Standing Up for the Power of Learning, by Jay Mathews

1069 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Essay about causes and effects of academic dishonesty

The essay, “Standing Up for the Power of Learning,” by Jay Mathews explained how one of many students was accused of academic dishonesty. During the regular school session of the year 2001, three fourths of 187 students at Georgia Institute of Technology (GIT) were found guilty of cheating. This was because they collaborated on an assignment in a computer science (CS) course with friends. By communicating with others about the project, the students violated the course honor code that prohibited the discussion among students for that particular class.

Perhaps, some people may argue that no collaboration is unhealthy and ineffective in a learning setting. Well, that is not the case for freshmen students at GIT who are taking CS 1321. As claimed by GIT, students are graded on their individual abilities to do the required work. I believe universities should exercise their rights to set reasonable and effective academic policies for its students, but without any over defined measures or limitations. For instance, the policy that is explained by Mathews that GIT had in place for freshmen who were taking CS is over estimated with little considerations to how students will react to it naturally.

Mathews argued on the behalf of one particular student who was a victim in violating the computer science honor code. According to Mathews’ knowledge of GIT’s computer science honor code, it declared that “at no time is it acceptable for you [students] to share your solutions to the homework assignments with other students, whether these solution are complete or partial, nor is it acceptable to compare your solutions with other students.” (Mathews 210) Legally, I agree with GIT for convicting this student of cheating and applying the punishment...

... middle of paper ...

...s that made no sense.” (Mathews 212) It somewhat seems to the reader like to writer is trying to make his audience feel sorry for the students but that is not the case. The justification for the claim of the author not committing a logical fallacy are the use of adequate facts he gathered from student of? Whom was convicted of cheating and his person understanding of the issue.

Indeed, Jay Mathews had done an admirable job in illustrating his argument as effectively as possible for the best comprehension of the sad situation that took place at Georgia Institute of Technology. Again, he made strong and concise points with adequate reasons and supports. We, as a class community, should try and use strategies Mathews used to ensure that we argue to the optimum level as possible.

Works Cited

robert yagelski and robert miller. the informed arguments. eight edition

Show More
Related

  • ' The Lesson, By Toni Cade Bambara

    1753 Words  | 4 Pages

    Toni Cade Bambara’s ‘The Lesson’ starts with the Sylvia’s description about one African-American’s appearance, who is called Miss Moore. The story is focused on the the event of field trip that Miss Moore conducted for her students one day. She takes her students to pricy toy store which is called F.A.O. Schwartz, to let them see the reality of gap between poor and rich. The story took place in 1970s which was during the movements for civil and social rights, equality and justice swept the United States. According to university of California, during this time, the opportunity to African American was really limited in a lot of aspects, including the education. People often tend to interpret the most important main point of this

    Read More

  • Andrew Curry's Why We Work By Barbara Ehrenreich

    1061 Words  | 3 Pages

    In today’s society you either have to work hard to live a good life, or just inherit a lump sum of cash, which is probably never going to happen. So instead a person has to work a usual nine to five just to put food on the table for their families, and in many cases that is not even enough. In the article, “Why We Work” by Andrew Curry, Curry examines the complexities of work and touches on the reasons why many workers feel unsatisfied with their jobs. Barbara Ehrenreich writes an essay called, “Serving in Florida” which is about the overlooked life of being a server and the struggles of working off low minimum wages. Curry’s standpoint on jobs is that workers are not satisfied, the job takes control of their whole life, and workers spend

    Read More

  • Power Matters By Brenda Allen

    1173 Words  | 3 Pages

    According to Brenda Allen in the chapter “Power Matters,” she mentions that there dominant ideologies of identity that “reflect perspectives and experiences of ruling groups, whose members construct and circulate beliefs that will most benefit them.” We live in a country where there are dominant ideologies of organizational hierarchy, which “arranges job positions in a stratified structure, with power flowing from the top down.” This exemplifies the ideology of domination, which is a belief system in America that the “superior should rule over the inferior” (32). This ideology is so embedded into our system that most people believe it is natural. The American society we live in values patriarchy, white supremacy, heteronormativity, and a specific culture of wealth and poverty; any identity that falls outside of these dominant ideologies is marginalized and placed in the lower strata of social power.

