Similar Themes in both Roger Malvin's Burial and The Minister's Black Veil by Nathaniel Hawthorne

Similar Themes in both Roger Malvin's Burial and The Minister's Black Veil by Nathaniel Hawthorne

Length: 2631 words (7.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Research Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

In both “Roger Malvin's Burial” and “The Minister's Black Veil,” Nathaniel Hawthorne centralizes the themes of sin, guilt, and repentance. Both are very much set in terms of what defines sin and, in turn, what would constitute action leaving an opening for forgiveness, and both leave many a question unanswered in the story being told. The main question for us becomes, then, one of applicability. Does either story hold a message, if so, what? In considering the two, it may be that they do indeed hold a message, but maybe that message is not one that Hawthorne himself could ever have intended. In this paper I will deal with the themes of guilt, sin, repentance and how Hawthorne developed them in both stories.
Considering first “Roger Malvin's Burial,” the reader is immediately caught off-balance in terms of the presentation of the background to the story. A battle has been fought and won. This, in the introduction, is presented in a fashion when Hawthorne tells us that “The battle, though so fatal to those who fought, was not unfortunate in its consequences to the country; for it broke the strength of a tribe and conduced to the peace which subsisted during several ensuing years” (20). In this lack of empathy for the Native Americans protecting their own homeland, we may realizes from the beginning that we are dealing with a writer whose sensibilities we may not ourselves share. As the story develops, this tends to be confirmed.
Two men, Reuben Bourne and Roger Malvin, have survived the battle and are trying to make their way back home. Both are wounded. As they stop in a forest by “…a young and vigorous sapling stood…,” Malvin entreats Bourne to abandon him and save himself (20). The men are familiar with one another and, at fir...

... middle of paper ...

...wthorne has a message or lesson to us and he delivers his message or lesson by his way such as he made his protagonist in both stories as guilty. His goal is to reveal something about unmoral and the people have, sin, guilt, shame, and they need a repentance. The sin, guilt, and shame, in the case of Bourne, a person who failed to keep his vow, he suffers guilt. the other hand, the sin, guilt, shame, in the case of Mr. Hooper, especially the mask is unbelievable that Mr. Hooper wears the mask and he did not take off even though when he is dying because the people’s sins. In both stories, we cannot accept Elizabeth's sacrifice, nor that of Cyrus. We would have been more moral for Mr. Hooper to have lifted his mask for Elizabeth and graced her with an explanation. Also we consider Hawthorne's stories exemplify a moral lesson, a lesson Hawthorne maybe never intended.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Main Themes of Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter and The Minister's Black Veil

- Main Themes of Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter and The Minister's Black Veil Nathaniel Hawthorne’s works often have parallel themes and similar characters. His approach is quite gloomy and the atmosphere for his stories is many times sad and depressing. Hawthorne concentrates his novel and short stories around the Puritan community, which adds to the tense and unforgiving atmosphere. One of his most renowned novels, The Scarlet Letter and his short story, The Minister’s Black Veil contain many of his typical elements and are many times referred synonymously....   [tags: Nathaniel Hawthorne, Scarlet Letter, Black Veil]

Research Papers
776 words (2.2 pages)

Judgmental Behavior in A&P, Revelation, and The Minister's Black Veil Essay

- Judgmental Behavior in A&P, Revelation, and The Minister's Black Veil Judging a person is very common in today's society. People everyday, judge one another, whether it is judging another's appearance, which is the most common, or judging the way one behaves, everyone is guilty of it. However, in most cases one is making judgments about someone without even knowing a person at all. It is wrong to judge someone because one can really hurt another's feelings, or it may backfire on them, and they may be the one to end up getting hurt....   [tags: A&P Minister's Black Veil Revelation]

Free Essays
1578 words (4.5 pages)

The Minister 's Black Veil Essay

- Milford Mockery The short story, The Minister’s Black Veil written by Nathaniel Hawthorne, is set in Milford, a Puritan town in New England, in the early 1600s. Hawthorne portrays the inhabitants of Milford as particularly petty, judgmental, and hypocritical, and by portraying the inhabitants as such implication arises about small towns as a whole. Hawthorne wrote The Minister’s Black Veil in order to mock the culture of small towns. Hawthorne mocks the inhabitants of Milford by portraying their concerns regarding the veil as petty and unreliable....   [tags: Short story, Nathaniel Hawthorne, Mock object]

