Throughout Gerring’s (2006) description of case selection techniques, the emphasis is set in the methodological structures of each procedure. Each of these techniques relies on certain parameters in which cases look for different means to representativeness. A case study should always be representative of a larger population and this stands a decisive benchmark for its validity as a stand-alone case, either for testing or generating a hypothesis (Gerring, 2006).
The crucial case study however is presented with a more careful insight, since its methodological approach distances from the other techniques. In fact, crucial cases in social sciences, according to Gerring (2006/2007), are problematic to test. Since the nature of a crucial case relies on the deterministic precision of a hypothesis, its applicability to social sciences, where theories always fall prey to a certain degree of ambiguity, must not be taken for granted (2007, p.233). In order to overcome such issue, Gerring reflects on the use of most-likely and least-likely crucial cases, in which the central point relies on assessing the quality of the studied theory and its disconfirmation or confirmation of such, respectably. In summary, the crucial case research design will much depend on the deductive power of the researcher and the quality of the theory under investigation (Ibid, p.235).
This paper will use Chris Hamnet’s article as an example, titled Social Polarisation in Global Cities: Theory and Evidence (1994). His main goal is to discuss Saskia Sassen’s theory of polarisation and its theoretical and empirical validity. Although it is not explicitly stated, the presented case study of the Randstad in the Netherlands, assumes what I could inf...
... middle of paper ...
..., crucial case studies in social sciences are unlikely to be related to a deterministic hypothesis, but are rather used to evaluate the ambiguity of a theory. A “pure” crucial case, that is, a case where a risky hypothesis determines specific causal mechanisms it’s not part of the nature of causal relationships as understood in social sciences. This is the reason why crucial cases must always be treated with scepticism.
• Gerring, J. (2001). Social science methodology: A criterial framework. Cambridge University Press.
• Gerring, J. (2006). Case study research: principles and practices. Cambridge University Press.
• Gerring, J. (2007). Is there a (viable) crucial-case method?. Comparative Political Studies, 40(3), 231-253.
• Hamnett, C. (1994). Social polarisation in global cities: theory and evidence. Urban studies, 31(3), 401-424.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The term “Peckhamania” has been introduced in an article by Chris Martin in 2013, dubbing Peckham as London’s buzzing new hotspot, with “galleries, rooftop bars and foodie night markets that make East London look positively parochial”, a stark contrast to Olsen (1997) labelling it an inner city area which is among the poorest and most deprived in the country... Blighted by ills such as drugs, crime, unemployment, low educational achievement, a deteriorating infrastructure; life lived at the margins.... [tags: Middle class, Social class, Racial segregation]
1615 words (4.6 pages)
- In Death of an Innocent, Chris McCandless goes on a memorable and tragic journey into Alaska, but for most of his expedition he was known, not as Chris McCandless, but as Alexander Supertramp. The reason that he changed his name for his journey was because he is running away from his past and wanted to become the person he believed he really was. Chris McCandless had a very comfortable life of an upper-middle class citizen, with a good education and many opportunities. On a summer trip to California, Chris learned a life shattering secret, that he had actually had several half siblings.... [tags: Death of an Innocent, Chris McCandless, ]
987 words (2.8 pages)
- Jon Krakauer, fascinated by a young man in April 1992 who hitchhiked to Alaska and lived alone in the wild for four months before his decomposed body was discovered, writes the story of Christopher McCandless, in his national bestseller: Into the Wild. McCandless was always a unique and intelligent boy who saw the world differently. Into the Wild explores all aspects of McCandless’s life in order to better understand the reason why a smart, social boy, from an upper class family would put himself in extraordinary peril by living off the land in the Alaskan Bush.... [tags: Character of Chris McCandless]
1654 words (4.7 pages)
- Over time the development of towns and cities has drastically increased since the old cities back in biblical times. The first city known to history was the city of Byblos, which had the reputation for oldest city in the world and dates back to the third millennium. In ancient Greece the term for the city of all cities was called Megapolis, examples of one now would be New York City or Chicago. Cities back in the past were clearly different and constructed compared to modern cities now. A city is defined as permanent settlement, but it doesn’t just start out as a city it has to build it up.... [tags: development of towns and cities increase]
984 words (2.8 pages)
- The Corrupt Social Structure Exposed in A Tale of Two Cities Charles Dickens has been acclaimed as one of the foremost satirists of the nineteenth century. In his novel A Tale of Two Cities Dickens finds fault with the social structure of the society. A few of these social problems are the difference between the classes, the lunacy of the revolution, and the judicial system in effect as this time. The first of the faults in the social structure of the society is the difference between the classes.... [tags: Tale Two Cities Essays]
496 words (1.4 pages)
- Detroit, America’s great comeback city. On May 5th 2013 that slogan was chosen to be the new slogan representing Detroit in a nationally-focused advertising campaign that started last July. Why is Detroit making a comeback and where from. The era of mass production emerged in Detroit in the early twentieth century when Henry Ford’s Dearborn plant opened in 1913. Much of the subsequent development was tied up with the automobile industry. The city’s social geographies were reflective of the strongly racialised organization of labour within the industry.... [tags: Decline of Cities]
1861 words (5.3 pages)
- Cities by John Reader, the acclaimed historian attempts to dive readers deep into the territory of urban historians, depicting and analyzing the greatest cities of planet earth. From the earliest examples of cities to the ultra modern cities, 7000-9000 years later, of Mumbai or Tokyo, Reader paints the picture loud and clear. Cities around the globe are home to half of the entire planets population. Those living in cities, consume nearly 75% of all natural resources in the entire world. From the ruins of the earliest cities to the present, Reader will explore how cities develop and thrive, how they can decline and die, how they remake themselves.... [tags: modern cities, mesopotamia, catalhoyuk]
1287 words (3.7 pages)
- In the comedy-drama movie, About a boy by Chris Weitz and Paul Weitz, many things happened in Marcus’s life. His parents were divorced and the only person he had in his life was his mother, but she was not the best person to be around because she suffered from a deep depression. Marcus’s mother was so deep in depression that she attempted to commit suicide by overdosing on cough syrup medicine. Marcus witnessed his mother cry many times; he couldn’t focus in school because he was afraid that his mother was going to try to commit suicide while he away and couldn’t be able to save her.... [tags: Suicide, Suicide methods, Chris Weitz, Mind]
1241 words (3.5 pages)
- What is a social theory. Social theories are essential building blocks of evidence used to study and interpret social phenomena. Sociological theories are the core and underlying strength of the discipline. The term social theory is coined by the idea about how society changes and develops rapidly making it difficult for those who live in the past to catch up to a new way of thinking. According to Charles Lemart “there are methods of explaining social behavior an extensive list that molded the world for centuries.... [tags: Sociology, Social control theory, Human behavior]
701 words (2 pages)
- The Search for Truth in A Tale of Two Cities "Since before the ancient Greeks, mankind has striven to discern and define truth, a noble if somewhat arduous task"( Swisher 118). Even modern society, despite losing so many of the old, "prudish" morals of preceding generations, still holds truth as one of the greatest virtues and to find truth in life, one of the greatest accomplishments. Authors such as Charles Dickens reflect this great desire to seek and find truth, using many varying mediums to express their opinions or discoveries.... [tags: Tale Two Cities Essays]
2656 words (7.6 pages)