Scruton 's Equivalency Thesis : Photography And Representation Essay

Scruton 's Equivalency Thesis : Photography And Representation Essay

Length: 1309 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Scruton’s Equivalency Thesis
In Photography and Representation, Scruton advances the view that photography cannot be described as a representational art form in the same sense as painting, and that the photograph is unworthy of aesthetic appreciation in and of itself. Indeed, Scruton suggests that it is not even possible to have an aesthetic interest in the photograph, as such interest is necessarily directed towards its subject. In this sense, photography is merely a facilitator of seeing. It is no more a representational art form than viewing a scene through a pair of spectacles, or observing an object through a magnifying glass. It is a simply a tool for seeing-through, and what one perceives in a photograph is quite literally the object photographed; it is, Scruton suggests, a surrogate for engaging with the object directly (Scruton, 1980, 221). The photograph is thus transparent to its subject - it cannot alter or represent reality in any way, but merely captures a glimpse of it. It is imprisoned by its truthfulness to its subject, as its content is entirely determined by whatever is before the camera lens when one takes the photograph. Hence, the photograph is simply an automated reproduction of reality over which the photographer possesses scant control (Scruton, 1980, 227).


In contrast, upon observing the details of a painting, it is possible for one to question the intentions of the artist in virtue of what and how she chooses to represent. As Scruton articulates, when perceiving a painting, “the question, ‘Why?’ can be asked of every observable feature, even if it may sometimes prove impossible to answer” (Scruton, 1980, 226). For instance, one may perceive a photograph and take profound aesthetic interest in the way ...


... middle of paper ...


...acity to arouse an interest in the subject photographed in a manner that transcends face-to-face viewing, the fact that the photograph boasts the ability to suspend its subject in time is also indicative of its transcendence of face-to-face viewing. If one takes an aesthetic interest in Vivian Maier’s photographs of children playing in a street in the 1950’s, for instance, this would evidently not be equivalent to viewing the same subjects directly in the present moment. As such, the photograph’s ‘distance’ from its subject, both physical and temporal, is perhaps further reason to distinguish it from face-to-face seeing, and may be indicative of its worth as a visual art form. Thus, contra Scruton, paintings and photographs are equally worthy of aesthetic appreciation as visual art forms, and photographic transparency is not synonymous with photographic equivalency.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Representation in Music by Roger Scruton and Sound and Semblance by Peter Kivy

- "Representation in Music" by Roger Scruton and "Sound and Semblance" by Peter Kivy Can music represent. Does it matter if it can. Roger Scruton and Peter Kivy tackle these two questions in two articles concerning music’s representational powers: Representation in Music (Scruton) and Sound and Semblance (Kivy). Scruton takes a two-pronged approach to the question of musical representation arguing that 1) music cannot represent things and 2) even if it could, such representation is irrelevant to the appreciation of the music....   [tags: Music Semblance Scruton Kivy Essays]

Better Essays
3630 words (10.4 pages)

Roger Scruton on Photography Essay

- In Roger Scruton's Photography and Representation the author establishes the idea that ideal photography is not art. In the same breath he says that ideal photography is not necessarily an idea which photographers should strive, nor does it necessarily exist. Yet, he bases his argument upon the ideal. In reviewing his paper, I’ll take a look at why he painstakingly tries to make this distinction between ideal painting and ideal photography. His argument is based upon the proposition that photographs can only represent in a causal fashion, whereas painters create representational artwork via intentional relations....   [tags: Photography]

Better Essays
2314 words (6.6 pages)

Music And Morality : An Expository Article That Was Written By Roger Scruton

- Controlled by Music Music and Morality is an expository article that was written by Roger Scruton in 2010. Scruton is a moral philosophy professor at St. Andrews University and has written other works about the subject of music. The purpose of Music and Morality is to inform individuals who listen to music that there are morals behind music. He encourages readers to really listen to the music, and persuades readers that if we stop submitting to the music we will actually find the moral qualities....   [tags: Morality, Ethics, Moral, Dance music]

