The Severity of Castration as a Form of Punishment for Rapists

The Severity of Castration as a Form of Punishment for Rapists

Length: 561 words (1.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
The topic of our debate is the castration of rapists. The topic has sparked the interest of many people due to its severity. Castration is a very harsh punishment and can affect a person for the rest of their lives. The question then rise, does a human really deserve a severe punishment such a castration? Humans are prone to making many mistakes throughout life and these mistakes are what mold them to becoming better people at the end. This drives me to believe that castration of rapists is a bad idea and should not be used as a source of punishment.
My judgment on this issue can be backed up by viewing the recidivism rates of prisoners released from jail. According to a study done by the Bureau of Statistics in year of 2007, it showed the recidivism rates of rapists are the second lowest among all of the crimes that are committed by prisoners. The statistics show that robbers have a 70.2% recidivism rate, burglars have 74.0%, larcenists have 74.6%, motor vehicle thieves have 78.8%, and inmates that possessed or sold stolen property have 77.4%. The recidivism rate for rapist comes in at 2.5 percent. This low rate suggests that the jail time is proving to be enough punishment for most convicts that are guilty of rape. Another factor that plays into the jail time serving as a good punishment is the treatment of rapists in prison. Rapists are frowned upon in society and even more frowned upon in prison. The inmates show tremendous hatred and disrespect for the convicts that commit this horrific crime. These inmates are usually isolated in individual cells to prevent them from having to encounter any danger from the rest of the inmate population.
False accusations are another vital reason why rapist should not be castrated for punishment. There are numerous cases across the world where a person is falsely accused of rape due to personal issues that they may have with that particular person. Rape differs from most other crimes because of its relevance to sexual intercourse. Sex can either be consensual or forced. The only person that has any say in this situation is the victim but how does one know that this information is truthful? A case that serves a prime example of issue is the case of Elizabeth Paige Coast in Virginia. In this case, she accused Jonathon Montgomery of raping her in the year of 2000.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Severity of Castration as a Form of Punishment for Rapists." 18 Jan 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Capital Punishment and Torture Essay

- Capital punishment is not a morally acceptable practice because the process has come to represent a form of torture in our modern society and therefore, should not be seen as an acceptable form of punishment for any criminal act. The goal of a punishment is to properly reprimand the criminal so justice is served in regard to the victim. This can be achieved without violating our moral standards through the use of punishments which sufficiently punish the offender while still doing right by the victim....   [tags: Capital Punishment, Death Penalty]

Research Papers
2197 words (6.3 pages)

A Case in Favor of the Death Penalty Essay

- Death Penalty Historically, death penalty was used as the most severe punishment available if a person disobeyed the laws or committed murder. The death penalty also known as capital punishment is the judicially ordered execution of a prisoner for an extremely serious crime. The rate of violent crimes in the United States is one of the highest, despite the fact that the United States has one of the harsher penal systems in the world. The courts have generally seen their task as fitting the punishment to the crime perpetrated....   [tags: capital punishment]

Research Papers
1343 words (3.8 pages)

Capital Punishment Is A Form Of Punishment Essays

- Capital Punishment is a form of punishment, administered by the government, which sentences people to death for their crimes. Many of these crimes are murders and rape, and it doesn’t discriminate either. Blacks, whites, the mentally retarded, and even the military have faced capital punishment. There have been many legal issues with how to administer capital punishment, but now we have a system to constitutionally administer capital punishment. Even with these revisions, there will always be an ongoing debate on whether to keep or abolish capital punishment....   [tags: Capital punishment, Prison, Crime]

Research Papers
1345 words (3.8 pages)

The Death Penalty As A Form Of Punishment Essay

- Whether because of financial reasons, moral reasons, or societal pressure, over two thirds of the countries in the world have abolished the death penalty in law or practice; so I ask, should the United States insist on having the death penalty as a form of punishment. Capital punishment is one of the most controversial topics among Americans today. Since every person has their own opinion on this topic, either for or against.In this argument, I 'm going to present the two sides of the issue, in order to objectively, come to a conclusion....   [tags: Capital punishment, Crime, Prison, Murder]

Research Papers
909 words (2.6 pages)

