Essay about State and Morality: The Necessity of Injustice

Essay about State and Morality: The Necessity of Injustice

Length: 1468 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Governing ourselves is an important issue that has been discussed since the beginning of History. With Aristotle came the idea that we are “political animals” and that we are therefore forced to form a society. That is how we came to form states that need to be governed according to laws. The aim of these laws is problematic: for classical philosophers, the aim of the laws is and must be the Common Good: happiness for everyone in the state, which is regarded as a perfect community. This conception puts the benefit of all above the benefit of each and gives to the state the responsibility to be rational and moral.
Nevertheless, often, states are seen as aggressive immoral entities, for example when they collect taxes, repress certain behaviors, etc.
So states behave non morally vis-à-vis particular interests to achieve their higher goal, the common good: paying taxes hurt people on the short term but is supposed to benefit the society on the longer one for example. I will here argue that states have to be unjust.
In Aquinas’ conception of a state, people within would raise oppositions, because particular interests necessarily clash with the common good. Based on this idea that individual freedom is the highest aim, Nozick develops his theory of libertarianism. But we morally need sort of a fair state, position that Rawls adopts. However, here also one has to give up individual interests, and thus liberties. Therefore, we might have to accept the loosening of some of our freedom, as argued by Hobbes, to live together and the state has to commit “necessary injustices”.

In his treaty On Law, Thomas Aquinas defends the position that “the law is always something directed to the common good”. Laws are thus directed toward a comm...

... middle of paper ...

...o live with the “necessary injustice” of the state.

Works Cited

- Aquinas, Thomas. ‘First Part of the Second Part: On Law’, Summa Theologica.
- Hobbes, Thomas. 1651. Leviathan, ed. by Edwin Curley (Indianapolis and Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Co., 1994)
- Libertarian Party 1971. The Party of Principle. Minimum Government, Maximum Freedom.’s website.
- Rawls, John. 1971. A Theory of Justice (Harvard University Press, 1999).
- Arrington, Robert L., Western Ethics. An Historical Introduction (Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1998).
- Feser, Edward, ‘Robert Nozick (1938-2002)’, Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
- Lloyd, Sharon A. and Sreedhar, Susanne, "Hobbes's Moral and Political Philosophy", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ed. by Edward N. Zalta (2014).
- Wenar, Leif, ‘John Rawls’, The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ed. by Edward N. Zalta (2013).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Kant and the Morality of Anger Essay example

- Kant and the Morality of Anger Introduction This essay does not comprise a defence of retributive punishment, neither does it imply a rejection of deterrent punishment. The writer suggests that one possible reason for the tendency to advocate punishment of offenders with ever increasing severity can be discovered in the concept of the 'morality of anger'. It is this explanation of the phenomenon that forms the principal burden of the arguments used in this essay. The salient characteristics of the two theories of punishment, which find expression in English law, will be found below [1]....   [tags: Philosophy Papers]

Powerful Essays
4103 words (11.7 pages)

Affirmative Action: An Interpretation through the Application of Justice Theories

- Introduction President John F. Kennedy introduced affirmative action programs to the United States in the early 1960s in effort to redress the history of systemic racial discrimination in the nation (Massey, 2004). As a world leader, the United States has an important influence over this issue, with numerous cases taken to the courts in recent decades. The original purpose of affirmative action programs was to pressure institutions into compliance with the equal rights mandate of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Massey, 2004)....   [tags: racism, injustice, social issues]

Powerful Essays
2744 words (7.8 pages)

Essay on Aristotle And Aristotle On The Modern Day Issues Of Social Justice

- Plato (427-347 B.C.) and Aristotle (384-322 B.C.) Plato and Aristotle were different in their philosophical approaches Aristotle being the pragmatist who dealt with the measurable and concrete, while Plato dealt with the world (two worlds) of concepts and ideas. The aim of this short essay is, therefore, an attempt to explore, and highlight the difference and relevance, if any, of Aristotelian ethical theory, and Platonism ethical theory on and to the modern-day issues of “Social Justice”. There are many “Issues Facing America” today, Social Justice or should we say “social injustice”, is the main issue that concern individuals in every facet of life, the aim of this short essay is, therefo...   [tags: Ethics, Virtue, Justice, Morality]

Powerful Essays
963 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on Analysis of The Singer Solution to World Poverty by Peter Singer

