Should Human Reproductive Cloning Be Legal Essay

Should Human Reproductive Cloning Be Legal Essay

Length: 836 words (2.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The matter of human reproductive cloning is a complex topic, in which there are many issues that must be addressed before any actions take place. Any decision based on reproductive cloning will not be clear-cut, and instead will host a multitude of ideas. In this paper, I will determine, through philosophical thinking, if human reproductive cloning is morally appropriate.
First and foremost, it is important to discuss what human cloning is. It is the conception of in vitro embryos that produces “individuals that are exact genetic copies of the donor from whom the DNA was obtained” (Munson 366). In Laymen’s terms, cells are inserted from the donor host into an unfertilized egg from another host (meaning it is asexual) and the new egg is transferred into the surrogate mother where it will foster into an embryo, if effective.
There are some rewards and disadvantages to utilizing human reproductive cloning. One advantage would be giving a woman who was not able to find the right person to have a child with, the child she had wanted. In “Mothers by Choice” there are many professional women, who before, would have to settle with ”Mr. Okay” to have a child (Munson 335). Now, marriage is not necessary to allow working women a child and they would not have to settle or put their ambitions to the wayside.
One disadvantage would certainly be like the Calvert Case. A couple was determined to have a child, however, the mother had a hysterectomy removing her uterus and therefore was not able to carry a child to term. Instead, the couple turned to a surrogate who would carry the child. Unfortunately, the surrogate felt that she should be a mother to the child as well, and took the case to court (Munson 348). The courts decided that since the c...

... middle of paper ...

...uld not want or desire to be manipulated in spite of cloning experimentation. By disrupting a process that can cause harm to many, we ensure that we are acting how we wish to be treated.
Finally, our course of action should be to legally ban human reproductive cloning. This decision will not be detrimental to anyone, nor will it abuse or exploit anyone. This action will be indicative of moral standards that we should wish everyone would follow. Ultimately, ethics is far greater than law. Ethical reflections are more significant than legal ideas because it is likely that laws themselves can show to be corrupt and inconsistent with honorable ethics. Therefore, we as a society must analyze the law in an ethical point of view, such as the case of reproductive cloning.

Works Cited
Munson, R. 2014. Intervention and reflection. Boston, MA: Wadsworth/Cengage Learning.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Human Cloning Should be Permitted Essay

- Human Cloning Should be Permitted What would you say if I told you that scientists had just developed a new procedure that could lead not only to the cure for cancer, but would provide an unlimited source of organ donors and could lead to the first effective treatment of nerve damage. Now adding on to this scenario lets say that our government was taking action to ban this new procedure because of a few myths and some loud mouthed conservatives. This scenario is true and is taking place with human cloning at this very moment....   [tags: Human Cloning Essays]

Strong Essays
1382 words (3.9 pages)

The Science and the Laws Impacting Human Cloning Essay

- The Science and the Laws Impacting Human Cloning Human cloning, long the subject of science fiction, is today a practical reality. Recent breakthroughs, most renowned the cloning of a sheep from an adult cell in Scotland in 1997, have caused the world to acknowledge that human cloning is indeed possible. Governments around the world immediately attempted to address the issue of human cloning, with varying levels of success. At the same time the pace of cloning technology continued to accelerate....   [tags: Human Cloning Research Paper]

Strong Essays
5882 words (16.8 pages)

The Ethics Of Human Cloning Essay

- The ethics of human cloning have been the subject of intense discussion in the United States and throughout the world for many years. In the United States, the technology to clone already exists, but deciding if it will provide benefits is another story. This paper will outline the history and available techniques, benefits, risks, and ethical issues of cloning. Through analyzing all the information provided in this paper and resources used, a general decision will be made as to whether cloning is ethical and therefore to be used in our country....   [tags: Cloning, Human cloning, DNA, Bioethics]

Strong Essays
1383 words (4 pages)

Essay about Should Cloning be Legalized in Humans?

