Essay on Superiority of the International Court of Justice

Essay on Superiority of the International Court of Justice

Length: 2819 words (8.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Introduction
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is an important organ of the United Nations. Actually it is the UN's principal judicial arm used to foster international peace. It was established after the League of the Nation and its judicial organ the Permanent Court of International Justice (PCIJ) were dissolved after the Second World War, in 1946. Its main purpose is to support the UN (which was formed in 1945) in its endeavour in promoting international peace and law . Important to note is the fact that this court, although referred to in a non-technical context as the world court, does not automatically possess compulsory international jurisdiction. The treaty creating this court, referred to as the stature of international court of justice, provides an option for member states to chose whether to be subjected to the court international compulsory jurisdiction or not. A state once it decides to be subjected to this compulsory jurisdiction is still at liberty of setting condition that will shield it against adverse implication of the subjection. This provision gives mainly powerful states undue advantage over less powerful ones when it comes to international matters. For instance they can easily decide not to attend the court proceeding, and if they attend they refuse to abide to the court ruling without facing serious implications .
The lack of automatic international compulsory jurisdiction renders ICJ inferior. Therefore the argument that referring to this court as the ‘World Court’ implies it is superior; an international equivalent of a national supreme court is null and void. Generally a supreme court is the highest ranking court. Its ruling is not subject to further review and therefore the disputing parties ha...


... middle of paper ...


...., Raič, and Thuránszky J., The International Court of Justice: its future role after fifty
years ( Boston: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1997).

Powell, Emilia and Mitchell, Sara M., ‘The International Court of Justice and the World’s Three
Legal Systems’ The Journal of Politics, 69/2 (2007), 397-415.

Posner, Erick and Figueiredo, Miguel., ‘Is the International Court of Justice Biased?’ JOHN M.
OLIN LAW & ECONOMICS WP, 234/2 (2004), 1-43.

Shimko, K. L., International Relations: Perspectives and Controversies (Boston: Wadsworth,
2009).
Tanzi, Attila., Problems of Enforcement of Decisions of the International Court of Justice and the Law of the United Nations, EJIL, 6, (1995) 539-572.
Warioba*, Joseph., ‘Monitoring Compliance with and Enforcement of Binding Decision of
International Courts’ Max Planck Yearbook of United Nation Law, 5 (2001), 41-52.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The European Court of Justice and its Interlocutors Essay

- Member state governments of the European Community began with a fundamental role in making EC policies and standards; but throughout the 1960s and 1970s the European Court of Justice gradually began to expand its role and developed an unprecedented regime comparable to the constitutional order of a federal state. The ECJ permitted itself to decide on matters traditionally considered to be the exclusive competence of member states; including social policy, gender equality and competition policy. Remarkably, the majority of national courts and governments of the member states have conformed to ECJ rulings and have harmoniously surrendered their jurisdiction over key policy areas – deferring to...   [tags: policies, standards, federal state]

Better Essays
1835 words (5.2 pages)

International criminal court Essay

- ICC and America Over the past few years, the International Criminal Court (ICC or “the Court”) has been igniting controversy the world over. As more countries rallied behind it, more objections have been made, particularly from Americans, regarding what many view as fundamental flaws. I have chosen two papers to compare and contrast the different viewpoints taken by the authors when reflecting upon America’s involvement with the ICC. One calls for total rejection of the ICC, the other weighs the risks and benefits and calls for revision but acceptance....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Better Essays
959 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Earl Warren: Chief Justice for the United States

- History isn’t made when it happens; it’s made because of the impacts on the national and international level. Often times, it is a small event that triggers a large reaction from the public. Often times, it is one person who can make a difference in the world. Earl Warren was one person that made a difference to Americans in the mid-1900s. From working in a law office to becoming the governor of California to appointed Chief Justice of the United States Supreme Court in 1953, Earl Warren had built up tremendous support....   [tags: Discrimination, Law, Changes]

Better Essays
743 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on The International Criminal Court ( Icc )

