Should Doctors Treat Inmates Awaiting Execution Like Patients With A Terminal Illness?

Should Doctors Treat Inmates Awaiting Execution Like Patients With A Terminal Illness?

Length: 1285 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Should doctors treat inmates awaiting execution like patients with a terminal illness?  The federal and the medical world remains divided on whether medical personnel should assist in state executions. The 8th amendment prohibits cruel and unusual punishment, such as executing an inmate by a firing squad, hanging, or electrocution.  To carry out this law, the courts has required medical personnel assistances in state executions through the lethal injection procedure.   Unfortunately, the American Medical Association has strictly declared that it is a violation against medical ethics for doctors to participate in state executions, which encourages many medical personnel to ignore inmates under the death penalty as potential patients. The only solution that would attempt to satisfy both the federal and the medical world is to have a system that trains state executioners to medically carry out this procedure better. However, even with any improvement in this system, there are doubts that state executioners will have the medical expertise to carry out such a complex procedure.  In light of the fixed medical and federal protocols, medical personnel must carry out state executions in order to minimize the potential for inmates to suffer unreasonably.

Some may argue an execution system without the involvement of medical personnel is practical, if state executioners are medically trained.   If this is the case, state executioners must be able to carry out tasks like the “placement of intravenous lines, monitoring of consciousness, adjustment in medication timing and dosage” in order substitute the need for medical personnel (Gawande 151). Apparently, this system will be heavily criticized for being impractical for many reasons.   An ethi...


... middle of paper ...


...timisms to attempt to satisfy both medical and federal worlds. Realistically, this solution is impractical because state executioners cannot substitute the role of medical personnel without violating the 8th amendment. In absences of necessary change to undo suffering, medical personnel must participate in state executions to ensure inmates do not suffer unreasonably.  In this controversial case between the AMA and federal protocols, denying inmates as patients by leaving them to suffer unnecessary is seen as more inhumane. Carlos Musso, a doctor who participated in state execution, says, “When we have a patient who can no longer survive his illness, we as physicians must ensure he has comfort.” (Gawande) We must encourage more medical personnel like Carlos to participate in state executions, if inmates are just as human as any person with a terminal illness.
  

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Appropriate Behavior of Doctors to Patients Essay

- Throughout professional jobs dealing with medicine or humans in general like doctors, clinical psychologists or physical therapists, the main question is how much empathy or compassion, for example a doctor should have toward his/her patients. There are a lot of speculations toward this. Some people say that there is no time for empathy and should just get down to the facts at hand. For example, general doctors that do not specify in a certain area usually see a multitude of patients in a day, so they only have a set time they can interact with their patients....   [tags: Patients, Health Care, Doctors, Empathy]

Strong Essays
1141 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Always Treat Books Like Gold

- “Always treat books like gold.” “Never settle for the mediocre.” “Best effort doesn’t always mean giving 100%.” To this day, these little nuggets of wisdom are the first to resurface whenever I think of the different teachers and mentors who have poured into my life over the years. The educators who said these words are people who have influenced me in ways that I am still discovering and have helped me grow into who I am today. While these phrases may seem a bit cliché, they have managed to stick with me over the years and now represent much more than the ideas they inspire....   [tags: Learning, Education, Teacher, Learning curve]

Strong Essays
1341 words (3.8 pages)

The Use of Medical Image to Diagnose and Treat Illness Essay

- If this was a perfect world, the moment a person underwent a surgery there would be no risk of having after effects of a major surgery. The doctors would be able to diagnose, treat and cure patients without causing any harmful side effects but reality is the total opposite of this. There is something that is helping to improve the perfect world that we reside upon in the medical field with Medical Imaging this fact has been improving. The use of medical imaging has provided the opportunity to the doctors to see inside a patient without having to cut them open....   [tags: doctors, surgery, cure patients]

Strong Essays
749 words (2.1 pages)

