Simon and Jack from Lord of the Flies by William Golding Essay

Simon and Jack from Lord of the Flies by William Golding Essay

Length: 1472 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


Simon and Jack from the novel of Lord of the Flies are great representations of the theories of Natural Man written by Aristotle and Thomas Hobbes. The character with the best purpose of representing Aristotle’s theory is Simon due to his morals and spiritual goodness. Leaving Jack as the best representation of Hobbes’s theory due to his violent state and the desire for power. The two theories clash due to the fact that they are polar opposite of one another. Aristotle sates that Natural Man is morally sound and just in their actions, whereas Hobbes states that Natural Man is corrupt and a wicked thing of existence. Therefore the two characters cannot coexist on the island. One or the other will have to come out on top, which Golding gives us a foreshadowed by placeing Jack’s camp on the top of the mountain.
Even though he doesn’t fall into either one of the theories, Ralph is considered “common ground” between the two philosophical arguments. By being the “command ground” for the coexistence of the two theories is rather difficult on Ralph, due to the fact he has to do what’s best for the group and not what’s best for him.
The Natural Man is the state in which a man is born without any teaching from life or from any other man. The theories of two philosophers are at war over this. For one states that a man is naturally just, and has the desire to build a stable society. That man will be filled with all intentions of helping the group prospers. As for the other philosopher, he states that a man is naturally wicked, and will go about any means to prosper himself. Even if that means that causing inflictions upon another man. For that man can gather his wants.
Simon stands on an entirely different level of understand from all the...


... middle of paper ...


... into being a way to see all three properties of these theories of Natural Man and then the combination of the two theories found within his novel. Even though man will never be just a morally sound man, nor will he be totally wicked and cruel, men can be both. Therefore the basis for all men can be the natural combination of both good and cruel within human beings. Golding gives us the solution to the thoughts of the ability for how the combinations of these theories can exist; and that is Ralph.
Ralph is not a representation of either one of the theories, but a representation of a man. He is the figure head of most men in the society of our life today. Most men have both theories in them, so they have to be taught the rights and wrongs though out life. By lessions learned for them self or form they men they grew up around. Men will be what they are taught to be.


Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Character of Simon in William Golding's Lord of the Flies Essay

- The Character of Simon in William Golding's Lord of the Flies      Throughout William Golding's, Lord of the Flies, many of the characters go through changes in their personality traits. From beginning to end, Simon goes through the smallest amount of change than anyone in the novel. Despite the fact that Simon did not really fit in with the other boys, he tried his hardest to make a difference in his and the other's lives.      In the beginning, Simon was described as a 'skinny, vivid little boy…,'; (Golding 24) showing that he was undersized and possibly weaker than the others....   [tags: William Golding Lord of the Flies]

Free Essays
425 words (1.2 pages)

Essay The Character and Role of Simon in Lord of the Flies

- The Character and Role of Simon in Lord of the Flies At the beginning of the novel Simon is described by Golding as a "skinny, vivid little boy" with "black, coarse hair". He is a member of the choir. The first time the boys are all together, Simon faints giving us the impression that he is physically weak. He is later chosen by Ralph to go with him on an expedition of the island. Because he is so "vivid", he is chosen by Ralph and he also has something about him, which attracts attention which may be a reason for Ralph choosing him out of all of the boys there....   [tags: Lord of the Flies William Golding Simon Essays]

Powerful Essays
1667 words (4.8 pages)

Simon and Jack from Lord of the Flies by William Golding Essay

- Simon and Jack from the novel of Lord of the Flies are great representations of the theories of Natural Man written by Aristotle and Thomas Hobbes. The character with the best purpose of representing Aristotle’s theory is Simon due to his morals and spiritual goodness. Leaving Jack as the best representation of Hobbes’s theory due to his violent state and the desire for power. The two theories clash due to the fact that they are polar opposite of one another. Aristotle sates that Natural Man is morally sound and just in their actions, whereas Hobbes states that Natural Man is corrupt and a wicked thing of existence....   [tags: natural man, human nature]

Powerful Essays
1472 words (4.2 pages)

The Presentation of the Deaths of Simon and Piggy in William Golding's Lord of the Flies