    Read More

  • Let's Really Reform Our Schools By Anita Garland

    1041 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many individuals have been affected negatively by trouble makers in school. Troublemakers have either disrupted classes or bullied other students. Yes, trouble makers may harm one’s learning environment, but should they be kicked out of school? Though many individuals argue that troublemakers will not change and hold the class down, they should not be kicked out because they need help. Most of these kids that are disobedient do not know the distinction between right and wrong. We should not withdraw trouble makers from school, rather, we should help these troublemakers and teach them right from wrong. In the article “Let’s Really Reform Our Schools” by Anita Garland, she states that American high schools are disasters because there are troublemakers (694). She asserts that the withdrawal of troublemakers in schools would make the learning environment peaceful for students who want to learn

    Read More

  • Critical Analysis Of Christian Miller's Essay On Cheating

    806 Words  | 2 Pages

    In this final chapter, Christian Miller speaks about cheating. There is a cheating behavior that many people do for various reasons. This assumes that the cheater might not be the one who is advantaged. Most humans today cheat when the opportunities arise. In studies, it is clear that many students cheat while in college. Of the many students who cheat, only a small fraction of them get caught. In a very large group of people, it was seen that only 3 people stated that they have never cheated while in school. In one case, a student found an exam on the printer and mass distributed it to the class and the class finished the exam quickly and scored higher. This made the teacher skeptical and a retake was made. It is clear that cheating is very prominent on college campuses. In an experiment, participants were told that they could only take 5 minutes on a

    Read More

  • Summary Of There Is No Harvard Cheating Scandal '

    161 Words  | 1 Pages

    In this article, Farhad states that Harvard had investigated more than 100 students from a Government 1310: Introduction to Congress class due to some doubts of cheating on the final exam. The exam was a completely open-book, open-internet, and take-home, but the instructor noticed that students had been started to break the rules by sharing notes. Some students, who was accused for cheating were

    Read More

  • Honor Codes

    1033 Words  | 3 Pages

    However, this may stem from a lack of enforcement of the rules. Even at the most prestigious schools, such as Harvard University, students are not upholding the rules implemented: “The possibility that 125 Harvard students ‘improperly collaborated’ on an exam in the spring has galvanized … discussion about … honor codes” (Source: C). In this case, people may argue that the only party at fault consists of the students. However, the faculty may be partially guilty as well, as their lack of care towards the rules has created a situation that jeopardizes the school’s integrity. Revision may then seem like the least of the school’s priorities, as they must show they seriously consider educational integrity. Likewise, at the University of Virginia, “157 students have been investigated by their peers in the largest cheating scandal in memory” (Source: D). Again, the school and all those who work there hold at least part of the fault for this ignorance because, theoretically, they should preserve and enforce the rules provided. The fact that the scandal exists means that they were not doing their jobs to their fullest. Although revision may seem simpler to carry out, the school’s staff must show an attempt at intervention within the student lives to keep them on a path towards

    Read More

  • Retroactive Grade Inflation Case Study

    717 Words  | 2 Pages

    The central moral issue in the case revolves around the fact that Loyola Law School in Los Angeles retroactively inflated its students‘ GPAs by 0.333. The grade inflation will effortlessly grant a student with an A- an A. Inflating the students’ GPAs by 0.333. has the potential to harm employers and school graduates. According to the author, employers may believe that the graduates were given the high grades undeservingly. Even students whose grades have been inflated are complaining that they will no longer be able to use their GPAs as an accurate measure of their performance in law school. On the other hand, grade inflation has the potential to help students that have not done very well academically. It would raise their average by a considerable amount of grades, which would

    Read More

  • Diane Ravitch's The Essentials Of A Good Education

    829 Words  | 2 Pages

    The ability for all children from varying walks of life to receive a well-rounded education in America has become nothing more than a myth. In excerpt “The Essentials of a Good Education”, Diane Ravitch argues the government’s fanatical obsession with data based on test scores has ruined the education system across the country (107). In their eyes, students have faded from their eyes as individual hopefully, creative and full of spirit, and have become statistics on a data sheet, percentages on a pie chart, and numbers calculated to show the intelligence they have from filling out bubbles in a booklet. In order for schools to be able to provide a liberal education, they need the proper funding, which comes from the testing.