Should Doctors Have Power Over Their Patients? Essay

- The Use of Force Do doctors have power over their patients. Doctors are generally well trusted because they studied hard for the position they are in, they have more knowledge about illness than ordinary people and doctors are protected by law in case things go wrong. However this raises the question; are doctors susceptible to using force on their patients to get what they want. Doctors, like every other person, are human beings and thus they can make mistakes just like everyone else. However, when a doctor makes a mistake, it is much more serious than a fast food employee messing up your order....   [tags: Patient, Physician, Doctor, Illness]

Strong Essays
1142 words (3.3 pages)

Essay about Tattoos and Piercings on Doctors

- When imagining a doctor many see a man or a woman in a blue or white outfit usually with healthy skin. Most, however, would not imagine a doctor adorned with tattoos or piercings but those kinds of doctors are out there. As long as a doctor can do their job right then piercings, or no piercings, and tattoos, or no tattoos, shouldn’t matter. Although some people have concerns about the quality of medical care about doctors with tattoos and piercings, they should not be discriminated against because of this personal choice....   [tags: Medical Quality, Professionalism]

Strong Essays
949 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Early Doctors, Surgeons, and Apothecaries

- ... Only 400 of them had some sort of medical training and 200 of them actually had medical degrees. During the revolutionary war, anyone who knew anyone with medical knowledge was forced to go into the war to help with the injured and the sick. The training of each person varied. All of the injured and sick were sent to one place. It was usually very dirty and unsanitary. In these places there was a camp surgeon. He cared for the camp’s diseased soldiers and tried to watch for unsanitary conditions....   [tags: medical field in the 18th century]

Strong Essays
872 words (2.5 pages)

Lethal Injection Is The Method Of Execution Essay

- Can you imagine what it would be like waking up one day in a 60-square-foot cement enclosure telling a guard what you would like for your very last meal. Having to walk down to a room where people get to watch you die. Where you’re bound to a gurney or a chair and then two needles are inserted into your arms. Heart monitors are placed all over your chest by one of the execution team members. The curtain is lifted, and there is a room full of people staring at you. Waiting for you to take your last breaths....   [tags: Capital punishment, Lethal injection]

Strong Essays
1417 words (4 pages)

Essay on White Doctors Are The Ideal Type Of Doctor

- White Doctors Are the Ideal Type of Doctor The article “When You’re a Doctor of Color, Many Won’t Think You’re a Doctor”, describes an event that happened to Dr. Tamika Cross, OB-GYN physician, who tried to help a person that was in need of medical assistance. The flight attendant asked for a doctor and Dr. Cross offered help since she was a doctor and the attendant replied with “oh no honey not you we need a real doctor” (Conti). Dr. Cross insisted that she is, in fact, a doctor but the flight attendant wanted to see her credentials; meanwhile, a white doctor comes up to the attendant and offers help which makes the flight attendant tell Cross that the other doctor will help....   [tags: Racism, Discrimination, Rhetoric, Question]

Strong Essays
1132 words (3.2 pages)

Edwar Hirch's Execution Essay example

- Edward Hirch's poem Execution touches on various thought provoking and heart touching subjects such as cancer. Hirsch does this by using a common American loved sport football to make connections with the reader. Within the poem Hirsch begins to by building a character for us which was the football Coach who was diagnosed with cancer. Hirsch used an extensive amount of literary strategies in his poem to portray the Coach as a man who had always been a strong fighter and strives for the "perfect execution" and winning in life....   [tags: literary analysis of the poem]

Strong Essays
1069 words (3.1 pages)

Methods Of Execution Essay

- Methods of Execution One man's taking of another's life is generally seen as an unforgivable act which is punishable with death. When this is done as punishment however, it is seen as an honorary deed by removing this criminal from the world and making it a much safer place to live. With executions in mind, it is incredible what ingenious methods can be thought of by the human brain and the fact that the idea is centered around the murdering of one man does not even change how prodigious these innovations are seen to be....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Free Essays
2071 words (5.9 pages)