The Situational Theory Approach And Contingency Approach Essay

The Situational Theory Approach And Contingency Approach Essay

Length: 1093 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The situational theory approach and contingency approach are both two major types of leaders approach that researchers have studied for several years. Northhouse (2013, p.99) stated that, “the premise of the theory is that different situations demand different kinds of leadership”. For simple understanding it means that leaders have to be able to switch and adapt their style as different situation arise. Situational approach is broken down into two main dimensions, which is the directive (task) and supportive (relationship) behaviours.
The directive behaviour as used by managers is a way of helping followers achieve their goals by giving direction, establishing goals and methods of evaluation, setting time lines, defining roles and showing how goals are to be achieved Northhouse (2013, p.101). In the directive behaviour the leader is the one in charge, as it is known as the one –way communication.
The situational behaviour helps followers feel comfortable with themselves, their fellow coworkers and their current situation, this involves a two-way communication unlike the directive behaviour, the leaders asks for input from his followers, problem solving, praising, sharing information about oneself but at the end of the day makes the last decision over any matter Northhouse (2013, p.101).
Northhouse came up with a chart to help break down the two major behaviours mentioned above into four distinct categories;
• High directive and low in supportive style (directing)
• High directive and high supportive style (supporting)
• High supportive and low directive (coaching)
• Low supportive and low directive (delegating)
Due to the presences of these categories, the effects of situational approach on leadership became prevalent, the direc...


... middle of paper ...


...understand that they do not have to be everything in the organisation. Understanding the leaders strongest ability and placing him in a point of advantage. This approach matches the leader and the situation but does not demand that the leader fit every situation.
WEAKNESS
• It does not enable a leader grow in their career path, because it does not promote a leader to learn new style of leadership he might end up never being productive at the higher levels of an organisation.
• The LPC scale is arguable because it requires an individual to be the judge of character of another individual and his behaviour, it is not easy to complete correctly without biases or human error.
• There is the tendency to mismatch a leader and a situation in a work place, it does not teach leaders to adapt their styles to various situations in other to improve leadership in the organisation.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Relationship Between Interacting Leadership Variables On Situational And Contingency Approach

- 2. THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN INTERACTING LEADERSHIP VARIABLES IN SITUATIONAL/CONTINGENCY APPROACH. Situational Leadership Theory developed from the writings of Reddin (1967). Reddin 's 3-Dimensional Management Style Theory posits the importance of a manager 's relationship orientation and task orientation in conjunction with effectiveness. Although Reddin suggested that his framework explained effectiveness as a function of matching style to situation, his approach did not identify specific situational attributes that could be explicitly incorporated into a predictive scheme....   [tags: Leadership, Situational leadership theory]

Better Essays
1388 words (4 pages)

Theories Of Educational Leadership : Theories, Situational Theory, And Contingency Theory

- Leadership Theories This paper will address the three theories that are chosen applicable to Educational Leadership. The theories comprise, path-goal theory, situational theory and contingency theory. These theories will be compared and contrasted relevant to Educational Leadership. Additionally, this paper will explain how a particular theory adds or may add to the understanding of Educational Leadership. According to Barnard, theories relevant to educational leadership effect the actions of subordinates and encourage them to follow a specific program of action (Barnard, 1938)....   [tags: Leadership, Situational leadership theory]

Better Essays
1050 words (3 pages)

Contingency Theories Of Leadership : A Focus On The Situational Leadership Model

- Contingency Theories Of Leadership: A Focus On The Situational Leadership Model Name Institutional Affiliation   Contingency Theories Of Leadership: A Focus On The Situational Leadership Model Introduction The situational leadership model in essence suggests that there is nothing like a one size fits all approach with regards to leadership. Therefore, depending on the situation at hand, there are varying levels of management and leadership that are deemed necessary. However, all leaders are encouraged to first identify their most vital priorities or tasks with regard to leadership and management....   [tags: Leadership, Situational leadership theory]

Better Essays
715 words (2 pages)