Better Essays
904 words (2.6 pages)

Writing a Thesis Statement Essay

- A Thesis is: -The statement of the author’s position on a topic or subject. -Clear, concise, and goes beyond fact or observation to become an idea that needs to be supported. -Often a statement of tension, where the author refutes or complicates an existing assumption or claim (counterargument). -Often answers WHY or HOW questions related to the topic at hand. A Thesis Statement is Not: - A statement of fact or observation (no matter how astute the observation). - A statement of personal conviction or opinion....   [tags: Writing a Thesis Statement 2014]

Free Essays
500 words (1.4 pages)

Representations of Nature in King Lear Essay

- We are lucky, today, that the majority of the world’s nations are democracies. This has only been the case in very recent times. For the greater part of human history, society has subscribed to the belief that birth is the most important determinant of one’s future. In Elizabethan England, this was especially true. Those born into the nobility enjoyed a lifetime of privilege, while those born outside of their ranks mainly existed to serve them. A century later, the British encountered an even stricter form of this belief when they conquered India....   [tags: Representations of Nature in King Lear]

Better Essays
856 words (2.4 pages)

Personal Narrative: My Graduate School Thesis Essay

- There I was, poised with the first draft of my masters thesis, ready to jack it under the rear wheels of my car so that I could vent my anger and frustration. Never had I felt this kind of undiluted rage in dealing with a piece of writing. As far as I was concerned, the first draft was complete and therefore the entire piece was finished; however, my thesis advisor didn’t quite agree with me. A less deranged friend of mine talked me out of repeatedly backing over my thesis, and convinced me that it didn’t really matter if I did leave tire marks on it because I had multiple drafts on my disk....   [tags: Narrative Essay Writing English Thesis]

Better Essays
1317 words (3.8 pages)

More Evidence Needed to Support George Ritzer's McDonaldization Thesis Essay example

- More Evidence Needed to Support George Ritzer's McDonaldization Thesis The McDonaldization Thesis presupposes some familiarity with Ritzer's earlier work, The McDonaldization of Society (1993), in which he defines McDonaldization as "the process by which the principles of the fast-food restaurant are coming to dominate more and more sectors of American society as well as the rest of the world" (1). These principles include efficiency, predictability, calculability (or an emphasis on quantification), and control (especially via non-human technologies)....   [tags: George Ritzer McDonaldization Thesis]

Free Essays
2150 words (6.1 pages)

Modern Day Social Representations of Men and Women Essay examples

- The aim of this project is to identify and explain modern day social representations of both men and women found within a contemporary magazine aimed at a male audience, GQ magazine. This will be achieved by gaining a sample from several back issues of the magazine forming a female sample and a male sample. Both of these will comprise only of articles featuring overtly a picture of either a male representation or a female representation or in some cases both, such pieces will fall into both samples or into which they are most appropriate too....   [tags: Social Representation of Gender]

Free Essays
3275 words (9.4 pages)

Writing a Thesis Paper

- Writing a Thesis Paper A specific style of writing is necessary in order to write a thesis paper. A good thesis paper will use sound evidence presented in a convincing way to prove a thesis statement. After the thesis is introduced in the opening paragraph, the writer presents facts which are used to prove their thesis. These facts are contained within the body paragraphs. Finally, a conclusion is presented which restates the thesis and summarizes the steps that were taken by the writer in order to prove it....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
439 words (1.3 pages)

Thesis Essay

- Thesis The purpose of this research paper is to investigate the effectiveness of character education programs and how technology can be used to enhance student learning about character education. According to Laura and Malcolm Gauld (2002)" For families, educators, corporations, and communities, the biggest job we'll ever have is nothing less than a new paradigm for reconnecting education with core values." (p.1) The world of education is at a place where they are placing extreme importance on teaching our students values....   [tags: essays papers]

Better Essays
1994 words (5.7 pages)