`` Simple Recipes `` By Madeleine Thien, And The Closing Down Of Summer ``

`` Simple Recipes `` By Madeleine Thien, And The Closing Down Of Summer ``

Length: 1795 words (5.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

“Simple recipes” by Madeleine Thien, and “The Closing Down of Summer” by Allister MacLeod both take focus on the struggles of isolation or alienation in their families, caused by the separation of cultural identities, or being away from home due to work. The impression of isolation found in the text is generated from the circumstantial behaviours among the character’s actions, thoughts, or exchange of language. Macleod focuses on how his protagonist has become detached from his family, losing the ability to communicate to them due to his seasonal occupation and adapting to the sub-culture of his work life. Whereas Thiens story demonstrates how the behaviour of a parent’s desire to retain culture has created a dividing tension between two different social identities of oriental parents, and Canadian cultivated children. In which this paper will analyze and interpret the similarities of both stories, in how isolation or alienation is generated because of the inability to properly communicate.

Macleod 's story focuses on the struggling isolation a shaft miner faces in their seasonal occupation, damaging their relationship with family due to the adaptation of a miner’s lifestyle. An emphasized result is the destruction of communication, which in effect deteriorated the protagonist’s position as father and husband. The metaphorical literalness in “delving downward and outward through the unknown depths of and distances, and to become lost and separated and unavailable for communication” [104]. The narrator’s perspective of communicating as a parent has been buried within his work culture. Given his circumstances in being surrounded by others who have forgotten, or has no need for the uses of communication. The reader is given insight...


... middle of paper ...


...issed moments in fulfilling the role as a parent. The missed sentimental realization that he want present for the birth of any of his children, the death of two, nor being present for any youthful accomplishment or occasions. Someone else stepped in taking his role as a father, which is emphasized that “broken tricycle wheels and dolls with crippled limbs have been mended by other hands than mine” For there is a painful realization in Macleon’s fatherly figure, being the odd parent that returns for a short span of time to try and regain his role as a father, yet it doesn’t suffice. Rather he visits children that he can barely connect too, and possibly disregard his position as a father. In the harsh reality of not being there for their upbringing. This absence solidifies itself and he becomes incapable to defend his absence to his children, so it’s kept to himself.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

`` Simple Recipes `` By Madeleine Thien, And The Closing Down Of Summer Essay

- “Simple Recipes” by Madeleine Thien, and “The Closing Down of Summer” by Allister MacLeod, both possess a theme of isolation or alienation within two different family dynamics, caused by cultural division. The impression of isolation found in the text is generated from the the character’s inability to communicate their internal emotions, or the forceful demand to adhere to cultural traditions. Macleod narrating protagonist has become detached from his family, losing the ability to communicate to them due to his seasonal occupation and adapting to the sub-culture of his work life....   [tags: Family, Sociology, Heteronormativity, Norm]

Better Essays
1886 words (5.4 pages)

Simple Recipes : The Closing Down Of Summer Essay

- Simple recipes FOCUS ON JUST LONLINESS The closing down of summer. “Simple recipes” by Madeleine Thien, and “The Closing Down of Summer” by Allister MacLeod both take focus on the struggles of isolation or alienation in their families, caused by the separation of cultural identities, or being away from home due to work. The impression of isolation found in the text is generated from the circumstantial behaviours among the character’s actions, thoughts, or exchange of language. Macleod focuses on how his protagonist has become detached from his family, losing the ability to communicate to them due to his seasonal occupation and adapting to the sub-culture of his work life....   [tags: Family, Sociology, Norm, Heteronormativity]

Better Essays
1808 words (5.2 pages)

Madeleine Thien 's Simple Recipes Essay

- Madeleine Thien’s “Simple Recipes” is a story of an immigrant family and their struggles to assimilate to a new culture. The story follows a father and daughter who prepare Malaysian food, with Malaysian customs in their Canadian home. While the father and daughter work at home, the mother and son do otherwise outside the home, assimilating themselves into Canadian culture. The story culminates in a violent beating to the son by his father with a bamboo stick, an Asian tool. The violent episode served as an attempt by the father to beat the culture back into him: “The bamboo drops silently....   [tags: Family, Son, Interpersonal relationship, Mother]

Better Essays
794 words (2.3 pages)