Death Penalty Debate Essay

- Why is the death penalty still allowed throughout much of the U.S.. The process of prosecuting and convicting an individual is astronomical, and there is great debate as to whether the death penalty actually works as a deterrent. Retribution and biasness have contributed too many that have received this sentence, considering all this, life imprisonment is best for all, realistically, and most effective. The advantages of life imprisonment far more outweigh the death sentence.   Death Penalty America has always had a history of using the death penalty, but no subject has received greater debate....   [tags: capital punishment, death penalty]

Research Papers
1792 words (5.1 pages)

Capital Punishment - An Appropriate Form of Punishment Essay

- Since the early settlers first stepped foot on what is now the United States of America, capital punishment has been reserved as a form of punishment for the people who have committed some of society’s most heinous crimes. Recently, support of capital punishment has begun to erode due to the advancements of DNA technology and groups, such as the Innocence Project. Capital punishment, however, remains to be an appropriate form of punishment for someone convicted of capital crimes, and may be effective in deterring such offenses....   [tags: Capital Punishment, Death Penalty]

Research Papers
902 words (2.6 pages)

Capital Punishment Is An Acceptable Form Of Punishment Essay

- Why is capital punishment such a controversy. Since the beginning of time, capital punishment has been viewed as both just and unjust. Supporters think that capital punishment is an acceptable form of punishment for perpetrators. Critics view capital punishment as being morally wrong; they think that no one deserves the punishment regardless of what crime they committed. There are many controversial issues that come along with capital punishment. When it comes to capital punishment, it is literally a life and death issue....   [tags: Capital punishment, Murder, Prison, Crime]

Research Papers
1301 words (3.7 pages)

Capital Punishment Is The Best Form Of Punishment Essay

- There are over sixty offenses in the United States of America that can be punishable by receiving the death penalty (What is..., 1). However, many individuals believe that the death penalty is an inadequate source of punishment for any crime no matter how severe it is. The fact remains, however, that the death penalty is one of the most ideal forms of punishment. There are other individuals who agree with the idea that capital punishment is the best form of punishment. In fact, some of these individuals believe that this should be the only form of punishment....   [tags: Capital punishment, Murder, Crime, Prison]

Research Papers
1008 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about The Death Penalty As A Form Of Punishment

- Almost all the countries in the world once had the death penalty or still have it. The death penalty is use in cases as a form of punishment. In the United State, it is use as a punishment for offenders who have committed a capital offense. Many people argue that the death penalty help prevent the crime rate from prevailing in our society. However we do have some people who think it is a harsh work. Along with the history, the different ways of putting a person to death, makes the death sentencing one of the most effective ways to put fear in someone’s eye before they think about committing the same criminal act....   [tags: Capital punishment, Lethal injection]

Research Papers
1805 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on Rapists in Arkansas Should Receive Harsher Punishments

- Rapists in Arkansas Should Receive Harsher Punishment Many families of rapists or sexual offenders believe they are punished to harshly because they are never given the chance to attend services like counseling to better themselves before being punished as a major criminal. Many families of rape victims and other citizens believe a rapist goes nearly free compared to what the victim goes through, and believe it is unfair. Although it is true that offenders don’t get the chance to better themselves before being convicted as a hard felon, they should be convicted even harsher and differently than they already are in Arkansas because: they cause their victims to go through a lifetime full of p...   [tags: sexual offender, rate, crime, law, victims, felony]

Research Papers
1141 words (3.3 pages)

At this time, she was 10 years old while he was 14 years old. After taking the issue to court, Montgomery was immediately thrown into jail. He spent four years in jail before Ms. Coast admitted to making the whole story up and lying at his trail in 2008. If Montgomery was given the punishment of castration in this case, his life would have been permanently ruined. Even if he was given the freedom from jail, his future endeavors of reproducing would be demolished.
If castration was implemented in the punishment system, would this really stop rapist from committing the crime again? The results of castration are the loss of the ability to reproduce and reduced levels of testosterone levels. According to German study that was taken in the 1960s of castrated sex offenders, 65% of the offenders reported a drop in their sex drive and 18% reported that they were able to function normally after 20 years following the procedure. In addition, there are many sexual enhancements on the market that can restore testosterone levels. With this being said, it shows that there is a possibility that sex drive can be restored and the possibility of rape can still be repeated.
To conclude, I firmly believe that castration is too severe a punishment for person convicted of rape. When you take into consideration the possibility of false accusation, the penalty would be horrible if enforced on an innocent person. Prison time and the awareness of the community about the rapist is the farthest that I think the punishment should go. This is how I view the topic of my group’s debate.

Return to