- Saint Augustine once said, “Find out how much God has given you and from it take what you need; the remainder is needed by others.” (Augustine). Augustine's belief that it is the duty of the individual to assist those less fortunate than themselves is expressed in the essay "The Singer Solution to World Poverty" by Peter Singer. Singer shares his conviction that those living in luxury should support those struggling to survive in poverty. Singer adopts the persona of a sage utilitarian philosopher who judges the morality of actions based on the consequences that are wrought by them....   [tags: individual, luxury, poverty, morality]

Powerful Essays
822 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on Analysis Of The State Of Modern Morality

- In After Virtue, author Alasdair MacIntyre critiques the state of modern morality and proposes an argument in favor of Aristotelian virtue ethics. For MacIntyre, he believes that a lack of community driven morality is the cause of moral decline in society, and that this decline began during the age of Enlightenment. He explains that the Enlightenment brought society into a state of disruption because the intense focus on individualism drove people to philosophical emotivism. Emotivism is defined by MacIntyre as being “the doctrine that all evaluative judgements and more specifically all moral judgements are nothing but expressions of preference, expressions of attitude or feeling, insofar as...   [tags: Virtue ethics, Ethics, Morality, Virtue]

Powerful Essays
1639 words (4.7 pages)

Social Injustice in France Essay

- Social injustice had always been an uncorrected shortcoming for France from the early 19th century to the present. While the social injustice that appeared in the form of French religious persecution was much more visible during the early 19th century than in the reasonably tolerant 21st century, as seen in the contrasting cases of the Anti-Sacrilege Act in 1825 and the About-Picard Law in 2001, social injustice was a ubiquitous presence in many religious institutions of France. In a different degree of paramountcy, the social injustice manifested in the style of French political inequalities remains to be a perennial prejudice against the “forgotten man”, one clear-cut case being the anti-S...   [tags: social injustice, french religions]

Powerful Essays
1613 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on The Defense Of Duress, Self Defense, Necessity, And Entrapment

- In a criminal trial, a defendant has a choice of several justification defenses, of which the most common one is that they did not do anything. The four most important “justification defenses” for criminal culpability are duress, self-defense, necessity, and entrapment. I would like to discuss duress, self-defense, and necessity. The defense of duress can arise when a wrongful threat or use of physical force compels the defendant or any other reasonable person to perform an act which that person would not perform under normal circumstances (Gaines and Miller 91)....   [tags: Law, Necessity, Criminal law, Jury]

Powerful Essays
1156 words (3.3 pages)

Reconciling Injustice and Necessity: The Statesman in the Practical City

- Reconciling Injustice and Necessity: The Statesman in the Practical City When Socrates builds up a “city in speech” from ideals, he allows himself the option of overlooking the more distasteful features of real human cities simply by omitting them from the argument. His is a city whose primary purpose is to shed light on the soul of an individual, and its role as a metaphor allows it to contain logical conclusions which run wholly counter to the feasible practices of men. Aristotle permits himself no such luxury when he sets out to describe politics from the top down; he cannot overlook such thorny issues as slavery and empire because they exist as significant features in the constitutions...   [tags: Essays Papers]

Free Essays
1452 words (4.1 pages)

Morality : Morality And Morality Essay

- Morals: The belief in a moral obligation to engage in international, like the persuasion theory, is quite broad. Morality can’t be reduced to a matter of right and wrong; states have more complex beliefs than that. In this case, the causal factor for participation is rooted in belief. This differs from coercion in that coercion disregards the intentions of (the weaker) states. The weaker states do what they must not what they desire. The morality theory also differs from the persuasion theory. Under the persuasion theory the state is in control of its actions and acts based on ideas and principles, however, those principles are based on self-interest....   [tags: Law, Morality, Human rights, Ethics]

Powerful Essays
1089 words (3.1 pages)

Essay The Necessity to Speak

- The Necessity to Speak On September 11th 2001 America was attacked. Two planes taken over by terrorists crashed into the twin towers of the World Trade Center and one plane crashed into the Pentagon. For many it was disbelief, something out of a movie, but as the fateful day progressed reality struck hard. Thousands of people were lost in the rubble and hundreds more died trying to save them. For America it was a day of mourning, an event no one will ever forget. America's immunity to attack was broken and paranoia ran high....   [tags: The Necessity to Speak Sam Hamill Essays]

Powerful Essays
2468 words (7.1 pages)