Essay on The Sword in the Stone: Disney's Version vs. T.H. White

Essay on The Sword in the Stone: Disney's Version vs. T.H. White

Length: 1388 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The story of King Arthur is widely known, either his beginnings told in The Sword in the Stone or how he led the Knights of the Round Table. While there are many version of his story T. H. White’s written version and Disney’s animated version of The Sword in the Stone are two of the most recognized versions. Most movies have the ability to embody the original intent of the book they were based upon. Disney’s movie version of T. H. White’s rendition of The Sword in the Stone, however, while portraying the correct story, does not truly convey enough elements of White’s version to be effective in telling the original story. The characterization and Merlyn’s ‘lessons’ within the movie inhibit the film from being an effective portrayal of the book.
Disney’s rendition of T. H. White’s novel greatly misrepresents many supporting characters of the story. In the film, Wart’s foster father, Sir Ector, was depicted as completely unsupportive of everything relating to Wart. When Wart returned late from his Fish Lesson with Merlyn and tried to explain himself Sir Ector says: “That’s three demerits for being late, and three more for the fish story. Now hop it to the kitchen” (The Sword in the Stone). Another example of Sir Ector’s disapproval is how fast he was to reassign the duty of Kay’s squire to Hob, removing Wart from that title and putting him further down in the hierarchy of that time as a Page: “You said aplenty, boy! All that popping off just cooked your goose! Kay, from now on, young Hobbes is your squire. Ha! Did you hear that, Wart? Hobbes is going to be Kay's squire, hm-mmm” (The Sword in the Stone). Sir Ector’s quickness to punish Wart for every little thing he does shows how unsupportive he was of Wart. Sir Ector’s characters wa...


... middle of paper ...


...it to be a king, and the lessons in the film do not convey this fact or give him the chance to prove himself as a worthy King.
Disney’s representation of the Sword in the Stone does not depict the characters or the various lessons in a manner that successfully conveys T. H. White’s book version. Although the movie does hit the major points of Arthur’s beginning of becoming king, the over exaggeration of the characters takes away from those messages and the morals of the original story are important concepts for children to learn. By removing the original morals, the story loses its importance to the intended audience of children.



Works Cited

The Sword in the Stone. Dir. Wolfgang Reitherman. Perf. Rickie Sorensen, Sebastian Cabot, Karl Swenson. Walt Disney Productions, 1963. Film.
White, T. H.. The Sword in the Stone. New York: G.P. Putnam's Sons, 1958. Print.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Analysis Of Disney 's ' Disney ' Essay

- Many of Disney’s original movies such as snow white, sleeping beauty, and Cinderella all present perfect examples of a strong issue that has been the controversy of the 21st century. These movies bring on an obvious trend that even small children could point out. The beautiful girl is stuck in some kind of sad imprisonment(either brought upon by herself or by others) and a handsome prince sweeps her off her feet and saves the day. Which, raises an important question as to why some women wait for their prince charming to come rescue them, instead of putting on their metaphorical belt and boots and clearing their own path to the future they desire....   [tags: Woman, Girl, Man, Prince Charming]

Strong Essays
1965 words (5.6 pages)

Snow White : Walt Disney Essay

- Research Paper Deanna M. Wood Mrs. Tubergen and Mrs. Rhodes English 6 1 November 2017 LA. LA. LA. Sang your TV in your living room. You are watching your favorite childhood movie, Snow White, by Walt Disney. You love this movie because how pretty she is and amazed she became friends with the seven dwarfs, but have you event thought of the hard and difficult times Walt Disney had to deal with. Walt Disney was born on December 5, 1901 in Chicago, Illinois. When he turned 22 he started making films....   [tags: Walt Disney, Lillian Disney, Disneyland Park]

Strong Essays
836 words (2.4 pages)

Disney Studios : Disney And Disney Essay

- The Walt Disney company known generally as Disney is an American entertainment conglomerate located in Burbank, California. In terms of revenue it 's the second largest media conglomerate behind the cable giant Comcast. Disney was founded by Walt Disney and Roy O. Disney in 1923. Throughout the earliest years they established themselves as a leader in animation and live action media. Later on they would also begin to include other forms of entertainment and theme parks. It wasn 't until 1986 that the Walt Disney Studios was named what it is today Walt Disney Productions....   [tags: The Walt Disney Company, Walt Disney]

