Essay about Should Minors Be Prosecuted As Adults?

Essay about Should Minors Be Prosecuted As Adults?

Length: 1026 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

There are many questions arising about whether a minor should be prosecuted as an adult. Throughout the years many people have become dissatisfied with the system and the leniency towards minors committing heinous crimes. In present time, people have insisted that if the child commits a crime, he/she should therefore be treated as a criminal. Well, is there an age limit to restrict sentencing? At what age are a child’s thought process developed to know right from wrong? What percentage of people agree with this process? It all comes down to one major question; should minors be prosecuted as adults? It is believed to be that way in most criminal cases.
In 1899, one state passed the Juvenile Court Act, which established the nation’s first juvenile court. It was found on these three principles: juveniles are not comprehendible to hold account for their actions, they are not fully developed (mentally or physically), and can rehabilitate other than most adults. Now, in all but three states in the United States, anyone charged with committing a criminal act before his or her 18th birthday on average, is sought as a juvenile offender. More than ever, states and other countries globally have begun to question the reliability of juvenile court. The juvenile court system should be done away with, the system of punishment is too lenient on juvenile offenders, and it is also inefficient in responding to juvenile crime and violence.
In Tennessee an 11-year-old boy is facing first-degree murder charges in the death of an 8-year-old he shot and killed after he asked her to show him her puppy and she said no. The boy used his father 's 12-gauge shotgun, taking it from the unlocked closet, according to a story in the Washington Post. The local pr...

... middle of paper ... do adult actions, therefore should be treated as adult.
In today’s society we constantly hear the young adults/minors speak out about how they feel like they should be treated like they are adults because they are tired of hearing people tell them they are kids. Well if that’s the case, shouldn’t we put the big hammer down and start treating them like adults? When the minors fulfil adult actions, we should make their wish our command and treat them like the “adult” they are. If there were more laws about this particular viewpoint, maybe minors would realize that is what they are and start acting like the goofy teenagers they are meant to be. Teens in this generation are attempting to grow up faster than what is intended for them, and in most cases it is not good for the minor. If a minor commits an adult crime thus said minor should face the adult consequences.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Use of the Toulmin Model Essay

- The article “When Children Become Criminals” from The New York Times is an opinion piece by the Editorial Board. It discusses how New York is one of the only states to prosecute 16 year olds as adults; resulting in harsher sentences than if they were tried in juvenile court (2014, p. 1). The Toulmin model can be applied in order to analyze the argument. This model consists of a claim, grounds, backing, a warrant, a qualifier, and a rebuttal. In the New York Times editorial board article “When Children Become Criminals” from January 19, 2014 authors claim to try to persuade the readers that the age for adult criminal prosecution should be raised....   [tags: prosecute children as adults]

Strong Essays
1041 words (3 pages)

Essay about Minors Being Tried As Adults

- ... He was sentenced to 111 years in prison without the possibility of parole.1 A school shooting case that made headlines everywhere was the Columbine High School shooting. Eric Harris, who was eighteen, and Dylan Klebold, who was seventeen, walked into Columbine High School in Colorado. In a rampage of gunfire and homemade bombs, twelve students were killed and a teacher before killing themselves.1 This would have never made it to court because Eric and Dylan would have found a way to commit suicide before the case made it to trial....   [tags: accoutable, adults, consequences, crimes]

Strong Essays
2489 words (7.1 pages)

Criminal Offences Should Be Performed By Anyone Essay

- Criminal offenses can be performed by anybody, both the seniors and the juniors in the society. The law, however, handles these criminal offenses differently according to age. Many people feel that juvenile justice is a bit hard on the children and could result in gangs, but it is my opinion that it benefits the children by correcting them and showing them a brighter future, while at the same time making the society safe. Minors more so than not aren 't prosecuted when they commit crimes, unlike the adults....   [tags: Crime, Criminology, Juvenile delinquency]

Strong Essays
1241 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Should Minors Receive Parental Consent before Having an Abortion?

