Socrates 's Views On Plato 's Dialogue Essay

Socrates 's Views On Plato 's Dialogue Essay

Length: 869 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

It is easy to read Socrates’s dialogue each as an individual story. It is more difficult to take into consideration every word that Socrates has said up to that point and allow that to influence the validity of the current position or argument Socrates is supporting in one specific dialogue. Though this may be more difficult we must take everything that Socrates has claimed to hold in every dialogue. While holding Socrates accountable for every position he has taken during his dialogues there is a potential contradiction between Socrates Apology and in his dialogue with Crito. Though this contradiction is clearly visible when focusing on just the idea of these claims, there are background beliefs of the Gods that allows both Socrates claim in his apology and his argument in the Crito dialogues.
In his dialogues with Crito , Socrates argues that it would be wrong of him to escape his death sentence because if he did he would be wronging the Athenian Laws. Socrates is determined to avoid wronging the Athenian Laws because he says that one must never do wrong to another. He explains that one way to wrong another is by failing to honor a just agreement, and as a citizen of Athens he has agreed to do one of three things:
1. Leave Athens
2. Persuade the Athenian Laws that their orders are unjust
3. Follow the orders of the Athenian Laws
Because Socrates has failed to leave Athens or to persuade the Athenian Laws, he has some justly duty to follow the orders of the Athenian Laws, and accept his death.
However, in his Apology , Socrates says he will disregard the orders of the Athenian Laws and continue practicing philosophy. Socrates has established that breaking a just agreement is wrong regardless of the reason. Therefore, to keep ...

... middle of paper ...

...tool that he uses to spread his God-given gift of the wisdom to see one’s own arrogance and as an extent of the order prohibiting him in using his gifts to honor the Gods.
Because all citizens are required to show favor to the Gods, any order that prohibits someone to honor the Gods is unjust. Consequently, the agreement must not be just and the disobeying of the Athenian Laws is not an act of wrong doing, but rather an attempt to act in a way that gives more favor to the Gods. There is not Contradiction for Socrates.
A powerful objection to this line of thought would be to propose that Socrates could show the arrogance of other by using a tool other that his philosophical questioning. In this case he would be honoring both the Gods and the Athenian Laws. Perhaps this is possible, but I fail to find a tool as useful as Socrates method of philosophical questioning.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Socrates 's Views On The Apology Of Socrates Essay

- Socrates was a well-known philosopher in Ancient Greek who was named the father of Western philosophy. Yet, the counselors and state jurors did not believe that Socrates was the knowledgeable man that the city of Athens claims that he is. Therefore, the state accused Socrates for depraving the youth of Athens, as well as creating new gods that were not recognized by the state. In the Apology, one can understand that it was not much of an apology or an acknowledgment of offense. Later on, Socrates is sentenced to death and later writes Crito, where his friend Crito endeavors to convince Socrates to escape his jail cell....   [tags: Plato, Socrates, State, Trial of Socrates]

Better Essays
1285 words (3.7 pages)

The Importance Of Individuality ( Three Lessons From Plato 's Dialogue, The Apology

- The Importance of Individuality (Three Lessons from Plato’s Dialogue, The Apology) The trial of Socrates in the year 399 B.C. is a very important piece of history that teaches many lessons. Socrates was accused of being an atheist as well as corrupting the young men in his community. He was tried in a court and found guilty; then consequently required to propose his own penalty, as an alternative to Meletos’ penalty. The court ultimately voted against Socrates’ judgement, and gave him the death penalty....   [tags: Plato, Socrates, Apology, Belief]

Better Essays
1351 words (3.9 pages)

Socrates 's Seeker Of Wisdom Essay examples

- It has been said, that Socrates was s seeker of wisdom, who pursued it relentlessly, but through many dialogues with his interlocutors, he never was satisfied with their intellectual input. Or so it seemed on the superficial level, looking at his views on how society should be structured, it appears the Socratic project had a deeper and darker essence to it that threatened the core of Athenian society, by subtly pecking at the long held traditions, values, and ideas that made Athens so unique. Socrates lived in Athens, which at the time was an artistic, democratic, and an intellectual hub in the center of the Grecian world, whose pursuit, like in most sovereign states, was to advance in al...   [tags: Socrates, Plato, Trial of Socrates, Democracy]

