Some believe that racial profiling is a myth. People such as failed conservative Supreme Court nominee Robert Bork, the author of “Civil Liberties After 9/11,” feel that racial profiling “does not exist” and believe that “the idea [of racial profiling] rests on false assumption[s]” (Bork 290). Bork believes there is a “stigma attached to [racial] profiling” which could involve random frisking and luggage checks as a means to maintain national security, and he defines this stigma as a mere matter of political correctness (Bork 290-291). Bork’s view would be more credible if he had any clear evidence that the 9/11 attacks could have been prevented by racial profiling, but he gives his reader no such substantiation. Bork uses the analogy of state policemen pulling over African-Americans for speeding to illustrate the logic behind his position (Bork 290). This logic assumes that it is appropriate to target minorities if...
... middle of paper ...
...or to be considered when seeking to identify potential terrorists. To focus on race is not only ineffective but violates individuals’ civil rights. Smart profiling offers an alternative method in identifying terrorists, yet its continued reliance on human intuition still threatens civil liberties. One possible solution is to move towards a more technical definition of suspicious behavior in an effort to remove human judgment from security decisions. In the meantime, smart profiling is at least a step in the right direction.
Bork, Robert H. "Civil Liberties After 9/11." The Well-Crafted Argument. Eds. Fred D. White and Simone J. Billings. 2nd ed. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 2005. 288-99.
Zakaria, Fareed. “Freedom vs. Security.” The Well Crafted Argument. Eds. Fred D. White and Simone J. Billings. 2nd ed. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 2005. 307-313.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Humanity has always strived to become more “civilized”. Whether it was the manipulation of fire, the domestication of animals, the invention of electricity or the exploration of space, the goal has always been to become more advanced than our predecessors. We think of “civilization” as the opposite of “brutality” and we associate the former with peace and the latter with violence. For this reason, we are unable to deem a race that has walked on the moon as a “violent” race. However, “civilization” doesn’t abolish violence it simply removes the individual’s right to be violent and bestows it into the hands of a separate entity (like the military).... [tags: Hyper Incarcerated Society, Civilization]
1733 words (5 pages)
- In general, experience is very valuable and can aid in making decisions or judgment calls. This is especially true for law enforcement given the nature of their line of work. Police often need to make decisions based on little, specific information. In the same way experience can negatively affect an officer’s decision-making process. Likewise, experience can breed bias. Human’s all carry cultural baggage that may directly affect our actions and decisions. This by no means is an attempt to justify all the choices that an officer may make, but it may explain an inherent reason behind the decision.... [tags: Race Racism Prejudice Essays]
1073 words (3.1 pages)
- ... The Mad Bomber investigation is one of the most well known cases that psychologists were allowed to investigate. As a result of Jack Brussel’s spot-on detailed description of the Mad Bomber, police started to consult with more psychologists and psychiatrists. Psychological Profilers have abetted in multiple well-known cases and have locked up some serious psychos, such as, Jack the Ripper and the Green River Killer. Psychological Profiling is very effective because it uses the style and nature of the crime to apprehend its offender and has a higher closing rate than cases used without it.... [tags: mad bomber, crime, police]
731 words (2.1 pages)
- "I don't want to talk about whether or not racial profiling is legal. Racial profiling is not an effective law enforcement tool." -- Eric Holder, 82nd Attorney General of the United States Before any argument can be made against racial profiling, it is important to understand what racial profiling is. The American Civil Liberties Union, defines racial profiling as "the discriminatory practice by law enforcement officials of targeting individuals for suspicion of crime based on the individual's race, ethnicity, religion or national origin"(Racial Profiling: Definition).... [tags: Black Lives Matter Essays]
1120 words (3.2 pages)
- After the American tragedy of September 11, 2001, airport security became a heated debate that continues today. America must protect itself from terrorist attacks, but some homeland security methods are better than others. In January of 2010, the Obama administration declared that airport passengers from 14 countries, including Pakistan, Yemen, and Saudi Arabia, would be subjected to rigorous screening before flights into the United States (Schneier). Basically, airport security employees would have the right to discriminate against passengers of Arab descent because of the country they were born in.... [tags: Security, Terrorism, Behavior]
870 words (2.5 pages)
- Issues In Psychological Profiling Historically, crime and criminals have always caught the attention of law-abiding citizens. Whenever there is mention of serial killers or unsolved murders or abductions, psychological profiling, floats to the top of the list of concerns (Egger, 1999). Psychological profiling is an attempt to provide investigators with more information about an offender who has not yet been identified (Egger, 1999). Its purpose is to develop a behavioral composite that combines both sociological and psychological assessment of the would-be offender.... [tags: Psychology]
1339 words (3.8 pages)
- Criminal profiling is one of few first things to think of when it comes to forensic psychology. Criminal profiling is featured in popular television shows such as in Law and Order and CSI. Often in those shows, the police officers were able to catch the criminals based on the criminal profile that forensic psychologists came up with. In a theory, the polices rely on criminal profiling to catch criminals, educate the public about a possible criminal, and confirm the witnesses’ accounts. Criminal profiling involves using various methods to guess a criminal’s background, behavior, and even preferences for the victims.... [tags: Criminal Justice]
1257 words (3.6 pages)
- Historically, crime and criminals have always caught the attention of law-abiding citizens. Whenever there is mention of serial killers or unsolved murders or abductions, psychological profiling, now a household term, floats to the top of the list of concerns (Egger, 1999). Psychological profiling is an attempt to provide investigators with more information about an offender who has not yet been identified (Egger, 1999). Its purpose is to develop a behavioral composite that combines both sociological and psychological assessment of the would-be offender.... [tags: Criminology]
694 words (2 pages)
- ... when Leon shot President McKinley, Parker punched hem on the face, knocking the assassin down and disarming him. Czolgosz admitted during court, “I would have shot more but I was stunned by a blow in the face, a frightful blow that knocked me down and then everybody jumped on me!" McKinley’s life was extended for more than two weeks thanks to Parker, and as ironic as it seems, Parker saved the assassins life. After the assassin was disarmed, the people wanted to lynch Leon Czolgosz on the spot but McKinley, still alive thanks again to Parker ,commanded the crowd not to hurt the assassin.... [tags: ethnicity, nationality, race, religion]
1327 words (3.8 pages)
- Racial Profiling Violates the Constitution After the heinous attacks of Sept. 11, Americans have been forced to face the issue of racial profiling? Americans love to use data and statistics to justify their actions. What data might justify special searches of anyone who looks "Arab" at an airport. There are up to 7 million Arab Americans in the United States. If we add all those South Asians (1.6 million), Latinos and African Americans who might "appear" Arab, we have a ballpark figure of at least 10 million folks. How many of these are bona fide terrorists.... [tags: Sociology Racism Prejudice Essays]
711 words (2 pages)