The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer demonstrates a parade of polarizing ethical issues of today, but the topic of mandatory cervical cancer vaccines particularly caught my attention. I viewed the video not from the lens of a health care professional, but from the stance of a mother of a beautiful two year old little girl. As is the way of many parents, I am fiercely protective and want nothing short of the best for my daughter. Deciding what is best when it comes to mandatory vaccinations for cervical cancer is an issue being faced by parents of preteen girls all across the United States. Consequently, the commentary details the statistics behind human papillomavirus (HPV) and the correlating numbers leading to cervical cancer and sexually transmitted diseases (STDs). The debate comes in whether or not the vaccine should be mandatory. On one hand, as a parent, I do not like being told that my child must have the vaccine. This is a clear violation of her autonomy. On the other hand, I think of the benefit to my daughter if the majority of her peers were covered by the vaccine, ultimately protecting her via herd immunity. This is, in short, a kind of social justice (Morrison, 2010). As for as how I will address this issue with my daughter, I feel the only ethical thing to do is to implement a kind of informed consent. Although legall...
... middle of paper ...
... of the patient.
In conclusion, the health care industry is discovering new technology and compounding choices with each passing year. The decisions of the current health care consumer are complex and a very personal choice. For example, cancer vaccines for HPV bring the dilemma of vaccinating minors who should have autonomy. In addition, fraud in business is muddying the waters of the health care industry, in addition to complex topics such as euthanasia. Finally, as the landscape of healthcare continues to develop, the decisions of a well informed patient and competent patient should be honored.
Morrison, E. (2010). Ethics in health administration: a practical approach for decision makers. Jones & Bartlett Publishers.
Morrison, E., & Furling, E. (2014). Health Care Ethics: Critical Issues for the 21st Century. Jones & Bartlett Learning.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Vaccinations are designed to help people go through their everyday life. A country doctor, Edward Jenner, who lived in Berkeley, England, first administered vaccines in 1796 (Health Affairs). Throughout history, vaccinations have become better to where they are safer for the human body. Everyone should get vaccinated against certain disease to stay healthy. Vaccines have been proven to make people immune to serious diseases (Childhood Immunization). By being vaccinated the person is not only helping themselves but others around them too.... [tags: Edward Jenner, childhood vaccines]
1002 words (2.9 pages)
- 732,000 children’s lives have been saved in the past 20 years due to routine vaccinations according to a new report from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Vaccines are a product that produces immunity to a specific disease by stimulating a person’s immune system; this in turn protects the person from the disease. Once vaccinations became a practical way to fight disease, the United State’s state law mandating vaccinations for school children was passed in 1855 in Massachusetts. Now in presently all 50 states require vaccinations before starting public school, however there is no federal law that requires vaccines to be mandatory.... [tags: Vaccination, Immune system, Smallpox]
1435 words (4.1 pages)
- There is a large amount of reasons that someone should not receive vaccinations. Vaccines are not helpful in keeping someone from getting the disease. There are always side effects when getting vaccinations. The cost of vaccinations do not out way the benefits. They are not always effective long term. Reasons given to receive vaccination are based on the theory of “herd immunity.” This hypothesis was taken out of an old college textbook. This is only a hypothesis. Vaccines are a $20 Billion per year marker.... [tags: Vaccine, Vaccination, Immune system, Smallpox]
786 words (2.2 pages)
- In opening there are people who believe that vaccines and health hazards should be mandatory towards every person starting at the age of one and continues until eight teen years of age. Those people are wrong, why would someone ever believes that it’s all right to inject babies with multiple harmful vaccines such as measles, mumps, rubella and many more. These types of vaccines can lead to serious health problems in the future or even as soon as later on that day of the child receiving these vaccines.... [tags: Vaccine, Vaccination, Smallpox, Edward Jenner]
2008 words (5.7 pages)
- Health care is complex and ever changing. What makes perfect sense for one individual may bring deep-seated ethical issues for another individual. With the vast amount of possibilities expanding through research, ethical dilemmas develop and complicate the decisions we need to make for ourselves and loved ones. The varied choices regarding cancer vaccines, fraud and euthanasia will be explored. Cancer Vaccines The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer demonstrates a parade of polarizing ethical issues of today, but the topic of mandatory cervical cancer vaccines particularly caught my attention.... [tags: herd immunity, fraud, euthanisia]
889 words (2.5 pages)
- It used to be that vaccinations were considered a normal part of childhood, right along with loosing teeth and toilet training. However, in recent years vaccinations have become an extremely hot button issue, with many parents actually choosing not to vaccinate their children. The idea seems preposterous considering how many people were left with twisted backs, and withered limbs due to polio, or the amount of deaths as a result of measles. To see someone who has been left in an iron lung from a disease that is now preventable, and still choose not to prevent the disease seems absolutely asinine, and yet many parents are doing just that.... [tags: Vaccines Should Be Required]
1034 words (3 pages)
- Evaluative Summary Jessica Boyd English 104 Andre Berchiolly Northern Illinois University 31 January 2015 Vaccinations are currently a very controversial topic and seeing as though all 50 states require students to have certain vaccinations before entering school; it must be a logical reason as to why that is. However, parents or guardians are still allowed to get this requirement waived, and that is what makes the topic so controversial. Some people feel as though this requirement should not be waived, because it is not safe, but others do not have a problem with it at all.... [tags: Vaccination, Vaccine]
1939 words (5.5 pages)
- Although autonomy is such a highly sought after aspect of human life, there are times when it is overridden for the good of the person or for others around them. The question of whether autonomy is always the most important factor in determining the morality of an issue must be made. According to Fields, autonomy requires and allows a person to “comprehend the action to be taken, the alternatives, and the consequences,” which is what it does. Nonetheless, there are times when this extent of autonomy may be skewed by beliefs and ideas that may not be entirely accurate.... [tags: vaccines, vaccination, mmr vaccine]
1384 words (4 pages)
- Vaccines save Lives. Nothing is more heartbreaking than a young life that has been taken by the infection of a killer disease. It’s painful to know that a child will never get to live to see their full potential. Diseases kill children every year, and most of the more deadly diseases can be prevented. Children are much more vulnerable to disease because of their weak immune systems. They are weak because they have not lived long enough to build immunities for such infections. So how would children protect themselves from these deadly diseases.... [tags: Vaccination, Vaccine, Immune system, Smallpox]
1379 words (3.9 pages)
- For recurrent generations, there encompasses numerous controversies surrounding vaccinations for children in addition to the unfavorable reactions that may arise. The chief concerns are whether vaccinating causes serious developmental delays such as autism in children. The aim of this composition is to enlighten others that vaccinating children does not bring about autism. By means of scientific exploration along with advanced medical diagnosis in children, researchers currently recognize that the increase in autism claims are not vaccine linked.... [tags: vaccines, diseases, vacinations]
620 words (1.8 pages)