Should dolphins be given “Non-Person rights” as a intelligent species? Recently scientists have been calling for increased protection of dolphins because there is evidence that they are highly intelligent and capable of abstract thought; however the consequences of grating them more protection than they have now would be economically devastating. Dolphins have been regarded as a intelligent species for many years, in the last couple years there has been a lot more research into their intelligence. The Question of whether they should be given special protection has come up and this essay will examine the argument between the morality and economic benefits and consequences of giving them these rights.
Through numerous tests, Dolphins have been shown to be capable of recognising themselves in mirrors (Psarakos). Until recently, only humans and certain primates have been able to recognise themselves as a reflection in mirror, this is an important indicator of animals being able to meta-cognate, or think about thinking. This in turn indicates a degree of sapience (Sternberg). If they are proven to be a sapient species rather than a instinctive one, scientists are calling for them to be protected on the same level as humans. Dolphins have also been shown to be capable of planning for the future and have a sense of delayed gratification. A typical case is dolphins picking up trash in their tank and giving it to their trainer in exchange for a fish as a reward. From this action-reward comes the emergent behaviour of the dolphins hoarding trash and delivering it piece by piece to maximise rewards (Ultimate Guide: Dolphins).
There is also evidence that dolphins are able to communicate abstract spatial ideas such as left and right. A...
... middle of paper ...
...hysical Data Center (NGDC) Home Page. Web. 07 Feb. 2010.
"Global Trade - Food & Water Watch." Food & Water Watch. Web. 07 Feb. 2010. .
Greenberg, Paul. "A Fish Oil Story." New York Times. New York TImes, 15 Dec. 2009. Web. 07 Feb. 2010.
"The Panama Canal Effect." The Economist 03 Dec. 2009. The Economist. 03 Dec. 2009. Web. 07 Feb. 2010.
Psarakos, Suchi, and Kenneth Marten. Self-awareness in Animals and Humans: Developmental Perspectives. New York: Cambridge UP, 1995. Print.
Raloff, Janet. "Preserving Paradise." Science News 170 (2006): 92. Print.
Sternberg, Robert J. Wisdom, Intelligence, and Creativity Synthesized. New York: Cambridge UP, 2003. Print.
"Ultimate Guide: Dolphins." Tursiops.org. Web. 07 Feb. 2010.
"WWF - Poorly managed fishing." WWF - Poorly Managed Fishing. Web. 07 Feb. 2010.
Is a dolphin a person? Most people would automatically dismiss the question, but in reality, this question can be discussed on a very complex level revealing that the definition of a person is not so black and white. Mary Midgley sets the stage to her narrative by telling the story of a specific court case that she uses as a reference on many occasions. In May of 1977, two men set free two dolphins who were used by the University of Hawaii’s Institute of Marine Biology for experimentation. Kenneth
believe is based on a human’s ability to empathise, it is thought the uncomfortable feeling of seeing another suffer pushes us to prevent the suffering. It can be viewed as the governing principal that allows us to know the difference between what is right and wrong, it drives us to act in a way which allows other beings we exist with to have a positive experience, preventing suffering. This is why irreprehensible acts such as mental abuse, physical and sexual assault and murder are considered just so
bond to the ocean. This cultural bond is displayed in various forms such as their artwork, history, and lore. One key aspect of their culture has come scrutiny within the past twenty years—whaling. Since 1855, the Makah people have legally held the right to whale in designated waters around their reservation. In the 1920’s, the Makah decided to halt whaling due to a dwindling population of the whales. In 1986, the International Whaling Commission enacted a global moratorium on commercial whaling with
Marys in Ohio. Since that day they have expanded their range of oil drilling, and our ecosystems are now paying the price for it. I think that offshore oil drilling should be banned because it is ruining the environment, hurting marine wildlife, and even has a negative affect on us humans. The first reason why offshore drilling should be stopped is because of how harmful it is to the environment. One way this is hurting the environment is because of a term called fracking, fracking is when a pressurized
I could feel the boat underneath, being pulled down into the watery nightmare, as the boat begins to fill with water, just like a bathtub, covering my lower body. There was a hole at the right hand side of the boat, about 3 inches in diameter, increasing in size as the waves continue to tease, and my boat continues to creak. I pulled my hand out and touched the deadly water, waiting for it to pull me in, since there was absolutely no use
society, the citizens presume the right to make laws that reflect their deepest values, yet this is no longer the case. With the emergence of the World Trade Organization (WTO), democracy has been abandoned. It no longer matters what the democratic societies want, but what the global corporations want. Created in 1994, the WTO is already among the most powerful, reserved, undemocratic bodies on earth. It has been granted with vast powers, which include the right to judge whether laws of nations
need to reinforce our nuclear plants. We need to retrain and support our emergency responders. We need to make sure that we can survive the unthinkable, because that seems a more likely threat. The Media is following the dollars and perhaps so should our government. I am not arguing Fallows’ point. Instead, I am more concerned with what comes next. Perhaps we have to leave behind what we know in order to discover what is to come. Works Cited http://www.sentencingproject.org/template/index
Philosopher A: Augustus saved the republic. Philosopher B: Saved it? He turned it into an empire! Augustus ruined the republic. Philosopher A: In the Republic, the Senate was the primary branch of the Roman government and held the majority of the political power. It controlled funds, administration and foreign policy, and had significant influence of the everyday life of the Roman people. When Augustus came to power, he kept the Senate and they retained their legal position. The Emperor’s rule
psychologically. This essay will argue that owning and training circus animals to perform for human entertainment is a blatantly unacceptable practice from an ethical perspective, and, hence, that humans have an obligation to appropriately uphold the ethical rights of circus animals. In doing so, three main points will be argued. Firstly, investigations will be undertaken to gauge the quality of life of circus animals. More specifically, the treatment and training methods of circus animals will be examined
On April 20, 2010, the Gulf of Mexico experienced a disaster unprecedented in scale and environmental impact. Fifty miles off the coast of Louisiana in the deep waters of the Gulf of Mexico, a BP drilling rig suffered an explosion that claimed eleven lives and caused the rig to sink over 5000 ft. to the sea bed floor. This was the beginning of the BP oil spill which spanned over eighty seven days, releasing an approximate 2.3 million barrels of crude oil into the Gulf of Mexico. Although the flow
(Gibbs). Refusing to show honor and gratitude towards our military members has become the common issue all over the United States involving citizens of all different ages, races, and professions. While some Americans believe it is a constitutional right to be a able to express one’s beliefs, others would strongly disagree. Buffalo Bills Coach Rex Ryan voiced his opinion on "The Star-Spangled Banner," suggesting that he highly
chairs on a beach and occupying each seat is a male college student. One guy has no shirt on and is wearing a hat. With a smile on his face, he looks to his right. The two guys sitting to his left are each reading a magazine. All three men seem to be enjoying the hot weather and the one looking to his right is enjoying a beer. Coming up on his right are three beautiful girls in bikinis. One girl is blonde, very well developed, and as she walks by you can see her breasts move back and forth with every