Should Welfare Recipients Be Mandatory Drug Testing? Essay

Should Welfare Recipients Be Mandatory Drug Testing? Essay

Length: 1049 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

How many times have you witnessed or heard stories about a Welfare recipients selling their food stamps for cash? We automatically assume it is to buy drugs, alcohol, cigarettes or, even a lottery ticket. What about the Facebook post showing welfare recipients buying an IPhone, IPad or gaming system? The comments that are attached to those postings show the anger people have against these behaviors. The problem is we assume all Welfare recipients are like this and all recipients are lazy and out to cheat the system. I at one pointed agreed with the backlash towards Welfare recipients and commended the mandatory drug testing at one point. During a recent debate with my classmates over this issue I was forced to be against mandatory drug testing and had to research and argue why Welfare recipients should not be subjected to drug testing for their benefits. After fighting my case and winning (of course). I started asking myself why was I so passionate for mandatory testing and was my view based more on hate, fear and assumption then facts. After looking at articles, facts and debating my assigned view on it. I had completed changed my mind. I am now against mandatory drug testing for Welfare recipients.

Drug testing is based on a stereotypes, studies show that out of the Welfare recipients population with a substance abuse disorder at anywhere from five and 27 percent, those reporting illicit drug use around 20 percent or less (Welfare, 2012). Michigan imposed a random testing on their recipients a found only 10 percent of them tested positive for illicit drugs, with 3 percent testing positive for “hard” drugs, such as meth and/or cocaine. Some of the use can be seen as recreational drug use, which is not an excuse especially ...


... middle of paper ...


...ese people at the stake we should be looking for other alternative ways to help. After the debate on my long drive home (45 minutes) I asked myself. How could we help but also hold people accountable? An idea that would work in my mind would be to offer incentive to recipients who volunteer to drug test. If we placed rules on volunteered drug testing, where individuals would get an “bonus” if they passed, if they failed it would result in lost benefits. These would give the receipts a goal to stop using drugs in order to receive more income. We could also offer drug program for those individual suffer from addiction. For anyone that completes 2-day program once a week would receive an additional $25 to $50 in benefits. Not only are we helping them with the addiction we are helping better themselves since many of these program include classes on improving their life.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Drug Testing Welfare Recipients Should Not A Positive Impact On The American Society

- For decades, since 1935, Americans have been receiving financial assistance from the government for many reasons. These reasons can range from being without a job for a period of time, to being too old to work, to even being too poor to support a family. One of the biggest controversial topics of welfare are should we drug test welfare recipients. There are many pros and cons to both sides of the argument, but drug testing welfare recipients could make a positive impact on the American society. Some of the positive impacts of drug testing welfare recipients are possibly saving taxpayers’ money, encouraging drug free lives, creating a fairness between working class, and non-working class fami...   [tags: United States, Social class, Working class]

Better Essays
908 words (2.6 pages)

Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients Essay

- There are suggestion that welfare recipients need to be drug tested, to make sure that taxpayers are not paying for their drug habits. Why would you want to give government benefits to someone who may, either directly or indirectly use the benefits to support their drug habit. Why can’t we drug test welfare recipients. Last year, Utah Republicans passed and enacted a law that mandated drug testing for welfare recipients. Many people argue that “forcing the welfare recipient to concede to waive their rights to random drug testing is unconstitutional and could be considered, blackmail.”(Drug Testing American Civil Liberties Union)....   [tags: Welfare Reform Essays]

Better Essays
1386 words (4 pages)

Drug Testing For Welfare Recipients Essay

- “America is facing a national debt of more than $14 trillion” (Vitter). This debt is only made worse by Welfare recipients who abuse the welfare benefits to purchase illegal drugs that hurts the economy and is a danger to society. This is happening all over the world and nothing has done about it. Some say drug testing is a unfair attack on the poor but it could actually benefit them as a push to get help. Drug Testing Welfare recipients will better the economy in several ways. It would be an uprising change for everyone....   [tags: screenings, abuse]

Better Essays
515 words (1.5 pages)