- The Presentation of the Deaths of Simon and Piggy in William Golding's Lord of the Flies The deaths of Simon and Piggy and the way they were built up and presented has a few similarities but not many. They mainly contrast and it is that which I will look at. First I will look at the death of Simon, and the way it was presented, then the death of Piggy and the way it was presented. Next, I will look at any differences, since there aren't any important similarities. Simon's death came about when he awakes and it is night....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
704 words (2 pages)

Jack and Simon in Chapter Three of the Lord of the Flies Essay example

- Jack and Simon in Chapter Three of the Lord of the Flies In the Lord of the Flies, William Golding makes many contrasts between his symbolic characters. For example in chapter three, 'Huts on the beach', many contrasts and similarities are made between the two characters Jack and Simon. These descriptions give an idea to their personality and feelings. The description of Simon in the jungle, and Jack in the woods highlights many of their differences. Jack is alone and descriptions like, 'with flared nostrils', and 'ape- like' suggest he is behaving like an animal....   [tags: Lord of the Flies William Golding Essays]

Powerful Essays
796 words (2.3 pages)

Lord of the Flies Character Analysis Essay (Simon)

- Is everybody born purely good inside. Or are we all filled with certain amounts of good and evil. In Lord of the Flies by William Golding a plane full of school boys lands on a deserted island, killing all the adults. With no adult supervision or civilization the boys descend back into the madness and savagery that is human nature. In Lord of the Flies by william Golding his character Simon uses spiritual power by finding out what the beast really is, showing how he failed to warn the others, how his use of the power affected the book as a whole, and how spiritual power is in the real world....   [tags: William Golding's novel]

Powerful Essays
880 words (2.5 pages)

William Golding 's The Lord Of The Flies Essay

- Throughout the novel several different characters are introduced to the reader, such as Ralph, Jack, Simon and Piggy. With all these characters presented to the reader, one can get to see into their minds-eye, which allows the reader to analyze their character. In this case one could examine their basic morals and distinguish between the person’s natural instinct to rely on civilization or savagery to solve their problems. The author of the novel, William Golding, had a “first-hand experience of battle line action during World War II” which caused him to realize, “[that] The war alone was not what appalled him, but what he had learnt of the natural - and original- sinfulness of mankind did....   [tags: Morality, William Golding, Simon says, Novel]

Powerful Essays
1286 words (3.7 pages)

Lord of the Flies, by William Golding Essay

- Throughout Lord of the Flies emotional feelings challenge the boys along with tasks the boys need to complete to get off the island as soon as possible. When the group breaks in two, the reader is shown emotional challenges that individuals undertake prior to this event. Golding uses the breaking of the groups to show the literal breaking point, the straw that breaks the camel's back. We see that several characters such as Piggy Ralph, and Simon want to be part of the group. These individuals face emotional difficulties....   [tags: character analysis, piggy, ralph, simon]

Powerful Essays
1129 words (3.2 pages)

Simon as Christ in Lord of the Flies Essay

- Simon as Christ in Lord of the Flies     The role of the prophet changes with the society in which he lives. In modern society, a prophet is a visionary, telling people what they can become; in Biblical times, a prophet was the voice of God, telling his people what they had to become to fulfill their covenant with God.  In William Golding's Lord of the Flies, the prophet is a peaceful lad, Simon.  He alone saw that the jungle, which represented freedom and the lack of civilization, was not to be feared but to be understood; he alone knew that the mythical Beast of the island, feared by all the boys, was, in fact, their own inherent savagery....   [tags: Lord Flies Essays]

Powerful Essays
873 words (2.5 pages)

"Lord of the Flies" by William Golding Essay

- Lord of the Flies “is both a story with a message” and “a great tale of adventure”. The novel Lord of the Flies by William Golding is an allegorical novel representing what the world was like during World War II. The novel is about a group of boys who survive a plane crash during the Blitzkrieg. The boys are stranded on an island and must find a way to survive until they are rescued. Most of the characters do not even know each other before the crash happens. As the novel progresses, the characters begin to show their different personalities....   [tags: Lord of the Flies, William Golding]

Powerful Essays
765 words (2.2 pages)