Strong Essays
816 words (2.3 pages)

The Disney Resorts : Disney And The History Of Disney Essay

- Introduction You may look at Disney and see nothing but theme parks and movies. Disney is much more than that. Disney has so much more to it; more than you could ever imagine. Not only are there theme parks involved, but there are also media networks such as: Disney Channel, ABC, Freeform, and ESPN. There are many different parks and resorts as well such as: Disneyland, Walt Disney World, and Disney Cruise Line, just to name a few. Two of the most popular studio entertainment networks are owned by Disney, which are Marvel and Pixar....   [tags: The Walt Disney Company, Walt Disney]

Strong Essays
1044 words (3 pages)

Analysis Of Disney Movies ' Career With Snow White And The Seven Dwarfs '

- Good Evening Class of 2016, As you sit here this evening on the day of your high school graduation, on the brink of your future, I would like for you—for just a moment—to stop and turn around and take a look at your past. What have you endured to reach this moment. What mistakes have you made. What have you learned. When I was thinking about what I have learned, I realized that many of the lessons in my life came from a very relatable topic—Disney movies. I think most of us grew up watching Disney movies....   [tags: The Walt Disney Company, Walt Disney]

Strong Essays
1148 words (3.3 pages)

The Little Mermaid, And Disney 's Version Of The Story Essay

- In both Hans Christian Andersons “The Little Mermaid,” and Disney’s version of the story, the main character— a young and beautiful mermaid— waits anxiously for her fifteenth birthday to venture from her father’s underwater castle to the world above the water. As the story carries on the mermaids priorities change; her modest and selfless nature is revealed towards the end in Andersen’s version. However, Disney’s version encompasses a rather shallow ending and plot throughout. The theme found in comparing the two versions reveal that Andersen’s substance trumps Disney’s entertainment factor in fairy tales....   [tags: The Little Mermaid, Hans Christian Andersen]

Strong Essays
1133 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Disney Studios : Walt Disney

- On October 16, 1923 the world was forever changed when Walt Disney founded the entertainment company known today as the Walt Disney Company. At the time known as Walt Disney Studio because Walt along with his brother Roy Disney produced several short cartoon’s titled “Alices Wonderland.” In 1927, Walt teamed up with Universal Pictures creating his first original character Oswald the Lucky Rabbit. Oswald became an instant success for Disney as Walt and Roy earned a respectable weekly salary of $100 for Walt and $65 for Roy....   [tags: The Walt Disney Company, Walt Disney]

Strong Essays
1044 words (3 pages)

Disney, By Walt Disney Essays

- Walt Disney once said, “If you can dream it, you can do it,” and he absolutely lived up to that saying. This was proved through the numerous awards he received by chasing his dreams. According to “Walt Disney Biography,” Walt Disney was born on December 5, 1901 in Chicago, Illinois. Disney had three older brothers and one younger sister, and his parent’s names were Elias Disney and Flora Call Disney (“Walt Disney Biography”). As a child, his parents moved their family from Marceline, Missouri to Kansas City, Missouri and then back to Chicago (“Walt Disney Biography”)....   [tags: Walt Disney, The Walt Disney Company]

Strong Essays
1232 words (3.5 pages)

The Disney Princesses Essay

- Disney has been an inspiration to kids since October 16, 1923. With the start of Mickey Mouse cartoons, Disney has created an empire of imagination. Ever since Snow White, Disney’s first princess in 1937, came on the screen, young females have been amazed by the vision of the “Disney Princess”. As the years went by, dozens of princesses have hit movie screens and Disney has made billions off of the profits from these individuals. In reality, Disney has influenced the immature views of what to expect of beauty from a woman....   [tags: Walt Disney, Cartoons, Children, View on Women]

Strong Essays
1734 words (5 pages)

Essay on The Sword in the Stone by T.H. White

- It’s everywhere. It surrounds me and tracks me down like an unyielding shadow. I often ponder about this magical illusion that I am enveloped in, and find myself dumbfounded with the outcome. What is it. How can I rid of this “thing'; that tugs on my sleeve and has me tied down relentlessly. There’s no explanation, it’s just there. Itlingers mysteriously above my head as if a lonely moon hung high in the midnight sky,illuminating a faint glimmer of mist above the surface of the dark pool water....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1019 words (2.9 pages)