Sula versus The Great Gatsby

Sula versus The Great Gatsby

Length: 996 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
The American Dream: Is Betterment Worth It?

Through the years, the inhabitants of America have been mobile people. The Native Americans moved according to the seasons and the migration of animals; the first Spanish settlers moved to find gold; the European colonists moved for land; and in the past weeks, Southerners have been moving to escape tragedy. Although these four major diasporas seem to have individual reasons, all four share one common root: the American Dream - an urge to improve a given lifestyle by making a drastic change. In their respective books, The Great Gatsby and Sula, F. Scott Fitzgerald and Toni Morrison display this phenomenon by creating characters that will do anything to better their personal lives; however, both writers incorporate great failure into the lives of their main characters, thus dismissing the idealistic thoughts of the American Dream.
From a young age, James Gatz has plans to change his social status; he plans his days hour by hour; forfeits his given name for a new one; deserts his home, family and friends; and most importantly picks up a job as a bootlegger to make his desired sum of money. The schedule taken from an old book of James' shows his plan for an entire day and includes a list of "GENERAL RESOLVES (Fitzgerald, 173)," both of which show a general urge for success. James' resolve to, ‘save $3.00 per week (Fitzgerald, 173), displays an early understanding of the American dream and the necessity of money. His further understanding of the way life works is expressed through the action of changing his name from James Gatz to Jay Gatsby, a name that seems to flow easier and deserve a greater deal of respect than his previous, harsh name of James Gatz. His new name, in essence, opens up a new life for Gatsby, and allows him to start over the way he wants to. Gatsby's next choice, to abandon his home, family, and friends in order to sail aboard a yacht for years with a near stranger, displays Gatsby's belief that living a fanciful life aboard a yacht will enable him to lead a fantastic lifestyle in all aspects of his living. Finally, it is at this point where Gatsby makes the biggest decision of his life, solely on the belief that a high income will bring him happiness, and ultimately the love of his life; Gatsby chooses to accept partnership with a man working as a bootlegger of grain alcohol.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Sula versus The Great Gatsby." 21 Aug 2018

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Lies and Deciet in The Great Gatsby

- Lying has deadly effects on both the individual who lies and those around them. This concept is demonstrated in The Great Gatsby. Although Gatsby, Tom and Myrtle have different motives for being deceitful, they all lie in order to fulfill their desires and personal needs. Myrtle’s desire to be wealthy is illustrated when she first meets Tom, dressed in his expensive clothing, as her attitude changes when she puts on the luxurious dress and when she encourages Tom to buy her a dog. Tom’s deception is clear when he hides his affair with Myrtle by placing Myrtle in a different train, withholding the truth from Mr....   [tags: The Great Gatsby]

Research Papers
1131 words (3.2 pages)

In The Great Gatsby, Is Gatsby Truly Great? Essay

-   Is great Gatsby truly great. It seems so according to Nick Carraway, the narrator in the novel of “The Great Gatsby.” Nick has a moral background that allows him to judge Jay Gatsby accordingly. His descriptions did not only creates sympathy, but also made Gatsby, the outlaw bootlegger, somehow admirable. F. Scott Fitzgerald presented this ethical trick to expose people’s delusions about the American dream, and uses Nick to show sympathy for strivers.   At the roaring ages of 1920s, the booming economy brings up the notion of American dream....   [tags: The Great Gatsby Essays]

Research Papers
845 words (2.4 pages)

The Grand Illusion in The Great Gatsby Essays

- The American dream is a farce. Hopeful American children and quixotic foreigners believe that freedom will lead to prosperity, and that prosperity will bring happiness. This anticipation of joy will never come to fruition, and all these unfortunate people will feel that they were cheated out of happiness by some unlucky roll of dice, but really they have been chasing cars, because the American dream is not something one can truly capture, but only smoke trapped in the palm of a hand. In The Great Gatsby, Jay Gatsby’s lavish parties, characterized by music, dancing, and illegal alcohol, are a representation of the corruption of society’s values, and are filled with guests only concerned with...   [tags: The Great Gatsby]

Research Papers
827 words (2.4 pages)

The Great Gatsby Essay

- There is vast and deep connection between the author’s life and the novel. The author portrayed his real life-based situation in the novel through which he went. The author explained how seventeen-year-old young lady became the reason of his downfall. He fell and wanted to marry the girl named Zelda Sayre who had deep desire for Fitzgerald’s wealth, fame, money and material luxury. Both Gatsby and Fitzgerald idolize wealth and luxury and at last fell in love with a beautiful woman when they stopped at a military camp in the South....   [tags: The Great Gatsby Essays]

Research Papers
1290 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on The Great Gatsby and the Great Depression

- The Great Gatsby and the Great Depression       When F. Scott Fitzgerald published The Great Gatsby in 1925, it was impossible for him to predict that only four years later his story would be enacted in real-life during the Great Depression.  There are many prophetic symbols in the novel that tie The Great Gatsby and the Great Depression together.               The twenties was a decade full of new financial opportunities in a society unable to adopt so much so quickly.  All of the new possibilities, such as credit and loans, led to greater debts and bigger holes to fill.  Society began getting too deeply in debt and was becoming increasingly unable to get itself out.  So, they began se...   [tags: Great Gatsby Essays]

Research Papers
1140 words (3.3 pages)

