The Benefits and Drawbacks of Proportional Representation Essay

The Benefits and Drawbacks of Proportional Representation Essay

Length: 877 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Every state has its own distinct electoral system in choosing their government, Britain is not an exception. It is a well-established country, which also seeks an appropriate and effective legislature. This in turn involves fair and rational voting policy and distribution of seats. During periods it had different systems of election and the current one is First-Past-The-Post (FPTP here and after). However, recently British government started to investigate its drawbacks and benefits, rationality and fairness of elections and now they are considering replacing it by Proportional Representation (PR here and after). PR is the system of election where seats in parliament are almost in same proportion as votes cast, while FPTP is one of plurality/majority systems, where parties with most votes take all and represent the whole Parliament. (accessed on http://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/) The following essay is going to analyze the benefits and drawbacks of PR and as a conclusion it will argue that this system can successfully replace FPTP in electing British Government.
To begin with advantages, PR would result in better representation of the racial and ethnic minorities (Amy 1997). These parties are awarded a constituent power at a public and regional degree in the countries exploiting this system. Western Europe and Latin America are the demonstrative examples where PR is dominant according to Andrew Reynolds and Ben Reilly (2002). Besides, imposition of this system would provide the voters with a greater amount of viewpoints, so that the candidates of Minor Parties would have more possibility to get a seat at Westminster (Amy 1997). Participation in solving governmental issues would help to develop some new concepts, which don’t a...


... middle of paper ...


...re Proportional Representation can suitably replace First Past The Post in the election of British Government and I believe that imposition of PR will influence the further prosperity of the government and the country as a whole.



Works Cited

1. Amy, J. 1997. Full Representation: The Case for a Better Election System. USA: Crescent Street Press.
2. Farrell,M. 2001. Electoral systems: A comparative introduction. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
3. Gallagher, M., and P.Mitchell. ed. 2008. The politics of electoral systems. Oxford: Oxford University Press
4. Hix, S., R.Johnston and I.Mclean 2010. A research report prepared for the British Academy. London.
5. Reynolds, A., B. Reilly and A.Ellis. 2008. Electoral System Design: The New International IDEA Handbook. Sweden: Trydells Tryckeri AB.
6. http://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/proportional_representation.htm

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Proportional Representation Voting Should Be Enforced in Democratic States

- The concept of representation in a political state that embraces a democratic system is determined by its capability to include a plurality of views when creating legislation. Election systems in a democratic government should, thus, aid and enforce the proportional representation of most politically active members of the state. As depicted by the International Institute for Democracy and Election Assistance (IDEA), “The purpose of an election is to translate the freely expressed political will of the people into a workable representative institution […] a government (i) must accurately represent the population and (ii) must be able to govern effectively.”(IDEA) These premises of a democrati...   [tags: Proportional Representation, Voting, Democracy, US]

Better Essays
903 words (2.6 pages)

The Pros and Cons of Proportional Representation (PR) Essay examples

- The results of recent elections in Britain raised many significant questions about current political situation in the country, particularly concerning electoral system. Therefore the problem of “crisis” in democracy of Britain was the subject of wide speculation among analysts and political scientists over last years. In addition it is widely recognized that the traditional electoral system in the UK-first past the post- is the main cause of that crisis and should be replaced as part of a plan to reconstitute the democratic culture (Kelly 2008)....   [tags: britain, politics]

Better Essays
1160 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Canada Should Adopt Proportional Representation

- For a democratic country to thrive, they must have a proper electoral system in producing the party to oversee our government. Since its inception in 1867, Canada has been using the first past the post system during elections to decide their leading party. Although we have been using this system for an extended duration of time, the FPTP system is flawed and should be changed. The goal of this paper is to prove the effectiveness of shifting to more of a proportional system, while also exposing the ineptness of Canada’s current system....   [tags: politics,electoral system]

Better Essays
1987 words (5.7 pages)

Essay about Canada Needs Proportional Representation

- One may be surprised to learn that the turnout rate of individuals voting in Canada's federal elections has never reached 80% (Elections Canada). In fact, it has been decreasing since the middle of the twentieth century, as shown by an increase in voter apathy. An electoral system is designed to provide those who live in democratic governments with the opportunity to vote – in an election – for the candidate whose platform coincides with their political beliefs. This can be achieved through a direct democracy, where citizens are directly involved in the decision-making process, or through an indirect democracy, where citizens elect a delegate to act on their behalf....   [tags: increase in Canadian voter apathy]

Better Essays
1686 words (4.8 pages)

Every Voice Heard: The Case for Proportional Representation Essay

- There is a fundamental problem with democracy in Canada. The problem is rooted within our federal parliamentary voting-system. However, there is a promising solution to this issue. Canada should adopt the proportional representation system, known as the party list format (party-list PR), at the federal level if we wish to promote the expansion of democracy. If Canada embraces proportional representation in the battle for electoral reform then we will see beneficial results. Party-list PR will increase voter participation, which in turn will create more accurate representation in the parliament and ultimately a positive shift away from our disturbingly partisan dominated political culture....   [tags: International Politics ]

Better Essays
2385 words (6.8 pages)

Essay on Proportional Representation

- Proportional Representation Proportional representation gives voters little say in the shape of a future government, since political parties are usually reluctant to talk about the possible structure of a coalition prior to Election Day. And because all coalition members are as eager to take the praise for government success as they are to blame other coalition members when things go wrong, it's difficult for voters to ascertain which party has done well and which ones haven't....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
709 words (2 pages)

Benefits And Drawbacks Of Health Records Essay

- BENEFITS AND DRAWBACKS OF EMRs/EHRs EHRs come with benefits and drawbacks, some of the benefits include faster care, efficiency of communication between other health professionals and saving of space due to digital records. In contrast some drawbacks include loss in productivity, learning curve, and financial issues. All the articles listed below contain further details of the benefits and drawbacks that come with EHRs and how they can be of use in the near future. Ajami, S., & Bagheri-Tadi, T. (2013)....   [tags: Electronic health record]

Better Essays
1427 words (4.1 pages)

The Benefits And Drawbacks Of Transgenic Technology Essay examples

- Nemo Li The Benefits and Drawbacks of Transgenic Technology Science in modern society is developing rapidly, which stimulates the improvement of many things, like many kinds of entertainment, electronic devices, the public transport system, and especially some new technologies. Transgenic technology, which was first utilized by Cohen in 1974, is a typical example of them. As a technology that is not very familiar to people, transgenic is a quite controversial word. In 2014, magazine Scientific American evaluated it as one of the most ten hottest words of science and technology....   [tags: Genetically modified organism]

Better Essays
1839 words (5.3 pages)

Essay on Benefits and Drawbacks of Referral Programs

- Referral programs have many different potential benefits and drawbacks for businesses. One potential benefit would be the cost of having a referral program. Word of mouth advertising costs the business virtually nothing (Small Business). Referral programs can even provide additional sales even though the company does little or no advertising (Small Business). However for employee and customer referral programs, the people get rewarded for successfully referring people to a company. Another benefit is trust....   [tags: marketing strategies ]

Better Essays
746 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Benefits and Drawbacks of International Trading

- Trading is not concept that is new. Trading can be seen from all aspects of life throughout time. Whether it is a child in a elementary school, trading a bag chips for a cupcake, or it is back two thousand years and Native Americans trading with pilgrims. The concept of international trade is not new either, but the concept of international trade has as many benefits as it has drawbacks. One of the many advantages of trading internationally is having foreign direct investment (Investopedia, Foreign Direct Investment)....   [tags: globalization, economic analysis]

Better Essays
924 words (2.6 pages)