Research Papers
1001 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about The Minister’s Black Veil

- In the short story, “The Minister’s Black Veil,” Nathaniel Hawthorne tells the Mr. Hooper’s black veil and the words that can describe between him and the veil. Hawthorne demonstrates how a black veil can describe as many words. Through the story, Hawthorne introduces the reader to Mr. Hooper, a parson in Milford meeting-house and a gentlemanly person, who wears a black veil. Therefore, Mr. Hooper rejects from his finance and his people, because they ask him to move the veil, but he does not want to do it....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Hawthorne]

Free Essays
970 words (2.8 pages)

The Minister’s Black Veil Essay

- In his various works, Nathaniel Hawthorne addresses the religious themes dominant in colonial Puritan society. For example, the beloved Mr. Hooper of Hawthorne’s parable The Minister’s Black Veil dons a black veil, a mysterious change which the Puritans believed “could portend nothing but evil” (Hawthorne 630). As a result, the Puritans isolate their minister. Even though the parable does show the Puritans’ harsh and superstitious reaction to the vagary of the minister, the veil itself symbolizes both the minister’s isolation from society and his connection to society through original sin....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Nathaniel Hawthorne]

Research Papers
1831 words (5.2 pages)

A Comparison of "The Scarlet Letter" and "The Minister's Black Veil" Essays

- Throughout his literary endeavors, Nathaniel Hawthorne utilizes symbolism to present a certain theme that pertains to human nature and life. In his works, The Scarlet Letter and "The Minister's Black Veil", Hawthorne uses symbolism to present a common theme pertaining to religion; that though manifested sin will ostracize a person from society, un-confessed sin will destroy the soul. The central theme in The Scarlet Letter is that manifested sin will ostracize one from society and un-confessed sin will lead to the destruction of the inner spirit....   [tags: Comparative Literature]

Research Papers
730 words (2.1 pages)

The Minister's Black Veil and Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl Essay

- Comparing Two Works of Literature “The Minister’s Black Veil” and “Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl” are two stories that have had the most impact on me from our assigned readings. Interestingly, both of these stories were written around the mid 1850’s. The former reading focuses on our sin and the latter on the issue of slavery. Both sin and slavery seem to be two concerns that had once corrupted this country. Some people could argue that it is continuing to do so. In my opinion, prejudice, discrimination, and sin are still occurring in the United States....   [tags: comparing two works of literature]

Research Papers
1199 words (3.4 pages)

The Minister's Black Vail As Art Essays

- Art Is Art Is Hawthorne When an author (artist) can make his emotions, thoughts, ambitions, and inner self materialize, he has reached the dearest form of art, and the artwork can never mean as much to anyone as it does the one who created it. The artist does not own nor can he interpret completely due to the ever growing life-like attributes that the art/literature has adopted. Therefore, Hawthorne himself could not put into words an interpretation of The Minister's Black Vail because the story its self is an interpretation of something living inside the author, a feeling that can only be felt....   [tags: Nathaniel Hawthorne]

Free Essays
1804 words (5.2 pages)

Comparing Poor Man's Pudding, Bartleby, Minister's Black Veil, or Masque of the Red Death

- Lack of Epiphany in Poor Man's Pudding, Bartleby, Minister's Black Veil, or Masque of the Red Death In the Melville stories, "Poor Man's Pudding and Rich Man's Crumbs" and "Bartleby, the Scrivener", the narrators go through what appear to be life-changing experiences. Hawthorne offers a similar outline in "The Minister's Black Veil" as does Poe in "Masque of the Red Death". Yet, at the conclusion of each of these stories, there is no evidence to suggest that the narrator is affected by the differences (and perhaps similarities) of their lives and those less fortunate....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Research Papers
1069 words (3.1 pages)

Pride in Young Goodman Brown and The Minister's Black Veil Essay

- Pride in Young Goodman Brown and The Minister's Black Veil        Many of Hawthorne's characters wrap themselves in a pride of intellect. The characters become victims of their pride and consequently suffer.  Goodman Brown, from "Young Goodman Brown" and Hooper, from "The Minister's Black Veil" are two characters that suffer from a pride of intellect.  Their pride causes them similar problems and they end up living similar lives, although they came from different backgrounds.        Hooper and Goodman Brown both become isolated from society.  Hooper had a revelation, and he feels that he truly understands human nature and sin....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Research Papers
851 words (2.4 pages)