Leadership Research: The Situational Theory Essay

- ... Once again, we need to emphasize the idea of leadership as an interaction influence system involving a leader, follower, and situational variables. Contingency theory The main emphasis of Fidler’s contingency model of leadership effectiveness is on the interaction between a leader’s style of leadership and the favorableness of the situation for the leader. The leader’s style can be thought of as varying between a highly task-oriented approach and a relationship oriented approach. These styles are not unlike the Ohio State dimensions of initiating structure and consideration....   [tags: contingency theory, path goal theory]

Better Essays
736 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Kurt Lewin 's Contingency Theory

- Fielder’s Contingency Theory Introduction Leadership styles refer to the manner and approach, through which directions are provided, plans being implemented and motivating people. From the employee’s perspective, it encompasses the patterns of both explicit and implicit actions that a leader performs. Kurt Lewin conducted the first major leadership study in 1939 by leading a group of researchers in identifying the various types of leadership (Burnes, 2004). The study remained influential by establishing three major styles of leadership....   [tags: Leadership, Fiedler contingency model, Management]

Better Essays
821 words (2.3 pages)

A Weekly Paper 8 : Situational, Path Goal, Lmx, Mentoring

- Weekly Paper 8: Situational, Path Goal, LMX, Mentoring: Viren Kheni Leadership has been examined for a number of years to discover how successful leaders are created. To better understand leadership, researchers have proposed several theories, including the trait, behavioral, contingency, and full-range models of leadership. Behavioral contingencies state the if-then conditions that set the occasion for the potential occurrence of certain behavior and its consequences. There are various Behavioral Contingency models....   [tags: Leadership, Situational leadership theory]

Better Essays
944 words (2.7 pages)

Contingency Management Theory Essay

- ... The weakness of Fiedler’s theory is that the model is inflexible and ignores a leader's potential for adaptability. There are many other contingency theories that have been developed since Fiedler's work. Some of the more significant theorists and their models include: Vroom and Yetton's (1973) decision-making theory, House's (1971) path-goal theory, Yukl's (1971) multiple-linkage model, Hersey and Blanchard's (1977) situational theory, and Kerr and Jermier's (1978) leader substitution theory (McGlone, 2005)....   [tags: business applications]

Free Essays
629 words (1.8 pages)

Situational Leadership And Its Impact On The Leader 's Personality Essay

- Leaders are our role models. They influence the culture, values, thoughts and actions of the company and its people. Effective leadership is important to any organization’s success. The leaders of an organization must be able to effectively communication the company’s message, delegate work duties, and motivate their employees. The leader’s leadership styles will depend on the leader’s personality. Organizations can choose a leader or manager with a personal style that complements the needs of the company or they can pick a manager who uses the situational leadership style that will change according to employee needs....   [tags: Leadership, Fiedler contingency model]

Better Essays
986 words (2.8 pages)

Leadership Styles As A Teaching Tool Than A Theory Essay

- LEADERSHIP STYLES There are many leadership styles, and none appears to work for every situation, though some seem effective in a broader range of leadership interactions. The questions asked in both the Queendom and Mind Tools surveys generally address each of the leadership styles, Situational, Functional, Relational, Transactional, and Transformational; though to varying degrees. The most interesting aspect of these surveys is, while they are different in length and question complexity, both surveys had very similar results....   [tags: Leadership, Situational leadership theory]

Better Essays
1191 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on Effective Leadership

- 1. Introduction: Scholars and business experts have endeavored to define an effective leader. Some theorists suggested that effective leadership is simply assigning and directing, while others support a more comprehensive philosophy of collaboration with followers, planning, hard work and continuous practice from leaders to lead effectively. This paper seeks to compare and contrast two business leaders to ascertain which the more effective leader is. Firstly, I would introduce two leaders with ephemeral biographies and identify how their traits, behaviors, experience and values influenced and organized their individual groups in achieving the organization goals and strategies....   [tags: e-commerce, contingency theory]

Better Essays
995 words (2.8 pages)