    Read More

  • Ethics and the Cheating Epidemic

    781 Words  | 2 Pages

    First is a freshman named John Smolik, and his words are incriminating for all college students. He says “Cheating IS an answer” (Clayton 20). This is nothing new. Cheating has always been an answer for students. Most of them get caught, however. The fact that a student says this, however, makes people think that he has cheated or that it is widespread. In fact, he is just expressing a personal opinion, which he is entitled to.

    Read More

  • Academic Integrity Essay

    731 Words  | 2 Pages

    Honesty is a key moral characteristic to have throughout life, but the problem is some students lack the honesty to admit that they are even in the wrong. According to an article in the Huffington Post, “75% of college students admit to cheating”(Buchmann). I am

    Read More

  • Academic Dishonesty: Applying Technology To Cheat

    1468 Words  | 3 Pages

    Modern students face many pressures for academic success. They are often unwilling to disappoint their parents or spouses. Some fear that not cheating will weaken a student’s ability to compete with their peers. They rationalize their unethical behavior, unwilling to accept a poor grade, consequently justifying cheating as the only means to that end.

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Plagiarism

    1383 Words  | 3 Pages

    Today, millions of students will hand in work to a teacher; for some of them this is the assignment that will make or break their grade. If your entire academic future rested on a single grade, wouldn 't you do everything you could to make it your best work possible? Some people stay up for countless hours, working harder than they ever have in their entire lives, to produce high quality work. Other people decide to break one of the most enforced rules at every school in the country. In other words, they cheat. There are many different ways a student can cheat: they could have plagiarized work off of the internet, they could have snuck their phone into a test and used it to look up answers, etc. There are a million different ways students

    Read More

  • Set In Our Ways: Why Change Is So Hard By Nikolas Westeroff

    844 Words  | 2 Pages

    The general pattern for people is that when they becoming older they are less able to vary life. Nikolas Westerhoff in his article “Set in Our ways: Why Change is So Hard” described the connection between humans’ brains and behavior during the certain periods of life. The key assumption is that in 20s people are more hazardous and tend to adventures, while after 30s this trend is less expressed. Author gives an example when the young generation can be even over risky and inconsiderate. The article includes the story about 22-year-old Cristopher McCandless, who gave his money for charity and hitchhiked around the USA and died in Alaska because of famine. When 40s – 60s are coming people lose their appetite for novelty due to the natural process, which reveal that old habits express themselves at those ages. The elder generation wants to feel stability continuing do customary things and taking care of their children or grandchildren. Also they are under the society’s pressure, when it is quite inappropriate being infantile or just make crazy travels instead of making a career and having a family. Author mentioned false hope syndrome, which means that people often procrastinate certain thinks that never be finished. That is why Westerhoff suggests doing everything “on a right time in a right place” because then it would be probably late.

    Read More

  • Academic Cheating Essay

    991 Words  | 2 Pages

    The word “cheating” when introduced in a conversation brings forth the connotation of thief, laziness, incompetence, scared, untrustworthy just to name a few characteristics. However, take that same word, “cheating”, and apply it to education or business and the audience begin to stuttering, become confused, offer qualifiers and exclusions, delineations, classifications or absolute deny any such behavior. It is generally accepted that cheating occurs in high school and college, but is it viewed as an acceptable practice by students or a lack of understanding or miscommunication between students and educational institutions. According to data gathered by the Educational Portal, between 75%-98%

    Read More

More about Standing Up for the Power of Learning, by Jay Mathews

Open Document