Standing Up for the Power of Learning, by Jay Mathews Essay

Standing Up for the Power of Learning, by Jay Mathews Essay

Length: 1069 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The essay, “Standing Up for the Power of Learning,” by Jay Mathews explained how one of many students was accused of academic dishonesty. During the regular school session of the year 2001, three fourths of 187 students at Georgia Institute of Technology (GIT) were found guilty of cheating. This was because they collaborated on an assignment in a computer science (CS) course with friends. By communicating with others about the project, the students violated the course honor code that prohibited the discussion among students for that particular class.
Perhaps, some people may argue that no collaboration is unhealthy and ineffective in a learning setting. Well, that is not the case for freshmen students at GIT who are taking CS 1321. As claimed by GIT, students are graded on their individual abilities to do the required work. I believe universities should exercise their rights to set reasonable and effective academic policies for its students, but without any over defined measures or limitations. For instance, the policy that is explained by Mathews that GIT had in place for freshmen who were taking CS is over estimated with little considerations to how students will react to it naturally.
Mathews argued on the behalf of one particular student who was a victim in violating the computer science honor code. According to Mathews’ knowledge of GIT’s computer science honor code, it declared that “at no time is it acceptable for you [students] to share your solutions to the homework assignments with other students, whether these solution are complete or partial, nor is it acceptable to compare your solutions with other students.” (Mathews 210) Legally, I agree with GIT for convicting this student of cheating and applying the punishment...


... middle of paper ...


...s that made no sense.” (Mathews 212) It somewhat seems to the reader like to writer is trying to make his audience feel sorry for the students but that is not the case. The justification for the claim of the author not committing a logical fallacy are the use of adequate facts he gathered from student of? Whom was convicted of cheating and his person understanding of the issue.
Indeed, Jay Mathews had done an admirable job in illustrating his argument as effectively as possible for the best comprehension of the sad situation that took place at Georgia Institute of Technology. Again, he made strong and concise points with adequate reasons and supports. We, as a class community, should try and use strategies Mathews used to ensure that we argue to the optimum level as possible.

Works Cited

robert yagelski and robert miller. the informed arguments. eight edition

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Adolescence: Fitting in and Not Standing Out Essay

- Many people say it is hard to fit into today’s society. We grow up in a world where we do not want to stand out because that is considered wrong. We want people to accept us, but we cannot do that when we do not fit in. You may not like the people who fit in, but you have to get to the top somehow. Some people feel they must help people in need because they have more than them and it sometimes hurts to see them have less. Some people are nice to others, but you can’t be nice to everyone. Can you really reach the top by fitting in and not standing out....   [tags: standing out, fit in, adolescence]

Strong Essays
794 words (2.3 pages)

Essay about Analysis Of Jay Z 's Life

- ... In “The Truth”, an interview with Elliott Wilson, Jay Z speaks on his childhood and how learning how to adapt to the people around him got him respect. Jay Z got his respect by beating people older than him in basketball, which was very commendable where he grew up. He tells Wilson that sometimes people let the younger kids win at basketball simply because those individuals want the child to feel accomplished, but ultimately letting a child win will make him unprepared for the future because he then thinks that life is handed to him or life is easier than he thinks....   [tags: Education, Learning, Psychology]

Strong Essays
872 words (2.5 pages)

Comparison Of Kanye West And Jay Gatsby Essays

- Comparison of Kanye West and Jay Gatsby Materialism is a key part of our society. It is something that exists in real life, and is portrayed in Literature. A real life representation of materialism in our society is Kanye West. Kanye West is one of the most successful rappers of our time. He is known for his extreme rants and controversial verses and sayings. Literature is also known for creating materialistic characters. Jay Gatsby from The Great Gatsby, written by F. Scott Fitzgerald, is a great example of materialism....   [tags: F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby, Jay Gatsby]

Strong Essays
987 words (2.8 pages)