- Abortion is a very sensitive, yet popular, topic that is plaguing the United States. According to Merriam-Webster, abortion is, “A medical procedure used to end a pregnancy and cause the death of a fetus.” (n.d.). According to Griffin-Carlson &Mackin (1993), “In 1988, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) reported that there were 1,371,285 abortions in the United States, 25% of which were obtained by women under 19. Researches at the National Center for Health Statistics estimated that of the 1.1 million pregnancies among teenagers in 1981, 40% ended in abortion, 13% in miscarriage, and 47% in live births (p....   [tags: unwanted pregnancies in minors]

Strong Essays
1509 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on Should We Support Virtual Pornography?

- In today’s fast developing and modern society the thought of seeing two grown adults having sex is still considered taboo. Most Americans cringe at the thought of seeing pornography and dismiss the act as nothing more than a senseless lewd act. Yet, the Supreme Court held that pornography was to be considered a form of personal expression and should be protected under the first amendment (New York v. Ferber, 1973). The Supreme Court did not choose to extend the same constitutional protection to child pornography, arguing against its explicit and hurtful content....   [tags: child, protect, computer, value]

Strong Essays
1504 words (4.3 pages)

Should Minors Who Commit Violent Crimes Be Tried As Adults? Essay

- For my research paper, the topic that I have selected is “should minors who commit violent crimes be tried as adults?” I choose this topic for two reasons. The Frist reason is because the United States is currently trying to lower the age to be tried as an adult to fourteen years of age. At fourteen kids are going through a lot of different emotions and hormones which affects their mental status and hinders their capability to make the right or wrong decision. The second is because every person on this earth makes mistakes in their life, but at a younger age many of the mistakes are due to how the juvenile is raised, their environment and being in the wrong place at the wrong time....   [tags: Crime, Decision making, Decision theory]

Strong Essays
737 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Should Minors Contract Be Legal?

- Capacity Capacity states persons under the age of 18 whom are classed as minors do not have the lawful capacity to sign a contract. It is illegal to accept a person under that age into a contract. Types of services, goods including Clothes, alcohol, entry into nightclubs and venues are strictly monitored and are forbidden to minors. Minors Contract Act 1987 covers minors and adults. States the seller of services and products providing to the buyers can sue the sellers if there are not of legal age....   [tags: Contract, Marketing, Contract law]

Strong Essays
706 words (2 pages)

Deciding Whether a Case Should be Prosecuted or Not Essay

- When a prosecutor is deciding whether a case should be prosecuted in the courts and charges should be filed against someone, prosecutors consider two important questions: Is it in the best interest of the public to proceed. And, is there a strong reasonable likelihood that there will be a conviction. If the answer to both are yes, then there is the task of deciding whether there is enough evidence to prosecute the case and whether the evidence is reliable and can it be used in court. This means carefully assessing the quality of the evidence from all related witnesses before reaching a final decision....   [tags: crime and legal process]

Strong Essays
1003 words (2.9 pages)

Should The Minors Be Charged With The Death Penalty? Essay

- We as a country do not want to be looked at as someone who just loves to kill anybody for any little thing. We do what 's justice and giving minors the option with death penalty is just wrong. Minors should not be charged with the death penalty because it would not be justified to be kill that young. It would be a cruel and unusual punishment and that goes against what the constitution stands for. You would have to change the law in some states in order for this to happen and that would be a long process to deal with....   [tags: Capital punishment]

Strong Essays
1044 words (3 pages)

The Ethics of Selling Cigarrettes to Minors Essay

- Ethically as we Americans have defined is not on the minds of these executives of the cigarette firms. Our society has made it ethically and legally wrong to sell cigarettes to a minor. These companies located in the United States adhere to the laws and ethical issues within our borders, so what is the difference when they practice these unethical business transactions in smaller countries. These smaller, less developed countries do not have the technology and understanding to disallow the sale of cigarettes to minors....   [tags: Selling Cigarrettes to Minors]

Free Essays
612 words (1.7 pages)