Drug Testing For Welfare Recipients Essay

- Drug Testing Welfare Recipients each urinalysis test cost the state $19, he said. Therefore, the total cost of the Addiction Severity Index Tests was $34,770 and the total cost of the urinalysis tests was $10,203. When the costs of all three-drug screenings are added together, the total comes to $82,773. That is more than double the $35,910 it would have cost if Oklahoma TANF applicants had all been screened using just urinalysis testing as former state Rep. Liebmann originally envisioned”(Ellis)....   [tags: Drug addiction, Addiction, Heroin, Tax]

Better Essays
1317 words (3.8 pages)

Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients Essay

- The history of social welfare can be traced back to ancient times, but the time most influential to the start of social welfare programs in the United States occurred during the great depression. In 1935, then President Theodore Roosevelt introduced the Social Security Act. This act guaranteed pensions, unemployment insurance, and help for children and the disabled. The Works Progress Administration was also put in to place and helped unemployed people find jobs (HISTORY.COM-New Deal). A proposition to mandate drug testing for recipients has been brought up in more recent times, namely by Governor Rick Scott (R) of Florida....   [tags: Welfare Reform Essays]

Better Essays
2110 words (6 pages)

Welfare Recipients Drug Tested Essay

- There has been an ongoing controversy as to whether welfare recipients should have to have drug testing done. Drug testing will ensure that recipients will not abuse the money they’re given by the government. Having people on welfare take drug test is advantageous because it could save the system money, it would help social workers identify children who are around drug abuse, and it would deter people from purchasing and using illegal drugs; however, it does have a downside such as people who are on prescription medication will show false positives, it can be an invasion of privacy and drug testing can take hundreds and even thousands of dollars to administer....   [tags: drug testing, public assistance]

Better Essays
1318 words (3.8 pages)

Drug Testing Welfare Recipients Essay

- ... The unemployment rate goes beyond the lack of available jobs in the U.S.; unemployment also falls back on the individuals without jobs. While there are many unemployed Americans who do everything in their power to find a job, there are also several who abuse the system. Heritage.org reports that of the adults reported to be using illegal drugs, a majority of the users were unemployed. As seen in Appendix 3, 17.5% of adults using illegal drugs in 2010 were also unemployed. Additionally, according to the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, severe barriers to unemployment were experienced by substance abusing women by more than double of those who do not abuse substances....   [tags: welfare assistance policy needs to change]

Better Essays
1101 words (3.1 pages)

Essay about Mandatory Drug Testing For Welfare Recipients

- The process of drug testing individuals who are applying or receiving welfare benefits has recently become the focus of a widely spread controversy. Florida, the first state to pass the law, now requires all individuals applying for public assistance to undergo drug testing. The state of Kentucky, among others, have considered following this trend. State lawmakers hope to prevent the squandering of taxpayer dollars on drugs by proposing similar guidelines. Alabama’s states representative Kerry Rich clearly affirmed his state’s position on the matter, “I don’t think the taxpayers should have to help fund somebody’s drug habit” (qtd....   [tags: Require Drug Testing to Receive Welfare]

Better Essays
1334 words (3.8 pages)

Welfare Drug Testing in the United States-Should it be Required? Essay

- The idea of helping others is not a new concept. There are always individuals who need a little extra help every once in a while to get by. The main concept of welfare in the United States has been around since the 1800’s, for that very reason, to assist the needy. During the past five years, many have recognized a trend in welfare recipients and they want answers. Legislation has been submitted left and right regarding the issue of whether or not individuals receiving welfare should be drug tested in order to receive benefits from welfare assistance programs....   [tags: Welfare State, Poverty, Federal Assistance]

Better Essays
1835 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on Drug Testing Not Required

- It’s the middle of the month and bills are due. Will there be enough money to pay the bills and buy the groceries for the month. These are just a few worries that welfare recipients have everyday of their life living paycheck to paycheck. Should welfare recipients be stereotyped as drug users just because they don’t have all the money they need to pay for the cost of living. Citizens living like this don’t exactly have the spare money to pay for the drug tests. So who will pay for these tests. In Lizette Alvarez’s article, she used Newton’s statement that citizens who are drug tested before receiving welfare benefits and test negative will be reimbursed by the state, but the money that is us...   [tags: welfare recipients, paychecks, money]

Better Essays
1217 words (3.5 pages)