- The International Criminal Court (ICC) is dependent upon ratification from states that are willing to give up their own jurisdiction in order to have a stronger enforcement of international crimes. Without support from major states, the ICC will continue to struggle in following through with its promise to promote its main purposes, “justice, peace, and stability” (Simmons, 226). The International Criminal Court has many merits, but also has many weaknesses, but based on the provided articles, I personally believe that the International Criminal Court is an organization worthy of my support....   [tags: Human rights, Law, International Criminal Court]

Better Essays
1996 words (5.7 pages)

The World Conference On Human Rights Essay

- Moreover, according to Hanna Arendt, the magnitude of the European refugee crisis also propelled human rights to the centre of post-war international politics. Forced displacements as a result of the Second World War, the Holocaust, the Cold War and then later anticommunists escapees was on such a large scale it made a huge impact on the encountering nations, and the international enforcement and protection of innocent civilians (Hoffman, 2010). There were approximately eight million civilians who qualified as "displaced persons" under the United Nations Relief and Rehabilitation Administration, including: slave labourers, prisoners of war, liberated concentration camp inmates, with most of...   [tags: Human rights, Amnesty International]

Better Essays
1066 words (3 pages)

Is International Law Really Law? Essay

- What is international law and is international law really considered to be law; the answer to these questions can be found in the examples of different international resolutions. Some of these examples of when the law has been followed and upheld can be called law can be found in the examples of New Zealand v. France with the bombing and sinking of the Greenpeace vessel. Another example can be seen in the case of the Islamic Republic of Iran v. Untied States of America in regards to the United States shooting down an Iranian commercial aircraft....   [tags: international court of justice]

Better Essays
1727 words (4.9 pages)

The New Terrain of International Law Reaction Paper

- "The New Terrain of International Law Reaction Paper " The author in this paper is presenting the new style of international courts. The new international judicial architecture that review administrative decisions validity, asses state compliance with international law, influence international and domestic politics, serving as a regulative role of creating guidelines and setting expectations and allowing private parties to seek remedies with international legal bodies. The authors theory is that international courts alter politics through alliance with compliance constituencies....   [tags: international court of justice, ]

Better Essays
818 words (2.3 pages)

Essay The Court System And The Justice System

- In a governmental context, it can be argued that a court system that does not present a unified position when dealing with legislative and executive branch entities is not, in fact, an equal branch of government. The court system, as a whole, and the Supreme Court itself, in most cases where it is involved, want and need to speak in one voice, with a unified message. This, however, is not always the reality that we see. There are sometimes cases where the justices cannot agree on the outcome. Although the outcome favored by the majority always prevails, the dissenting sometimes choose to voice their disagreement in a public opinion in order to advocate for a different policy they themselves...   [tags: Law, Appeal, Court, Court systems]

Better Essays
1238 words (3.5 pages)

The International Court of Justice Essay

- The International Court of Justice International Court Of Justice (ICJ) is the principal of the United Nations Judicial organ of the United Nations, which succeeded the Permanent court of International Justice after World War Two. It gains its legitimacy from Article 92 of the UN Charter, which allows it to function " in accordance with the annexed Statute, which is based upon The Statute of the Permanent Court of International Justice and forms an integral part of the present Charter". By Article 93 all members of the UN are ipso-facto members of The Statute and that states not members may become parties, on conditions to be determined in each case by the UN General Assembly on Recommenda...   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
1304 words (3.7 pages)

International Criminal Court Essay

- The International Criminal Court (ICC) is a relatively new organization; only just a decade old and it has seen a great deal of hardships and success. Since the creation of ICC it has seen a vast deal of criticisms that “[range] from concerns about racism and neocolonialism” and so forth. Not only has it encountered criticisms, but as well, people have questioned the usefulness of this organization. In truth, is it necessary to question the value, based on what little it has accomplished and in addition to, the amount of wealth it needs to stay buoyant....   [tags: Rome Statute, Global Justice]

Better Essays
2912 words (8.3 pages)