Laboratory Learnings : A Lab Learnings Essay

- ... Name: Leisure Skills Crossword Puzzle (Pettry, 2006). Goal: To increase familiarization of leisure related vocabulary Objectives: Participants will complete one sheet each week for four weeks. Objectives: Participants will engage in open discussions weekly for four weeks. Supplies/resources: One activity sheet, and a pen or pencil Sequences: A Crossword is made by the teacher and given to students to complete. Supplies will be distributed and directions will be explained. Students will complete the crossword with questions such as “to increase one’s abilities and skills” and “a period for doing an activity” Finish activity with an open discussion....   [tags: Learning, Education, Teacher, Leisure]

Strong Essays
776 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on The Social Standing Treatment

- The Social Standing Treatment Although success in life is measured in several different ways, many people are comparatively judging themselves against their neighbors and colleagues. While the basic structure of classes and the power they each possess are quite noticeable, the invisible divisions between them and personal responses to unequal treatment are not as easily seen. Consequently, it is the purpose of this report to address these issues and more within the ensuing lines of text. Unfortunately, several problems exist between people of various social classes....   [tags: Sociology]

Strong Essays
697 words (2 pages)

Standing Out Essay

- Seeing light in the pearl of Indian Ocean - Sri Lanka, I grew up with various circumstances and developed various ethics that differentiates me from others. In addition to experiences in Sri Lanka, various circumstances in the United States after migrating in 2006 contributed to standing out from other applicants. Furthermore, during the 2004 Indian Ocean Tsunami, living in a Sri Lankan coastal city and witnessing the tsunami waves caused me to grow and develop a perspective that not many high school seniors possess....   [tags: Autobiography, Personal Experience]

Strong Essays
1029 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on The Amityville Horror by Jay Anson

- ... When Kathy is checking on her children, as a mother, she takes notice and remembers the sleeping position of all three of her children. So when all three of them are lying on their stomach, Kathy says, “That was the first time I could ever remember the children sleeping in that position – particularly all three on their stomachs at the same time” (49). Details make up one’s memory. In the story, Father Mancuso remembers his urge to call the Lutzes (56) because he “kept envisioning a room he believed to be on the second floor of the house....   [tags: memories, story analysis]

Strong Essays
1455 words (4.2 pages)

Diagnosing Change, Jay Galbraith Essay

- Diagnosing Change Review of Change Diagnostic Model (20 pts) The Star Model was developed by Jay Galbraith to analyze an organization’s effectiveness by focusing on strategy, structure, process, rewards and people. Strategy is the direction and the basis for decisions that people will make. Structure is the authority given to people and the groupings of activities. Process is the coordinated activities throughout the organization. Rewards link individual’s actions to organizational objectives....   [tags: star model, reward, diversification]

Strong Essays
1319 words (3.8 pages)

Jay Gatsby’s Heroism Essay

- Novalis, the great German philosopher, once said that, "A hero is one who knows how to hang on one minute longer." In The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald, the main character, Jay Gatsby, will do anything to acquire his lost love, Daisy Buchanan. The 1920’s novel sets the stage for Gatsby to showcase his prominence in the society of West Egg, New York through the descriptive language and emotion that Fitzgerald writes with. Jay Gatsby’s heroicness is displayed through the symbolism of the green light, the eyes of Doctor T.J....   [tags: heroes, great gatsby, f. scott fitzgerald, ]

Strong Essays
802 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on Dave Mathews

- According to the American Heritage Dictionary a poet is someone who writes poems. If I were to give my own definition of a poet it would say a poet is someone who can take a group of words and put a hundred different emotions and meanings into them. This is what Dave Mathews does with his lyrics; he takes his emotions and puts them into words. This is what makes him a poet and a master of words. From the debut of his first album Remember Two Things, Mathews has instructed the listener to do everything from love to relax and enjoy the day....   [tags: Music Essays]

Free Essays
705 words (2 pages)