Essay on Should Insanity Be Considered a Legal Defense for Criminals?

Essay on Should Insanity Be Considered a Legal Defense for Criminals?

Length: 1379 words (3.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Richard Bonnie, a Professor of law and psychiatry, leans on yes -- insanity should indeed exist as a legal defense for criminals. However, his stance on the matter focuses more on a modified variation of the existing defense used in the courts, as the defense maneuver is crucial in maintaining moral integrity of criminal law (Bonnie, 1982, p. 308). He begins with a suggestion to consider the case of John Hinckley. While hearing his argument for the insanity defense, it is mentioned how the media takes on many cases, such as Hinckley's own case, and coupled with a lack of disagreement among experts in the psychiatric field, the media has had a negative influence on the overall depiction of the defense's credibility. The idea of punishing criminals is focused upon the foundation that all humans are in full command of their faculties and should therefore be appropriately dealt with because of their own choice to engage in criminal behavior. The Hinckley case managed to open eyes to the most basic moral reasons behind the insanity defense in criminal law (Bonnie, 1982, p. 308). Bonnie asserts that while he is in strong opposition to the abolishment of the insanity defense, he does account for the fact that there can be certain cases in which this defense could be taken advantage of. It becomes necessary for the sake of preventing serious moral incidents from occurring, that the burden of presenting evidence attesting to the defendant's legal insanity at the time of criminal behavior should be left to the defendant themselves (Bonnie, 1982, p. 309). Following the morality issues regarding the application of the defense, there is also the matter of its necessity. If the defense was no longer in effect, the law would have no way of ackno...


... middle of paper ...


...d to a psychiatric facility, the individual must prove themselves to no longer be a threat to themselves nor to society, and once this is proven beyond a shadow of a doubt, only then can it be considered that the individual is "sane" and ready to return to society.



Works Cited

(*1) - http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-insanity-verdict-on-trial/
The Insanity Verdict on Trial
The insanity defense, rarely used, is widely misunderstood
Dec 23, 2010 |By Scott O. Lilienfeld and Hal Arkowitz

(*2) - http://www.szasz.com/insanity.pdf
"Should The Insanity Defense Be Abolished?"
DebatesDebates #110
Taped: August 26, 1996
(*3) - http://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4551&context=jclc
Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology
Volume 47 | Issue 6 Article 4
1957
Should the Criminally Insane be Housed in Prisons
F. Legrande Magleby

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Insanity Defense Essay

- When someone commits a crime, he or she may use mental illness as a defense. This is called an insanity plea or insanity defense. What the insanity defense does is try to give the alleged perpetrator a fair trial. At least in extreme cases, society agrees with this principle. The problem is where do we draw the line. Under what circumstances is a person considered insane, and when are they not. The trouble with the insanity defense in recent years is the assumption that virtually all criminals have some sort of mental problem....   [tags: A Crime Of Insanity]

Free Essays
2529 words (7.2 pages)

Insanity Is Not Guilty By Reason Of Insanity Essay

- In the United States, trials in which a defendant pleads not guilty by reason of insanity represent 1% of all the criminal cases, and the defense is lawfully verified in only 25% of these cases (Giannetakis, 2011). The not guilty by reason of insanity plea, or NGRI, is a legal defense a defendant might use to argue that he or she was not guilty of a crime because of insanity (Butcher, Hooley, & Mineka, 2014). The effort to define insanity in a legal sense begins in 1843 and carries on until 1984....   [tags: Insanity defense, Mental disorder, Insanity]

Strong Essays
1374 words (3.9 pages)

Essay about Insanity Ple Mental Illness

- Many criminals find many ways to get out of jail or being sentenced to death, what goes through their minds. Pleading insanity means to not be guilty of a crime committed due to reason of mental illness. In many cases criminals get away with pleading insanity, but in the end does it always work out. Bruco Eastwood pleaded insanity and therefore his background, crime, and where he is now will be crucial to Brucos’ insanity plea. Who was Bruco Eastwood before his insanity plea. For starters, he had major issues from his adolescence days....   [tags: Mental disorder, Crime, Insanity defense]

Strong Essays
1230 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Legal System: The Insanity Defense

