The Second Constitutional Convention Essay

The Second Constitutional Convention Essay

Length: 1520 words (4.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Second Constitutional Convention has introduced three new ideas to the United States government to help create a more balanced effective and limited political institution. The three proposals include switching the electoral system in the House of Representatives to proportional representation. Another proposal introduced to the conveners was to change the current presidential system to a parliamentary system. The last proposal was to change the rules for the selection of senators. The proposals are vague, leaving a lot of room for the smaller details. However, after further review and thought process for each of the proposals, only one seem to be relevant to the government’s growth. 
 James Madison co-authored the U.S. Constitution keeping in mind a strong central government that will help unify the country. Madison often feared that government can change into a tyranny; he believed that men were not capable of governing themselves, because they are not “angels” (Samuels Ch. 3). This is often called Madison’s Dilemma. In the Federalist Papers, which Madison co-authored, he mentioned “If men were angels, no government would be necessary…”. Madison believed that political power should be limited to maintain a stable and effective government.
Only the first proposal, changing the electoral system for the House of Representatives to proportional representation, help advocate for Madison’s view on political institutions.The legislative branch of the U.S. government currently elects and reelects the members of both the House of Representatives and Senate using the first-past-the-post (FPTP) electoral system. Through FPTP, candidates win their seats by winning the most votes during the election; candidates just need more votes than ...

... middle of paper ... a limited and effective government. Although there might be positive outcomes from changing the executive structure and the rules for the selection of senators, both proposals do not clearly advocate for Madison’s ideal political institution. There is not enough factual evidence or possible scenarios that switching into a parliamentary system or making a governor the senator as well, contributes to a limited and effective government. However, changing the electoral system in the House of Representatives into proportional representation does contribute to fixing Madison’s Dilemma, because each state must work with one another while also giving each political party room to represent their ideas and people. The Second Constitutional Convention should only accept the proposals that help further the U.S. government’s growth into a more limited and effective government.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Constitutional Convention Drafted the Constitution in 1787 Essays

- After the failure of the Articles of Confederation exemplified by Shay’s rebellion in 1787, the young United States needed a new government with improved policies. The Constitutional Convention drafted the Constitution in 1787 and, after much debate between Federalists and Anti-Federalists, ratified it in 1789 which provided a government of checks and balances between the judiciary, legislative, and executive branches, distributed more power to the federal government, established that the president would not serve for life, and determined that the president would be voted democratically....   [tags: Founding Fathers]

Strong Essays
1945 words (5.6 pages)

Essay about The Constitutional Convention Of The Constitution

- On May 25, 1787 the constitutional convention began at the Independence Hall in Philadelphia in order to amend the Articles of Confederation. It was apparent to the framers of the Constitution that the Articles of Confederation lacked central authority over foreign and domestic commerce, threw many conflicts over time after the Revolutionary War. This wouldn’t be a harmonious amendment either. Between the Federalists and the Anti – Federalist they spent the entire summer creating a new government unlike any before....   [tags: United States Constitution]

Strong Essays
1901 words (5.4 pages)

The Constitutional Convention Of The United States Essay

- Constitutional Convention The Constitutional Convention was established in Philadelphia on May 24, 1787 (A New Nation Notes). The purpose of the Constitutional Convention was for the colonies to revise the Articles of Confederation (A New Nation Notes). The Convention was also used to establish unity within the colonies and to establish a new central government between the colonies (Teaching American History). Seventy four delegates were invited to attend, but only fifty five delegates were at the Convention, with only Rhode Island refusing to attend....   [tags: United States Constitution]

Strong Essays
1781 words (5.1 pages)

Essay about The Constitutional Convention Of Philadelphia

- The Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia met between May and September of 1787 to address the problems of the weak central government that existed under the Articles of Confederation. The Antifederalists were extremely concerned that the national government would trample their rights. Rhode Island and North Carolina refused to ratify until the framers added the Bill of Rights. These first ten amendments outlined things that the government could not do to its people. They are as such: o First Amendment: Freedom of Religion, of Speech, of the Press, of Peaceful Assembly, and the Right to Petition o Second Amendment: Right to Keep and Bear Arms o Third Amendment: Quartering of Soldiers...   [tags: United States Constitution]

Strong Essays
715 words (2 pages)

Essay about The Constitution And The Constitutional Convention

- One of the principal compromises in the constitution is on the topic of representation and its power. During the drafting of the constitution and the constitutional convention, the topic of representation as well as separation of power were soundly argued. To maintain a balance of powers, the drafters of the constitution agreed on a middle ground between the Connecticut and Virginal compromise. The separation of powers as entailed in the United States Constitution separates power of government into three branches hence guarantying that no single part of government is above another, this guarantee is entailed in a “checks and balances system”....   [tags: Separation of powers]

Strong Essays
1219 words (3.5 pages)

Essay The Constitutional Convention Of The United States

- “The Congress shall have Power To make all laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all other Powers vested by this Constitution in the Government of the United States, or in any Department or Officer thereof.” (Necessary and Proper Clause. 2008.) At the Constitutional Convention, the Committee of Detail took the Convention 's resolutions on national legislative authority and particularized them into a series of enumerated powers. This originated the principle of enumerated powers, under which federal law can govern only as to matters within the terms of some power-granting clause of the Constitution....   [tags: United States Congress]

Strong Essays
723 words (2.1 pages)

The Constitutional Convention of 1787 Essay

- The Constitutional Convention of 1787 was held to address problems in governing the United States which had been operating under the Articles of Confederation since it’s independence from Britain. Fifty-five delegates from the states attended the convention to address these issues. The delegates consisted of federalists who wanted a strong central government to maintain order and were mainly wealthier merchants and plantation owners and anti-federalists who were farmers, tradesmen and local politicians who feared losing their power and believed more power should be given to the states....   [tags: US History]

Strong Essays
819 words (2.3 pages)

The 's Speech At The 1829 Virginia Constitutional Convention

- In his speech at the 1829 Virginia Constitutional Convention, James Madison said “The great danger [in a republic] is that the majority may not sufficiently respect the rights of the minority.” When he said this, he meant that the idea of majority rule can result in the infringement on the rights of the minority in order to protect or further the rights, freedoms, or ideals of the majority. Journalists and the media are a major factor in shaping people 's political opinions, moral beliefs, and knowledge of current events....   [tags: Vietnam War, Lyndon B. Johnson, United States]

Strong Essays
1167 words (3.3 pages)

Democratic and Undemocratic Aspects of the Constitutional Convention Essays

- Democratic and Undemocratic Aspects of the Constitutional Convention The Articles of Confederation was the first government of the United States. The Articles had created a very weak national government. At the time the Articles were approved, they had served the will of the people. Americans had just fought a war to get freedom from a great national authority--King George III (Patterson 34). But after this government was put to use, it was evident that it was not going to keep peace between the states....   [tags: American America History]

Free Essays
1373 words (3.9 pages)

The Call for a World Constitutional Convention: An Application of John Locke's Theory of Revolution

- The Call for a World Constitutional Convention: An Application of John Locke's Theory of Revolution ABSTRACT: A movement led by an organization called "One World" is advocating the idea of "Direct Democracy," whereby individuals everywhere would have the opportunity to elect delegates to a world constitutional convention. In theory, any document drafted by this convention would be returned to individuals throughout the world for their approval. The assumption of the Direct Democracy movement is that individuals throughout the world have the right to bypass existing governments in order to establish the rule of law on a global level....   [tags: Philosophy Philosophical Essays]

Free Essays
2780 words (7.9 pages)