Essay on Should We Treat Minors With Leniency?

Essay on Should We Treat Minors With Leniency?

Length: 1374 words (3.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

When discussing juvenile offenders, there seems to be a distinct divide between how they should be treated in a court of law. Some believe such young citizens should be treated with leniency in court, while others could not agree less. So this raises the question, “Should we treat minors with more leniency than their adult counterparts because of their young, developing minds?” I believe that treating minors with leniency is doing them an insufferable injustice and it is vital that we treat them in equivalence to adults to instill the lesson that no one wrongful actions are inexcusable because of their age.
First and foremost, juveniles are commonly thought of as underdeveloped and naive children who are not always aware of the repercussions of their actions. Often times adults assume this mentality and believe that they should be treated with more of an open mind because of this. In fact, many argue that “the juvenile justice system was established in recognition of the fact that children and adolescents are quite different than adults” (Coalition). With this in mind, one may claim adolescents are incompetent and feel as if they are incapable of dealing with the repercussions they may face in adult prisons.Or perhaps they have sympathetic hearts when dealing with children, due to the fact that adolescence is typically associated with innocence,
However, what they fail to realize is that when minors are tried as such they are being “protected by a lenient and highly outdated juvenile justice system” (Estudiollo). As you can see, the
Seal 2
juvenile justice system is an extremely toxic one, because kids can take advantage of their situation and easily manipulate the outcome in their favor. Some youths are even known to commit cri...


... middle of paper ...


...ishment” (Coalition). As a society we must adopt the “tough love” approach to these juveniles if we ever want to make any progress. We cannot allow our sympathy to stand in the way of teaching these kids a valuable learning experience.
In short, treating minors in equivalence to adults in vital so that we do not serve them an insufferable injustice. Just because juveniles are young does not necessarily mean that they are naive and rehabilitation centers are always the most effective, especially when they are forced upon young adults More importantly, we need to remember that it is society’s duty to steer young juveniles in the right direction when given the opportunity. When dealing with juvenile offenders, we are forced to make a tough decision, but we have to remember that we cannot let our sympathetic nature get in the way of a vital lesson these teens must learn.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Should Minors Receive Parental Consent before Having an Abortion?

- Abortion is a very sensitive, yet popular, topic that is plaguing the United States. According to Merriam-Webster, abortion is, “A medical procedure used to end a pregnancy and cause the death of a fetus.” (n.d.). According to Griffin-Carlson &Mackin (1993), “In 1988, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) reported that there were 1,371,285 abortions in the United States, 25% of which were obtained by women under 19. Researches at the National Center for Health Statistics estimated that of the 1.1 million pregnancies among teenagers in 1981, 40% ended in abortion, 13% in miscarriage, and 47% in live births (p....   [tags: unwanted pregnancies in minors]

Better Essays
1509 words (4.3 pages)

Essay about Should Minors Be Prosecuted As Adults?

- There are many questions arising about whether a minor should be prosecuted as an adult. Throughout the years many people have become dissatisfied with the system and the leniency towards minors committing heinous crimes. In present time, people have insisted that if the child commits a crime, he/she should therefore be treated as a criminal. Well, is there an age limit to restrict sentencing. At what age are a child’s thought process developed to know right from wrong. What percentage of people agree with this process....   [tags: Crime, Criminology, Criminal law, Criminal justice]

Better Essays
1026 words (2.9 pages)

Juvenile Offenders : A Distinct Divide Between How They Should Be Treated

- When discussing juvenile offenders, there seems to be a distinct divide between how they should be treated. Some believe such young citizens should be treated with leniency in court while others completely disagree. This raises the question, “Should minors be treated with more leniency than their adult counterparts due to their youth?” Despite that the judicial system has flaws, treating juvenile offenders as adults in a court of law proves to be disadvantageous. To start off, it is important to realize that the juvenile justice system was created to specialize in aiding the youth of today....   [tags: Crime, Judge, Juvenile delinquency, Criminology]

Better Essays
1189 words (3.4 pages)

