meatpacking industry was able to increase profits at the expense of the American workers. The debate about whether the immigrants "took" those jobs from the American workers needs to be re-addressed to the companies that took advantage of the ...
... middle of paper ...
...rs as immigrants and minorities.
As the debate continues on whether or not immigrants and "foreigners" are crippling the American workforce, we must look at who is employing them and if American workers would actually work for the substandard wages. Does the success of corporate America depend on cheap labor to offer affordable products and services? Do we need the cheap labor to maintain our standard of living? Do we depend on it to get the jobs done that we won’t do ourselves? What would happen to the economy if the dirty jobs were paid at wages that only unions would accept? I do not think that immigrants have made American workers unemployed. I think their exploitation by corporations has pushed the American worker out of the market. Immigrants are taking the jobs that American workers don’t want at wages that no "self-respecting" American worker would take.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Immigration Reform The current immigration policy is badly in need of repairing. Its harsh treatment of immigrates has created mistrust between citizens and law enforcement, is costly in terms of clean environment, resources and human lives. Fixing this policy will vastly improve living situations for both citizens and immigrants. Although illegal immigration is against the federal law, many states believe that the government isn’t doing a very good job enforcing it. Some states, like Arizona, have came up with their own attempt in order to compensate for this issue.... [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]
1268 words (3.6 pages)
- The war on immigration has brought major controversy to the United States. Kenneth Jost, the author of an article called “Immigration Conflict”, talks about the debate people are having on aliens. He also addresses whether or not states should strictly inforce immigration laws. Jost stays impartial throughout the article but he presents good arguments for people are Pro states enforcing immigration laws and people who are against states enforcing immigration laws in order to inform the reader about what is going on.... [tags: United States, Immigration to the United States]
957 words (2.7 pages)
- Immigration debate: Immigration is a widespread problem these days. You may ask yourself what immigration means. It means to move to other country for purpose of job or permanent settlement. Illegal immigration comes into focus when people do not follow guidelines during the immigration process. For example, an abundant of paper work is required to receive immigration rights and much more. Americans see immigrants as a problem inside our borders that need to be dealt with. Over time Americans have blamed undocumented Mexican immigrants for the economic problems in the US.... [tags: Immigration to the United States]
1212 words (3.5 pages)
- Immigration Effect “We are a nation of immigrants, and that means that we’re constantly being replenished with strivers who believe in the American Dream,” stated President Obama on November 21,2014.The immigration debate on the United States has been one of the most controversial issues faced by the population. The country encounters consistent challenges regarding weak economic growth, dramatic levels, and projected growth in federal debt. The reform of immigration can raise population growth, labor force, and consequently a growth in Gross Domestic Product (GDP).... [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]
1314 words (3.8 pages)
- Reflection Paper The last two quarters have been extremely vital to changing my views of undocumented immigrants, especially undocumented students. I never particularly cared to think about their experiences beyond the fact that they are economically disadvantaged. The two quarters I have spent taking the Immigrant Rights, Labor and Higher Education course have taught me aboutvarious socioeconomicdisadvantagesundocumented immigrants face along with the anxieties that come with being the possibility of being separated from family members, deportations, the intersectionality of different identities interacting with their status.... [tags: Immigration, Immigration to the United States]
809 words (2.3 pages)
- It 's only a matter of time until the national anthem will be sung in Spanish all over our great country. The Mexican immigration and also those from South America are causing a shift in the direction that our nation is moving towards, and with each day, hundreds of illegals enter the country and there is no end in sight as well as no plan of how to act on it. While our government seems incompetent in handling the situation and deciding to either let them be or push them out we continue to have to suffer the consequences.... [tags: Immigration to the United States]
1196 words (3.4 pages)
- The immigration debate has challenged all nations with no exceptions since its founding. Hundreds of thousands of people around the world are nowadays immigrants, some of which are legally settled while other are simply not. People tend to migrate from poor countries to the developed ones, holding hopes, dreaming of brighter future, and bringing their own cultures with them. Those people choose to live abroad from where they were born. Not to mention that wars and bad governments can result in the increasing number of immigrants, but the main reason of this issue is that immigration will never stop as long as one country has a better place for living, that being said, it is governments’ resp... [tags: Immigration, Immigration to the United States]
1119 words (3.2 pages)
- In America, most jobs that are offered are better paid than what an average Mexican immigrant would be making in Mexico. Although Americans have more opportunities, not all of them take a stand to make an effort because they do not like to do the jobs that are not of quality or do not fit in their culture. As mentioned in the essay Why Americans Hate This Immigration Debate by Herbert Meyer, Meyer talks about how immigrants come to a whole new world not knowing anything besides having the desire to be an American.... [tags: Immigration to the United States]
1030 words (2.9 pages)
- The Debate in the United States over Immigration Immigration plays a huge role in the population of the United States. The U.S. is looked at as a place for a new start and a place to begin a new life. This country gives people the opportunity to make their own choices and have their own freedom, who are we to decide who can have these rights or not. Should Americans really have to right to deny another human being the right to live in this beautiful country. America is a wonderful place to live, so should immigration become legalized, meaning as soon as a foreigner steps on U.S soil should they be considered a U.S citizen or should immigration stay illegal for those who do not go thro... [tags: Immigration Emigration Migration Essays]
1304 words (3.7 pages)
- The most avidly debated effects of immigration involve the United States’ economy and labor force. It is estimated that there are 12 million undocumented immigrants in the United States today, and their impact on the economy can be perceived as positive as well as negative. The overall effect is unclear, and this essay will present both sides of the debate. Many economic factors have been influenced by an increasing number of immigrants that have entered our country. Population growth has had a direct effect on our economy.... [tags: The Immigration Debate, Economic Impact]
3521 words (10.1 pages)