The Great Gatsby Essay: The Great Gatsby is Not So Great

- The Great Gatsby is Not The novel has no plot to mention. ... The book is highly sensational, loud, blatant, ugly, pointless. There seems to be no reason for its existence Harvey Eagleton (Dallas Morning News, May 10, 1925). F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby is an absurd story, whether considered as romance, melodrama, or plain record of New York high life.  The occasional insights into character stand out as very green oases on an arid desert of waste paper.  Throughout the first half of the book the author shadows his leading character in mystery, but when in the latter part he unfolds his life story it is difficult to find the brains, the cleverness, and the glamour that one migh...   [tags: Great Gatsby Essays]

Free Essays
505 words (1.4 pages)

Conflicting Perspective in The Great Gatsby Essay

- The 1920s prove to be an era that brought around some of the greatest influences and some of the greatest controversies. In the 1920s, there began to be a schism in the beliefs of prohibition, personal freedoms, and class separation. Traditionalist believed that people were running ramped drink and being promiscuous. Modernists were out to seek personal freedoms, such drinking, sexual experimental, women coming out of their stereotypical roles of being reserved and prude. Classes divided because some people had inherited wealth and other had work hard to earn their money....   [tags: The Great Gatsby F. Scott Fitzgerald]

Research Papers
1201 words (3.4 pages)

The Great Gatsby Essay

- The Great Gatsby The Great Gatsby belongs to what Harold Bloom tags the “tomb” of literary archetypes, a family of fiction that espouses every facet of the expressive use of language (everything from Shakespeare’s plays to Dickens’ prose). As a participant in this tomb, The Great Gatsby has adopted a convenient persona in the world of twentieth century literature as “the great American novel,” a work that embodies the American thematic ideals of the self-made man, the great American character—Jay Gatsby....   [tags: Great Gatsby Fitzgerald Papers]

Research Papers
2601 words (7.4 pages)

The Great Gatsby Essay

- The Great Gatsby is a thrilling tale about a very wealthy man named Gatsby. The story is told through the eyes of the narrator, Nick Carraway. In the beginning Nick is showed as someone for all people to tell their problems. They vent their anger and frustration to him. Nick meets Tom and Daisy Buchanan. Nick is not very fond of Tom. Nick then becomes acquainted with Jordan Baker, whom happens to be a golf champion. Baker is portrayed as snotty and stuck up. Hints then begin to arise that there are problems between Daisy and Tom....   [tags: The Great Gatsby F. Scott Fitzgerald]

Free Essays
911 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on The Great Gatsby

- In the novel The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald, Jay Gatsby is a mysterious man living in the West Egg district of Long Island. Gatsby is extremely wealthy and owns a mansion with a large swimming pool, a fancy car, and dozens of servants. Every Saturday night, he throws extravagant parties which many people, most of whom haven't even been invited, attend. No one really knows anything about Gatsby, except that he is rich and generous. However, many rumors are created about him. Some say that he was a German spy during the war and some say that he killed a man....   [tags: The Great Gatsby F. Scott Fitzgerald]

Free Essays
1016 words (2.9 pages)

Related Searches

This choice to partake in a pure crime in order make big money illustrates Gatsby's almost unfathomable desire to achieve the American Dream: to be wealthy and live the easy life, regardless of the past. On the contrary, while Gatsby is allegedly succeeding by the standards of the American Dream, he is tragically failing in what he most desired to accomplish: winning the heart of the beautiful Daisy Fay. Furthermore, Gatsby also fails by dying alone with no one to pass on his wealth to and no one to mourn his death. Over the years Gatsby's drive for success opens up a lifestyle of false self gratitude and false accomplishment of the American Dream, in which he believes everyone loves him which ultimately is shown to be untrue.
Sula, similar to James Gatz, has the same desire to reach for the cherished American Dream of betterment; thus she longs to leave her house of disarray (Morrison, 51-52) in the Bottom and create a new lifestyle for herself. Foremost, from a young age Sula shows the determination that is thought of as a necessity in order to achieve her goal; with pure determination she cuts off her own finger in order to prove to a group of bullies that she is tougher than they are (Morrison, 54). This is the same determination that most likely drives Sula to pick up and move out of the Bottom during Nel's wedding party (Morrison, 85). Furthermore, Sula's taking of her deceased younger brother's insurance money to pay for college shows her drive to better herself, in this case by earning a college degree. Unfortunately, the line, "Accompanied by a plague of robins (Morrison, 89)" opens an image of sickness and disease upon Sula's arrival back in the Bottom, and shows how unsuccessful she was; she left town in order to raise her social status, but it seems as though she did just the opposite. Sula's next attempt at raising her social status, sleeping with prominent men, ultimately brings her to an even lower nadir in class. Almost immediately after coming home she is found sleeping with Jude, Nel's husband. This action can only be explained by a near ruthless desire for betterment; Sula risked ruining her friendship with her life long best friend just in order to be looked at with higher regard in society because she slept with a well to do man. Finally, as in Gatsby, Sula's utter failure is shown at her deal bth; the exclamation, from the few that attended her burial, that "a brighter day was dawning (Morrison, 151)"clearly shows how much the community despised Sula, thus shows her definitive failure at achieving the Great American Dream.
Although there have been many attempts at betterment throughout American history, no two stories describe the drive and failure of Americans better than The Great Gatsby and Sula. In each book the hero/in does anything and everything possible to achieve his/her dream, and in each book s/he, in the end, fails. However, without the false notion that the American Dream is capable of achieving, the world would not be the same; Columbus' men may not have ventured further than the Bahamas; colonial Europeans may not have experienced the great land grab throughout the northeast; and finally, Americans may not have ever settled in Hawaii, a prime American vacation destination.
Return to