Should There Be Legal Curfew For Minors? Essay

- Throughout the United States a question regarding teenagers is “Should there be a legal curfew for minors”. Some parents agree that there should be, while others think otherwise. The whole issue behind teen curfew came about when 80 percent of juvenile crimes began happening between 9a.m – 10p.m. Nothing seemed to reduce the crimes so the only solutions the law enforcement officials could come up with was a curfew. Little did they know it would cause more problems than the actual issue itself. The mayor and police say that curfew for teens reduces juvenile crime and prevents young children from becoming crime victims....   [tags: Crime, Juvenile delinquency, Curfew, Childhood]

Better Essays
1905 words (5.4 pages)

Essay on Should Minors Contract Be Legal?

- Capacity Capacity states persons under the age of 18 whom are classed as minors do not have the lawful capacity to sign a contract. It is illegal to accept a person under that age into a contract. Types of services, goods including Clothes, alcohol, entry into nightclubs and venues are strictly monitored and are forbidden to minors. Minors Contract Act 1987 covers minors and adults. States the seller of services and products providing to the buyers can sue the sellers if there are not of legal age....   [tags: Contract, Marketing, Contract law]

Better Essays
706 words (2 pages)

The Ethics of Selling Cigarrettes to Minors Essay

- Ethically as we Americans have defined is not on the minds of these executives of the cigarette firms. Our society has made it ethically and legally wrong to sell cigarettes to a minor. These companies located in the United States adhere to the laws and ethical issues within our borders, so what is the difference when they practice these unethical business transactions in smaller countries. These smaller, less developed countries do not have the technology and understanding to disallow the sale of cigarettes to minors....   [tags: Selling Cigarrettes to Minors]

Free Essays
612 words (1.7 pages)

Should The Minors Be Charged With The Death Penalty? Essay

- We as a country do not want to be looked at as someone who just loves to kill anybody for any little thing. We do what 's justice and giving minors the option with death penalty is just wrong. Minors should not be charged with the death penalty because it would not be justified to be kill that young. It would be a cruel and unusual punishment and that goes against what the constitution stands for. You would have to change the law in some states in order for this to happen and that would be a long process to deal with....   [tags: Capital punishment]

Better Essays
1044 words (3 pages)

Medical Marijuana Should NOT Be Legal For Minors Essay

- With the major and ongoing controversy of the legalization of marijuana, medical marijuana has been thrown into the limelight as an excuse as to why marijuana is “good.” But with medical marijuana’s supposed advancements, more and more doctors are prescribing it to anyone who claims to have a headache and now they are moving their clientele base to young children and teens who are not even old enough to know the long-term damage of the “medicine” their doctors are so willingly prescribing. While many doctors are beginning to jump on the medical weed train, others are continuing to speak against the effects; especially on minors....   [tags: Argumentative Essays]

Better Essays
1026 words (2.9 pages)

Should Minors Be Required Parental Consent? Essay

- Should minors be required to have parental consent to obtain birth control. I believe that today’s adolescents between the ages of thirteen through eighteen should be able to obtain a form of birth control without parental consent. Minors will often make life changing decisions regardless of their parent’s opinion or consent. During a minors teen years their curiosity will obscure their judgement. As for parents, the odds of teens reaching out to them aren’t in their favor. Sexual conversations between parents and teens are over looked....   [tags: Birth control, Pregnancy, Adolescence]

Better Essays
1045 words (3 pages)

Should Minors Be Sentenced? Sentences If They Are Guilty Of Violent Crimes?

- Should Minors Be Sentenced to Life Sentences If They Are Guilty of Violent Crimes. Introduction Since the enlargement of violent acts, the majority of the public have began to think about how the juvenile system should convict their minors. While some people believe a minor who commits a violent crime should be tried as an adult, there is psychological evidence which shows a minors brain does not process prison the same way an adult brain will. A lot of people believe minors usually are influenced by the people around them such as gang members, drug dealers, or an individual in their environment who is much older than them and could pressure them to do the act....   [tags: Crime, Murder, Violent crime, Violence]

Better Essays
1310 words (3.7 pages)