The article, “Virtual Child Pornography Should Not Be Banned,” by Wendy Kaminer, argues that “virtual” child pornography should not be banned because no child is harm. Kaminer serves on the national board of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU). Kaminer claims since no “real” child is being harm in the production, it should not be banned.
Kaminer start her argument by saying that it is possible that “virtual” child pornography may encourage pedophiles to act on their impulses or may help them in seducing children, but there is no evidence proving that these images have that want effects. She relied her sources on stating what the Child Pornography Prevention Act (CPPA)prohibited and what she believe they fail to realize and considered when making the Act of 1996. She also made points on how movies and ads are involved in “virtual” child pornography.
Kaminer argument was good, it was not that strong for me to think on it but she did point out good examples such as: how forty-year old mistake fifteen years old for young adults, which ...
... middle of paper ...
...e than emotions when supporting her argument. As one articles tried with evidence and the other with emotions to support their argument, they both lack stronger evidence and did not catch the reader attention that well. There are still more articles to examining on the subject but in the end, I felt Kaminer gave a stronger argument with more evidence and support then Rodriguez.
Rodriguez, Paul M. “Virtual Child Pornography Should Be Banned,” Understanding and
Engaging Humanity. Ed. Brad McAdon, Mary E. Williams, Auriana Ojeda, and Williams
Dudley. Farmington Hills, MI: Greenhaven Press 2010, 203-208
Kaminer, Kaminer. “Virtual Child Pornography Should Not Be Banned,” Understanding and
Engaging Humanity. Ed. Brad McAdon, Mary E. Williams, Auriana Ojeda, and Williams
Dudley. Farmington Hills, MI: Greenhaven Press 2010, 209-213
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- In today’s fast developing and modern society the thought of seeing two grown adults having sex is still considered taboo. Most Americans cringe at the thought of seeing pornography and dismiss the act as nothing more than a senseless lewd act. Yet, the Supreme Court held that pornography was to be considered a form of personal expression and should be protected under the first amendment (New York v. Ferber, 1973). The Supreme Court did not choose to extend the same constitutional protection to child pornography, arguing against its explicit and hurtful content.... [tags: child, protect, computer, value]
1504 words (4.3 pages)
- ... For instance, Facebook does not allow attacks and truly offensive speeches, however it does consent humor or satire (Facebook Guidelines). Analogously, YouTube clearly states that it is “not a shock site” (YouTube Community Guidelines); the company staff reviews flagged videos all day long and censors those who violate their Community Guidelines. When it comes to legal videos that may be inappropriate, the team instantly resorts to age-restriction. Both of these internet giants encourage free speech while supervising it and immediately removing content that is clearly offensive to the general public.... [tags: blocked, information, anamosity, criticism]
973 words (2.8 pages)
- To redeem themselves from the shame adults would say Internet pornography would be considered freedom of speech, but listed in that 1st amendment freedom of speech is evident but it has limitations. Internet pornography also affects adult addicts. It could get out of hand or to the point where it could make an impact on others where someone could get raped or infected with a disease. America is on the brink of banning Internet pornography, in fact down did ban pornography, but most individuals still entertain themselves with these sites.... [tags: Pornography, Addiction, Pornography addiction]
1458 words (4.2 pages)
- Introduction For the past 30 years, pornography has been a subject that has divided many North Americans as the topic became increasingly controversial with time. The subject makes for a very significant ethical issue mainly because it’s an issue that has the capability of altering our freedom of expression and because it’s a topic that invokes many conflicting values and competing ideas of right and wrong. Furthermore, pornography is also a major ethical issue because many of those that are against feel as though it infringes on societies’ morals as many believe that “viewing even mildly explicit pornography leads to an interest in increasingly deviant material” (McNaught and Renneboog).... [tags: Pornography Essays]
1993 words (5.7 pages)
- Virtual Child Pornography Should be Legal This nation has several issues over which most people's minds freeze up, with the disastrous drug war probably leading the list. I don't share a feeling of squeamishness and horror when it comes to drugs: What I don't want, I don't take, it's that simple. And I don't spend time fretting that my neighbors might be toking, or snorting, in the privacy of their homes. Child pornography is something else; it pushes all kinds of emotional hot-buttons in me.... [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Argument Essays]
589 words (1.7 pages)
- The Pornography Debate Pornography has been the topic of discussion in the court systems for years. Many would like to see legislation against it and software to filter it. The problem is it's not that easy and making laws against it would pose a problem against the first amendment. There have many issues brought up on the grounds that it is demoralizing to women and is filth for the eyes of children. But, is pornography really that harmful. There are many reasons why the government is having trouble putting restrictions on pornography.... [tags: Pornography]
823 words (2.4 pages)
- Pornography is an age-old phenomenon that has been under much modern-day scrutiny. With the recent proliferation of online pornography, possible social ramifications of sexually explicit material on uncontrolled mediums have become the subjects of intense debate. Proponents of a liberal approach toward pornography argue that access to online smut is a constitutionally protected freedom and "a harmless diversion that serves to satisfy curiosity and relieve sexual tensions.5" Opponents of this view are particularly concerned with the social effects of online pornography and its effect on the values and morals of minors who can access pornographic images.... [tags: Internet Pornography Essays]
1320 words (3.8 pages)
- Very few of us are strangers to pornography. Definitions and opinions aside, in each of our lives there was a moment when we first encountered that particular book or image or movie which forever skewed our conventional view of sex. After our introduction to pornography, sex just didn't seem as clean, serious or sacred. It became clumsy, juvenile, or simply laughable. I first became an acquaintance of pornography at the age of thirteen during a summer visit to my uncle's bachelor bungalow. In the bottom drawer of an old chest I found some moldy old copies of Hustler Magazine.... [tags: Pornography Censorship]
3174 words (9.1 pages)
- Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.(Wallace: 3) A statement from a document that a group of individuals put together to ensure their own ideas and beliefs would never change. The group of people was the forefathers of the United States of America and that document: The United States Constitution.... [tags: Pornography Essays]
2111 words (6 pages)
- Many people have many ideas and opinions on different things in society. One of these things that come up frequently is a person's opinion on pornography whether it is good or bad for society. My opinion is that porn is good for the society with limitations. Limitations that I believe in are that all persons in the pornography must be or the age of eighteen or older and animal pornography should be banned from print. These limitations could be made by the government or by the companies which make the pornography.... [tags: Pornography Essays]
673 words (1.9 pages)