The Struggles Indigenous Peoples Face to Obtain Justice Essay

The Struggles Indigenous Peoples Face to Obtain Justice Essay

Length: 1571 words (4.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

There are over 5000 Indigenous communities in over 70 different countries. They are defined collectively under the term Indigenous Peoples (IPs) by the Cobo Report but this term also allows for their diversity. They face numerous legal issues in attempting to achieve their rights, so they have collectively united to access the remedies available to them to achieve justice.

Broad characteristics to define them are highlighted in the Mick Dodson report and include: connection with territory that pre dates invasion, social and cultural traditions such as affinity with the land and colonisation, resistance and resurgence.

The issues facing IPs is the struggle to collectively achieve four rights which are recognised under in international law. Self identification is the ability for a group to choose if that person is a member of that group and for an individual to identify themselves as belonging to that group. The problems with achieving this right is demonstrated in the 2002 Good Weekend Article "A white shade of Black" which highlighted a court case in Tasmania to judge who could vote in ATSIC elections.



Cultural integrity is the right of IPs to practice and preserve cultural traditions such as affinity with the land while also allowing them to access modem innovations. This is seen through the Inuit people of where who maintain a traditional life but use snow mobiles for hunting. Self determination is described by the United Nations Charter as the ability to "freely pursue their economic, social and political development". However the term "peoples" refers to post WWII decolonisation and there are questions as to whether it can apply to IPs.

Sovereignty is the ability of a people to form a nation-state, which has c...


... middle of paper ...


...002 shows how ineffective intergovernmental organisations are for IPs issues.

East Timor gained sovereignty after decades of colonisations in March 2002.

It can be seen to be fairly ineffective due to resource efficiency as it took 25 years. Also, it needed human rights abuses to occur before UN decided to send an INTERFET force under Australia. The documentary "A birth of a nation" also highlights that political will from Australia to act only came after economic interest in the North West oil shelf.

Therefore it can be seen that the remedies available to IPs to gain their rights and save their legal issues in only effective when political will of nation states allows international law to be effective in their own states. Accessibility to UN is also a problem. So sovereignty is seen as the ability to remedy IPs issues and also as the obstacle to saving them.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Aborigines During The Colonization Of Canada Essay

- The Aboriginals have suffered greatly during the colonization of Canada. There were genocides, the destruction of their tribes, their land being taken away from them, and an attempt to destroy their culture. Indigenous children were taken away from their parents and sent into residential schools in order to remodel them into the eyes of the European settlers, and there are still vast amounts of unfair treatment of the First Natives with the small land reserves they are given and racism that they face....   [tags: Indigenous peoples, Culture, United States]

Powerful Essays
1021 words (2.9 pages)

Indigenous Peoples And Indigenous Cultures Essay

- The Indigenous Peoples Movement works to acquire legal protection and works to raise awareness towards the indigenous peoples’ causes globally. Indigenous peoples are generally defined as individuals who belong to a highly conservative, culturally and linguistically different non-dominant social group,—distinct from the modernly dominant society—hoping to maintain that separation with the superior culture. In addition, their cultures and traditional practices have been harmed over the centuries—complications arising from the European colonial era; still, many negative affections remain influencing their economic situations in the modern century....   [tags: Indigenous Australians, Indigenous peoples]

Powerful Essays
899 words (2.6 pages)

Essay Indigenous Religions Of Indigenous Peoples

- Indigenous religions are religions that originated naturally in a particular place, or region. Indigenous religion is often separated by scholars, from world religions such as Christianity or Buddhism. These religions do not, however, make up one large religion called indigenous. “The term “indigenous” is a generalized reference to the thousands of small scale societies who have distinct languages, kinship systems, mythologies, ancestral memories, and homelands. These different societies comprise more than 200 million people throughout the planet today” (The Forum)....   [tags: Religion, Ethnic group, Indigenous peoples]

Powerful Essays
1326 words (3.8 pages)