- In 1996, Scottish scientist Ian Wilmot and his research team was able to successfully clone a lamb named Dolly from an adult sheep. This invention shocked all of the world at the realization that cloning was no longer a fantasy or an element of a Science Fiction movie. Since then, human cloning has become one of the most debated topics in the world. Everyone started to discuss about its advantages or the ethical issues of human cloning. Most of the people were against it and called it an ‘evil’ experiment....   [tags: human cloning, organ transplants]

Strong Essays
1974 words (5.6 pages)

Two of Us: Cloning Essay

- Have you ever wondered what it would be like if you had twin or even if you had a clone. If you had an illness like diabetes, have you ever wondered what it would be like if you did not. Cloning is the creation of an organism that is an exact genetic copy of another. The first successful clone was in 1997 when scientist Edinburgh cloned Dolly the sheep. She was the first animal to be cloned with an adult somatic cell by using the process of nuclear transfer. She was born on July 5 1996, lived to the age of six and died after being diagnosed with lung disease called Jaagsiekte....   [tags: Cloning]

Strong Essays
1483 words (4.2 pages)

Human Cloning Should Remain Illegal Essay

- The discovery of cells in 1665 brought a huge development in science and also led to another striking discovery: copying cells; in other words, cloning. It did not take a long time for scientists to understand that same qualified organisms could be created by using and copying cells. After the first successful mammal cloning, Dolly the sheep in 1997, science world was proud, but not satisfied yet. Curiosity and enthusiasm manipulated scientists to reach the climax of the cloning history with an astonishing and risky discovery: the first successful stem cell cloning in 2013 which declares the possibility of human cloning....   [tags: cells, dna, religious conflict, scientists]

Strong Essays
1087 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on The Ethics of Human Cloning

- For many years, cloning has been a controversy. There has been many deliberations on weither cloning is ethically or morally right or wrong. The definition of cloning can differ from one situation to another, in general when speaking about a cloneit means a fragment of DNA which is a serie of manipulations from a particular piece that can be generated unlimitedly ( Cullis, "Entering The Clone Zone." ) In this essay, the readers will understand why cloning should be considered legal due to it's benefits among human beings and society....   [tags: dna, genetic engineering, génétiques]

Strong Essays
907 words (2.6 pages)

Ethics of Human Cloning Essays

- Ethics of Human Cloning   On February 23, 1997 Dolly the lamb was literally made. She is not the work of nature or nature's God but of man, and Englishman, Ian Wilmut, and his fellow scientists. Dolly came into being not only asexually but also as the genetically identical copy of mature ewe, of whom she is a clone. When the startling news was heard throughout the world, there seemed to be substantial debate over the issue since it would open the doors for the possibility of human cloning....   [tags: Cloning Argumentative Persuasive Argument]

Strong Essays
2061 words (5.9 pages)

Human Cloning - The Greatest Danger is Ignorance Essay example

- Human Cloning – The Greatest Danger is Ignorance The successful cloning of an adult sheep—in which the sheep's DNA was inserted into an unfertilized sheep egg to produce a lamb with identical DNA—generated an outpouring of ethical concerns. These concerns are not about Dolly, the now famous sheep, nor even about the considerable impact cloning may have on the animal breeding industry, but rather about the possibility of cloning humans. For the most part, however, the ethical concerns being raised are exaggerated and misplaced, because they are based on erroneous views about what genes are and what they can do....   [tags: Cloning Argumentative Persuasive Argument]

Free Essays
1322 words (3.8 pages)

Cloning Essay

- Should Human Cloning be Legal. Cloning captured the public’s attention when Scottish scientists startled the world in July of 1996 when they announced the birth of a sheep named Dolly which they had cloned from the nucleus of an adult mammary cell and a sheep egg. Ever since this spectacular event occurred people have been thinking about the possibility of cloning humans. What would a clone be like. His/her physical appearance would be the same as the person he/she was cloned from, but depending on the society it would be brought up in it’s personality would be totally different....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
1231 words (3.5 pages)