Some Laws are Based on Opinion Essay

Some Laws are Based on Opinion Essay

Length: 712 words (2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Good Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Since the robber during the night is presumed to be indulging in the murder of the householder, the householder is permitted to use deadly force to prevent him/her and his/her family from being assaulted. On the contrary, due to the fact that the robber during the day is presumed to merely have the intention of stealing without assault, the householder may not use deadly force against the robber, and may only strike him down without murdering him.
Rashi goes on further to teach that if the thief/robber is recognized for whatever reason (perhaps some light shines upon him or his voice sounds familiar or he is not wearing a mask) as a familiar person to the householder, than the householder may not use deadly force upon him. In this way the rights of the householder are limited to only being able to kill the thief during the night under certain circumstances when the thief is not recognized. Chizkuni or Hezekiah ben Manoah comments further, saying that if the thief is caught by the householder with the stolen goods, in the place where he broke, then there is not bloodguilt or liability by the blood avenger (one who exacts revenge on the murder of the thief/robber) for his death because he has caught the householder in the state of his blind rage. However, Chizkuni also says that in the case where the robber is caught breaking in during the day, there is bloodguilt or liability by the blood avenger if the robber is killed by the householder, because it is assumed that the robber does not come to kill, merely to steal; and therefore it is forbidden for the householder to take deadly action.

2.) Not all law is factual. A vast amount of decisions are somewhat made on an assumption, and not fully based on proof. These legal assumpt...


... middle of paper ...


...r the mindset or mentality of the robber/thief in order to deduct a better understanding as to the intentions of the robber/thief (based on most people’s actions in that position) and allow for a resolution of the case at hand. Furthermore a חזקה can help support one’s views within the court by providing a precedent to one’s opinion.
• Weakness: On the other hand, one weakness of the חזקה is that other cases and the assumed mindset of most people performing the theft or robbery may not necessarily apply to the specific case, which may be an outlier.(is not necessarily true, there may be outlier cases)
• Weakness: Another weakness to a חזקה is that when a case concerns life or death, nothing should ever be assumed, there should only be factual evidence, as life remains the highest Jewish value and cannot be put in jeopardy for merely what is assumed to be the case.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Tragedy of the Jim Crow Laws Essays

- Jim Crow laws are about power. Power of one race over another. These laws really highlight the flaws and weakness of human nature. One group of people asserting power over another for the pride and vanity of a system of politics that had been defeated at the cost of thousands of American lives during the civil war. The term "Jim Crow" has its origins of interest also. The interpretation was intended to ridicule the African American by white American's in the position of power. The Jim Crow laws were initiated after the civil war during the deconstruction of the new south and they help to create a racial caste system in the American South....   [tags: Jim Crow Laws Essays]

Free Essays
3868 words (11.1 pages)

The World Is Based From Two Types Of Laws Essay

- The world is based from two types of laws. Just and unjust laws. In recent years a series of new laws have been adopted. Some of these laws were just and others were unjust. Something that differentiates unjust law from just is it’s an unfairness. In other words, unjust law is something that does not equally apply to everybody. It could be directed to the specific person or group of people. For instance, the law of banning propaganda of homosexuality, making homosexsuals second class citizens who are not entitled to, for example, to express their feelings in public....   [tags: Law, United States, Property]

Good Essays
1405 words (4 pages)

Essay on Public Opinion And Supreme Court Decision

- In illustrating that there is a direct link between public opinion and Supreme Court decision an explanation as to why this phenomenon occurs can be found. There are two main schools of thought as to why this occurs. The first was explained by Dahl (1957) which claims that public opinion affects the Court indirectly through political appointments. As previously stated, the Court responds to national economic or political alliances, which dominate the national narrative. Justices respond to this national narrative and the national narrative responds to public opinion....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States]

Good Essays
1043 words (3 pages)

Personal Opinion Essay: Should Marijuana be Legalized?

- Right now in this country (and many other countries for that matter) we are experiencing a transitional period that is dependent on legislation, legislation that is bound to reinforce or oppress marijuana legalization. It’s not every day that states have policy that conflicts with federal laws and everyone seems to have an opinion. There are many options on the table for law makers. We could see the federal government enforce their current marijuana laws by cracking down and increase their raids on dispensaries, or they could make marijuana a higher priority with agencies from the DEA to local law enforcement....   [tags: Medical, Recreational, Drugs]

Good Essays
1242 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about Helmet Laws In The United States

- Helmet laws throughout the U.S. have always created a great deal of controversy. Currently there are two types of helmet laws in the United States; a universal helmet law, which requires all motorcyclists to wear a helmet and partial helmet law that has age requirements. The helmet debate has been a long battle between free-rights organizations and government officials. In 1967, the Highway Safety act created a federal highway safety grant program. Prior to this act, no state in the U.S. had a motorcycle helmet law....   [tags: Public Safety]

Good Essays
1483 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about Opinion on Genetic Engineering

- Opinion on Genetic Engineering "Only god has the right to interfere with our genes" Genetic engineering is when scientists manipulate the human genome to alter 'bad' genes; these genes are responsible for all types of diseases and conditions from cancer to the acclaimed 'fat' gene which is responsible for the obesity crisis that the modern world is currently facing. This practice has been controversial one because religions and other organizations across the world believe that genetic engineering is playing god as it allows man to create people with any mental and physical characteristics possible....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
691 words (2 pages)

Essay about The Morality Of Immoral Laws

- Morality of Immoral Laws In “Crito” and “Antigone,” Plato and Sophocles both talk about disobeying the law. Plato claims that it is wrong to disobey the law when the individual will gain something from his disobedience. On the other hand, Sophocles argues that it is wrong to disobey laws that do not follow the laws of God. While I agree with Plato and Sophocles in regards to their concepts of the law, I claim that Socrates and Plato would both agree that it is not right to follow an immoral law; it is better to break an immoral law than to follow it....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Plato, Human]

Good Essays
1437 words (4.1 pages)

Hate Crime Laws: Are They Constitutional? Essay

- Are hate crime penalty enforcement laws constitutional. “That’s Gay.” If you are around teenagers today, that is a phrase you will most likely hear very often. It is not necessarily meant as a homophobic or hate-filled remark, and most of the time it is referring to an object, an idea, or a conversation; things that obviously have no sexual orientation. But now, according to a bill passed by the senate, it could almost be considered a hate crime. Many people support the widening of hate crime laws, assuming that with stricter penalties, the crimes will lessen....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Good Essays
1568 words (4.5 pages)

Laws of Juvenile Sexual Offenders Essay

- Juvenile Sexual Offenders: Should the Laws Be Adjusted. In today’s society of internet sex crimes being broadcast on the evening news and 60 Minutes doing specials at least once a month. Are we paying enough attention to other sexual crimes and problems, such as the laws pertaining to juvenile sex offenders and their victims. Could more be done to help and protect the perpetrators, victims and their families. It is my opinion that the laws pertaining to juvenile sex offenders need to be adjusted....   [tags: Legal Law]

Good Essays
1692 words (4.8 pages)

Repeal Abortion Laws Now Essay

- Repeal Abortion Laws Now Why do the abortion laws stay on the books. One reason is the apparent inability or unwillingness of those who advocate population limitation to see the connection. (This does not apply to Planned Parenthood-World Population, which in November, 1968, passed resolutions calling for repeal of the abortion laws in support of its declared policy of voluntary parenthood.) By 1968, almost all the major religious groups in the United States except the Roman Catholic Church were on record in favor of abortion-law reform or repeal....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics]

Free Essays
936 words (2.7 pages)