Indigenous Peoples And Their Traditional Practices Essays

- This book is about the religious, social, and cultural hardships that indigenous peoples in Canada as well as the United States have faced since the 1600s till the most recent times now. Particularly it touches upon the connections between the three main religious groups of the Mi’kmaq peoples Neo-Traditionalism, Traditionalism, and Catholicism. It also touches upon the many differences. Robinson argues that Indigenous peoples have continuously met with many hardships such as assimilation, lose of their land, and decrease in population....   [tags: Culture, Religion, Indigenous peoples, Race]

Powerful Essays
1057 words (3 pages)

The Western And Eurocentric Mentality Towards Indigenous Peoples Essay

- I worry that the western and Eurocentric mentality towards Indigenous peoples has not changed as much as we would like to say. Modern-day schools still ignore Indigenous ways and therefore, portray them as lesser and attempt to remove them. If Indigenous philosophies and pedagogies are not part of the curriculum (and not a sidebar or merely reflected if you look closely), then “this creates tensions and adjustment problems for students, which may contribute to high dropout rates (Schissel & Wotherspoon, 2003).” (Overmars, 2010, p....   [tags: Indigenous peoples, Indigenous Australians]

Powerful Essays
1170 words (3.3 pages)

Analysis Of The Poem ' Indigenous Nationhood ' Essays

- On January 29, 2015, I attended Pamela Palmater’s book launch for her book, “Indigenous Nationhood,” which was a two-hour event that started from 6 PM to 8 PM. Palmater is a well-known lawyer, activist and academic from the Eel River Bar First Nation in northern New Brunswick. The event started with an opening performance from the Hidden River Singers. Palmater then addressed the crowd for around 30-40 minutes, in which the audience, including myself, sat in awe at the passion and intensity in her voice in empowering Indigenous people....   [tags: Indigenous Australians, Indigenous peoples]

Powerful Essays
704 words (2 pages)

Indigenous Media And Indigenous Culture Essay

- The creation of indigenous media content has proven highly beneficial and important for indigenous audiences. Indigenous media is important because it allows a platform for indigenous audiences to present themselves in a way which is often either neglected or negatively portrayed in mainstream media. This is important to the identity work of indigenous cultures and extends to the culture and connection of the indigenous community and wider culture. In particular this essay will focus on the representation of indigenous people in their own media and how they use indigenous media to show accurate and positive representations of themselves....   [tags: Indigenous Australians, Indigenous peoples]

Powerful Essays
950 words (2.7 pages)

The Indigenous Youth Of Australia Essay

- The Indigenous youth of Australia still face many challenges growing up in a world dominated by white Europeans. This essay will discuss the stereotypes and marginalisation that young Indigenous teenagers must face. After viewing Yolngu Boy and Black Chicks Talking, there will be examples from the two movies on the stereotypes, marginalisation, interdependent and the connection the characters of the movies have with the Aboriginal culture and the dominant white culture. Indigenous youth continue to be marginalised and oppressed....   [tags: Indigenous Australians, Indigenous peoples]

Powerful Essays
1222 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Racial And Cultural Bias Towards Indigenous People

- The relevant overarching human rights that should be considered in this case was racial and cultural bias towards Indigenous people in this school. The school principles assumed that the family were not concerned about Nakita’s situation because it was common for Aboriginal families not to respond to calls or letters. Nakita’s carers did not consent to any changes being made to Nakita’s situation at school and it was clear that the school had breached both the departmental policy and state legislation by testing Nakita without the informed consent of her carers....   [tags: Indigenous Australians, Indigenous peoples]

Powerful Essays
727 words (2.1 pages)

The Diversity Of Aboriginal Peoples Essay

- A goal to raise awareness and support, for the Indigenous Peoples, with family, friends and the wider community with the knowledge gained through lectures, tutorials, readings and visuals in studying Aboriginal Peoples and in addition, through research and personal engagement with a member of the Indigenous community. It is important personally, to share a positive collective history and reiterating the past and present struggles of the indigenous peoples, in a hope to influence and encourage a supportive, positive change in their lives....   [tags: Indigenous Australians, Indigenous peoples]

Powerful Essays
1435 words (4.1 pages)