Essay Lust and Love: A Father's Role

- ... While Lorraine and Kathleen love their father and want him to be with them Paula feels quite differently about hers showing the difference living at home and away can make. Another major difference between the two fathers is the amount of time the narrator spoke of them and the amount of time they were focused on in the stories. While Paula’s father was focused on for a very short amount of time and was not developed very much Kathleen and Lorraine’s father was in the story longer and his character was developed until the very end of the story....   [tags: Madeleine Thien's Simple Recipes]

Better Essays
1102 words (3.1 pages)

A Bird Of The House, By Madeleine Thien Essay

- Memories are an important part of anyone 's lives. To remember is to reflect and to impose meaning onto past events. In the texts, “A Bird in the House”, written by Margaret Laurence, and “Simple Recipes” written by Madeleine Thien, the authors bring across the idea of memories in the main character’s retelling of their lives to show us the relationship between the characters and their fathers respectively. Through the use of visual imagery and the main character 's choice of speech, the idea of memory is emphasized and shown in both stories....   [tags: Short story, Fiction, Remembrance Day]

Better Essays
1891 words (5.4 pages)

Essay about Mother 's Eyes By Madeleine Thien

- Simple recipes This is a story of an immigrated family, narrator’s father and mother who immigrate to Canada from Malaysia. In this family father prepares foods for everybody every day. One day, son’s rebellious behavior broke the silence of life, and father used violence to teach him a lesson, all this happened were in daughter’s eyes. The story is written by Madeleine Thien, “Canadian-born daughter of Malaysian-Chinese immigrants, who lives in Vancouver, British Columbia. Now, whose collection Simple Recipes was named a notable book by the 2001 Kiriyama Paci fic Rim Book Prize” (Brown, 2006)....   [tags: Family, Culture, Rice, Malaysia]

Better Essays
1565 words (4.5 pages)

Gluten Free Recipes For Food Essay examples

- The Ultimate Crepe Cookbook: 50 Easy to Follow Savory, Gluten-Free Recipes for Everyone Whether your health conscious or it’s for health related reasons, many people are eliminating gluten out of their diets and substituting similar products in its place. With this savory Gluten-Free crepe cookbook, I will take the frustration out of the term Gluten-Free and provide you easy to follow recipes that contain everyday ingredients found at your local grocery store. Gluten-Free cooking does not need to be difficult in order to be delicious....   [tags: Flour, Wheat, Gluten, Crêpe]

Better Essays
1594 words (4.6 pages)

Essay about Butternut Squash Chickpea Soup

- There aren't many soups as lush and versatile as butternut squash chickpea soup. This richly flavored combination can be adapted in many ways, seasoned to suit the occasion, and always offers a nutritious combination of vitamins and protein-building amino acids to support all types of diet. About Butternut Squash Chickpea Soup If you are looking for a nutritious, richly flavored soup that can be presented in many guises, a combination of butternut squash and chickpeas used as an adaptable base may be the answer you're looking for....   [tags: Recipes]

Better Essays
804 words (2.3 pages)

Feelings of Suspense in “Dead Simple” by Peter James Essay example

- The novel “Dead simple” by Peter James is a gripping novel which keeps the reader on the edge of his seat throughout. The story is about a young man named Michael who is on his stag due with his friends and when they play a harmless prank on him (burning him in a coffin.) It goes seriously wrong when they are killed in a car accident and the question remains, where is Michael Harrison. This essay will examine how Peter James creates suspense throughout the novel using various literary techniques....   [tags: Dead simple, Peter James, ]

Better Essays
711 words (2 pages)

What Documents To Review At A Closing For A Mortgage Essay

- What Documents To Review At A Closing For A Mortgage Three important mortgage documents 1.     Mortgage 2.     Note 3.     HUD-1 Settlement Statement Mortgage •     People who sign only have an interest in the property and our not responsible to pay for the loan •     Make sure the correct legal description and address are listed •     Gives the rights of the mortgage company o     Usually very standard •     Secures the note •     Gives the lender a claim against the home if you fail to live up to the terms of the loan Note •     Those who sign the note are responsible for paying the mortgage and their credit will be effected (positively and/or negatively) by the loan •     States the in...   [tags: Mortgage Closing Documents]

Free Essays
2180 words (6.2 pages)