- For centuries, one of the most controversial topics in the legal system has been the insanity defense. Some believe that this defense should stay, but many have the opposite opinion. Many of the arguments stemming from the public state that this defense is useless and does not belong in the legal system. The majority of the time, this opinion is formed based on a narrow view of high profile cases seen on the news without a sufficient amount of knowledge on the topic to have an educated opinion. Digging deeper into this subject shows that this defense deserves to remain in the legal system....   [tags: injustice, health and mental stability]

Strong Essays
1304 words (3.7 pages)

The Definition of Insanity as it Relates to Criminal Offences Essay

- The insanity defense is a defense asserted by an accused in a criminal prosecution to avoid liability for the commission of a crime because, at the time of the crime, the person did not appreciate the nature or quality or wrongfulness of the acts. The insanity defense is used by criminal defendants. The most common variation is cognitive insanity. Under the test for cognitive insanity, a defendant must have been so impaired by a mental disease or defect at the time of the act that he or she did not know the nature or quality of the act, or, if the defendant did know the nature or quality of the act, he or she did not know that the act was wrong....   [tags: Criminal Justice ]

Free Essays
531 words (1.5 pages)

Insanity And The Insanity Defense Essays

- Insanity. When some people think of the word “insanity”, television shows comparable to Law and Order and NCIS may come into mind. Due to some of these shows, one may not fully comprehend what is insanity. In this paper I will discuss what insanity, a brief history of insanity and how it impacts today’s society, furthermore, I will also discuss my personal thoughts on the subject. What is the insanity defense exactly. The insanity defense can be defined as “A defense asserted by an accused in a criminal prosecution to avoid liability for the commission of a crime, whereas at the time of the crime, the person did not appreciate the nature, quality, or wrongdoing of the acts.” In order to und...   [tags: Insanity defense, Mental disorder, Crime]

Strong Essays
1008 words (2.9 pages)

Criminology: Sane for Insanity? Essay

- Sane for insanity. Often times, the Insanity Defense is viewed by the public as an excused for criminals who are trying to be free of a sentence in jail.That may be the case for a small portion of the time, but that rarely works. It does not matter what the defendants mental ability is at the moment of a trial. The jurors focus on the mental capability at the moment the defendant committed the crime. There are several tests that are looked at in trying to find what the cause was for all of the commotion by the defendant in the committed crime to discover the level of their mental illness, or if there is an illness at all....   [tags: insanity defense, excuse for criminals]

Strong Essays
1223 words (3.5 pages)

The Hinckley Trial and the Insanity Defense Essay

- ... TREPANATION 20th century 3. ROTATIONAL THERAPY 4. MESMERISM (1734-1815) 5. LOBOTOMY 6. Electroconvulsive therapy 7.restraint 8. Strong drugs 9. Shock water treatment 10. Bleeding 11. Blistering salves. Such treatments often left patients severely damaged and not being able to function in society. New psychiatric drugs were developed in the 1950s, there was a new-found belief that people in mental institutions could be rehabilitated. Our current day treatments are rehabilitation hospitals, counseling, and medications....   [tags: symptoms of insanity, crime, trial]

Strong Essays
915 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Insanity Defense: Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity (NGRI)

- “Not guilty by reason of insanity” (NGRI) has often perplexed even the most stringent of legal and psychiatric professionals for centuries. Moreover, it has transcended into the pop culture, as a “loophole”for the criminal society. However, the insanity defense is only used in less than 1% of criminal cases, and used successfully in only 10-25% of those cases (Torry and Billick, 2010). In order to successfully be acquitted by reason of insanity, the legal team, paired with psychiatric professionals, must prove that the defendant is not legally responsible for the crime, despite the evidence that they executed the crime....   [tags: insanity, crime, defendant]

Strong Essays
2413 words (6.9 pages)

The Insanity Plea Of Insanity Essays

- With murder charges of fifteen people, cannibalism, and necrophilia hanging over his head, Jeffery Dahmer plead not guilty by reason of insanity. Since Dahmer was a child he had shown withdraws and avoidance of society. He had a habit of collecting dead animals, and he would dissect, dissolve them in many different ways. When Dahmers plea of insanity was rejected by the court, he was then charged with fifteen counts of murder (Yoong). Many believe that when Jeffrey Dahmer 's plea was rejected that it was the end of anyone using, but that isn’t the case....   [tags: Insanity defense, Mental disorder, Crime, Insanity]

Strong Essays
3860 words (11 pages)