Levi understands that selection is an arbitrary process. As Levi comments, “the important thing for the Lager is not that the most useless prisoners be eliminated, but that free posts be quickly created” (129). Selection is so frivolous that Levi and Alberto determine that when René is selected to be sent to the gas chambers and Levi is not, that it was “probable” (128) that this was due to a “mistake with [their] cards” (128). Because selection is a mostly indiscriminate process, Levi understands that prisoners have little bearing on their own survival. The Nazis were determined to kill a certain number of prisoners, and it made little difference to the Nazis which prisoners were sent to die. It is moments after the selection of October 1944 that the passage takes place. In this passage we witness the responses of several prisoners to selection, as narrated by Levi. Levi's perception of the situation is shaped by his understanding that survival in the Lager is due to fluke.
... middle of paper ...
...lection. This choice is not something that Kuhn should be thankful for.
This passage ends with Levi bitterly remarking, “If I was God, I would spit at Kuhn's prayer” (130). It is through this line that we realize Levi is not condemning Kuhn. Levi does in fact realize Kuhn is an old man, whose body and spirit had been crushed by the Nazis, just as Levi's, and the other prisoners' bodies and spirits, and Kuhn is merely attempting to comfort himself. Besides the fact that the Germans legally considered Kuhn a Jew, we know nothing of Kuhn's religious beliefs and practices, and so his “prayer” could have been a mere secular utterance the way a present day American college student “thanks God” for a snow day. Yet it is Kuhn's “prayer,” and the sentiment it contains, that Levi finds troubling, both for the deceased prisoners, and those prisoners still temporarily living.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- In all of human history there have been countless tragedies in which men and women have faced atrocities against them and their communities. One of the most debilitating acts of hatred is that of genocide. Genocide is the deliberate extermination of a particular group of people based on severe prejudice. Cultural genocide also exists as a way to exterminate a specific culture, leaving survivors broken and displaced. Incredibly, survivors of genocide who have had every reason to give up on life, against all odds, instead manage to persevere.... [tags: Auschwitz concentration camp, Extermination camp]
879 words (2.5 pages)
- “He cut into me, without anesthetic, . . .The pain was indescribable. I felt every slice of the knife. Then I saw my kidney pulsating in his hand. I cried like a madman, I cried out the prayer; ‘Hear, O Israel: the Lord our God, the Lord is one . . . And I prayed to die, that I might not suffer this agony any more’” (Hall). This was said by a ‘patient’ of Dr. Josef Mengele, Mr.Yitzhak Ganon. Mr. Ganon was of the survivors of the inhumane experiments that took place in Auschwitz by the hand of the abominable man that is Josef Mengele.... [tags: angel of death, evil, eugenics]
1323 words (3.8 pages)
- ... He belittles everyone around him including his second wife Mala making them feel unloved. "Mainly I remember arguing with him...and being told that I couldn't do anything as well as he could," Art tells his therapist (during the course of losing his mother). "No matter what I accomplish, it doesn't seem like much compared to surviving Auschwitz" (MAUS 2 44). It's obviously showed that with Vladek actions towards people we can understand why they feel so low. Vladek throughout the story, he stresses the importance of his heart (comparing himself of how heroic and very strong he use to be).... [tags: auschwitz , memories, prisoners]
923 words (2.6 pages)
- Denial of Life is Wrong What if people said your life never happened. People who lived through the Holocaust have to live with Holocaust deniers saying their life never happened. Holocaust survivors find this hurtful. If someone said your life never happened you would be just as mad as the Holocaust survivors. This is why Holocaust deniers are wrong because there were concentration camps, people lived through it, and there are artifacts from the Holocaust. After the Holocaust there were leftover concentration camps.... [tags: nazi, Auschwitz, jews]
885 words (2.5 pages)
- Since the Holocaust, a theory has emerged on the real reason Jews were forced into concentration camps. Controversy surrounds this theory, between those who claim, Jews were being exterminated inside concentration camps and those who disagree, claiming that this event never occurred in the camps. The theory began at the start of the Holocaust when the Nazis established concentration camps around Poland. Yet to this day, some skeptics are unclear whether these camps were built for forced labor or extermination.... [tags: Auschwitz, concentration camps, Nazis, Jews]
1040 words (3 pages)
- A 40 acre piece of land is attributed for over 2 million deaths, this is more than the total number of British and American soldiers combined that died in World War II. This small acreage was called Auschwitz and to the prisoners who stayed and died there it caused both mental and physical inhumanity to them. Mental inhumanity is an act against someone or a group of people, which is considered immorally wrong, on which affects their thoughts or feelings. Physical inhumanity is an act against a person or people which is considered immorally wrong, on which affects their body and health.... [tags: History, Auschwitz ]
1850 words (5.3 pages)
- Night by Elie Wiesel is one man’s story of surviving the holocaust and his struggle with maintaining relationships with his family and other Jews as they are dehumanized by their captivity and conditions. Through the characterization in the book as well as through the recounting of his journey, itself, Wiesel tells the story of how humankind can dehumanize others and cause the captives to also begin to dehumanize one another. Elie Weisel had three siblings, an unsentimental father, and mother who owned and helped run their family store.... [tags: Auschwitz concentration camp, Elie Wiesel]
2394 words (6.8 pages)
- Then with no more thought than she put into what to have for dinner she sentenced countless women to die in the gas chambers. The captives stood in the freezing cold or blistering heat, in mud and muck for hours at a time waiting to see who would be chosen to die at each selection. In Anatomy of Auschwitz Death Camp, Danuta Czech stated, “The highest number of such deaths was in February 1943, when 25.5 percent of all Auschwitz inmates died or were put to death.” Irma Grese and Dr. Josef Mengele many times made these selections together.... [tags: Auschwitz concentration camp]
1439 words (4.1 pages)
- Imagine one day waking up and leaving your family, your house, your possessions, and your life behind. You do not know where you’re going, or how long it will take to arrive at a destination. You are thrown into a cramped, small space with hundreds of strangers; some dead and some dying. It’s hard to stay positive in a situation like this. You have no clue what it is going on. You are on your way to the most deadly and most well known concentration camp. Its name is Auschwitz. The thought of ever leaving this place is the only hope that you and those have around you, and chances are slim.... [tags: Auschwitz concentration camp, Adolf Hitler]
1529 words (4.4 pages)
- Primo Levi's Survival in Auschwitz Reading the novel Survival in Auschwitz by author Primo Levi leads one to wonder whether his survival is attributed to his indefinite will to survive or a very subservient streak of luck. Throughout the novel, he is time and again spared from the fate that supposedly lies ahead of all inhabitants of the death camp at Auschwitz. Whether it was falling ill at the most convenient times or coming in contact with prisoners who had a compassionate, albeit uncommon, disposition, it would seem as though the Gods were always smiling upon him.... [tags: Primo Levi Survival Auschwitz Essays]
1597 words (4.6 pages)
- How much does Napoleon owe to the French Revolution?
- Persuasive Speech: You Can Stop the Genocide in Darfur
- House, M.D.- An Allegory for the Effects of Postmodernism on Society
- Peer Pressure and Adolescent Delinquency
- The Unheroic Traits of Odysseus in Homer's The Odyssey
- The Transformation of Battlefield Tactics During World War I