Better Essays
1699 words (4.9 pages)

Plato 's Attainment Of Virtues Essay

- Plato: Attainment of Virtues Attaining virtue is something that most philosophers did during their time. Philosophers employed a variety of definitions in order to define many of the issues their students and associates faced at different times. Philosophers like Plato and Socrates employed a quality approach that was to develop virtue in the minds and souls of their associates. The attaining virtue is the core subject that was to define the social, economic and political lives of the people. For example, attaining virtue in political democracy lead to the death of Socrates in the dialogue....   [tags: Plato, Virtue, Ethics, Socrates]

Better Essays
1118 words (3.2 pages)

Plato 's Theory Of Knowledge And Opinion Essay example

- Plato believes there is two types of worlds that are of knowledge and opinion. As he understands, what is an every lasting reality is a true knowledge, which is the heart of what needs to be understood and everything people need to know. As he says for opinion, it will be only successful some times, as knowledge will always be right and successful at all times when implemented. An opinion for him has no base on true knowledge, but pure people’s speculations of their points of views. A true knowledge will never be influenced by any changes and it cannot be affected by anything; it will stand alone without changing....   [tags: Plato, Soul, Socrates, Epistemology]

Better Essays
1160 words (3.3 pages)

The Realm Of Pedagogy, By Plato And Aristotle Essay

- In the realm of pedagogy, there has been a “battle for the mind” that has existed among philosophers and educators dating back to the time of Socrates, Plato and Aristotle. The introduction in our textbook Philosophical Documents in Education briefly explores various views that have struggled to definitively define what education is and it should be utilized by society. The qualifications of an educated person(s) have been debated about for generations, and the battle can largely be summed up as a “conflict between those who wish to indoctrinate humankind to do the right thing and those seeking to educate human beings to think for themselves” (18)....   [tags: Philosophy, Plato, Socrates, Scientific method]

Better Essays
864 words (2.5 pages)

Socrates As A Person Who Is Profoundly Wise Essay

- 1. Socrates is as a person who is profoundly wise, a person who has understood planes of reality far higher than what is understood by most people. He is depicted as one who has been outside the cave and who is no longer imprisoned by the illusions of the ordinary world. He is depicted as a skilled communicator who can ask people to question and examine even their most cherished assumptions. The Socratic Method is based on a dialogue between two or more people who may hold differing views, but wish to pursue the truth by seeking agreement with one another, Socrates used it quite differently in that he believed that knowledge was instinctive and could be brought out by means of skillful quest...   [tags: Plato, Socrates, Philosophy, Religion]

Better Essays
1207 words (3.4 pages)

Essay about Plato's Dialogue

- Plato's Dialogue Dialogue: to exchange and discuss ideas in a frank and open manner to reach a mutually agreed understanding. Dialogue on difficult issues is important to man. People can learn from others by exchanging ideas and expressing how a philosophy or a stand on an issue affects them. Comprehending the needs, feelings, problems and views of others can help create a better future for all. Can we in a society that proclaims the right to free speech participate in a free and open dialogue....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
475 words (1.4 pages)

Socrates Essay

- Socrates Socrates was a Greek philosopher and teacher. His teachings, life and death have made him one of the most admired people in history. Although he wrote no books or developed a regular school of thought, his influence inspired others to. Socrates affected the entire course of Western thought. I believe Socrates to be one of the most important philosophers ever. Born in Athens, Socrates (470-399 BCE) was the son of a wealthy sculptor. There he received the regular elementary education in literature, music, and gymnastics....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
653 words (1.9 pages)

socrates Essay examples

- Socrates Paper The duty between a citizen and the law and vice versa has been a challenging question that many individuals have been trying to answer for centuries. Throughout history many philosophers, historians, writers etc. have tried and to some extent in their best opinion come up with an answer. Plato, who through Socratic dialogues of the human soul provides a window for understanding the nature of the state, made one such attempt. In his famous dialogue, the Apology, which is a defense of the charges made on Socrates, he compares himself to a gadfly, “…....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
660 words (1.9 pages)