The Scottish Parliament Essays

The Scottish Parliament Essays

Length: 1104 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

For more than three hundred years, Scotland has been an active member of a union with Wales, England and Northern Ireland but recently this partnership has come under threat due to nationalist views from a group of deluded self-serving failed councillors better known as the SNP. The ideals of these individuals threaten the very fabric of this hub of culture and enterprise that we know and love as Scotland. With the tricentennial anniversary of union, the idea of Scottish independence has again come up for fierce debate. How, I ask myself, did Alex Salmond and his nationalist cronies manage to concoct such a specious solution to Scotland's problems? A question easily answered: on the basis of false, misinterpreted and corrupt data.

In 2007, the SNP scraped a narrow election victory in the Scottish Parliament of 1 seat, holding 47 to Labour's 46 out of 129. This forced the SNP to form a minority government, being a pathetic 18 seats short of a majority but the result still caused uproar in the media. The SNP's decision-making power may be seen as weak due to its minority status. However, being in government has given the nationalists centre stage in the media for promoting their principal policy of independence for Scotland from the rest of the UK. Whether or not this conjecture has any feasibility remains to be seen. Which begs the question, what plans could the SNP have for Scotland that would supposedly improve the welfare of every citizen in the nation, be they laird or lavvy cleaner?

To begin with, if they achieve their ultimate aim of Scottish independence, the SNP want to withdraw public spending from what they consider “unessential” expenses, e.g. the military, with particular emphasis on Trident, our nuclear deterr...

... middle of paper ...

...Union is three hundred years old for a reason: it simply works. Scotland benefits from the economies of scale, the checks and balances of one of the world's richest countries. The UK benefits from the flood of skilled professionals and entrepreneurs that Scotland has always provided. It is a sad fact that the small and isolated are suffering in the present financial climate - just observe Ireland and Iceland. Although devolution is a contemporary issue and its resurgence is inevitable in terms of the new Scottish government, concepts of total home rule are merely a novelty dreamt up amongst the hype and publicity of the anniversary of the Act of Union. It is something of a fashion that will pass with time, thus leaving us in yet another prosperous and peaceful period in Scotland's social and political history and more importantly the history of the United Kingdom.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Climate Change and The Scottish Parliament

- INTRODUCTION As climate change becomes an increasing matter of concern, inaction seems to be irresponsible and of great consequences. From the depletion of the non-renewable resources to the significant climatic changes to the earth’s atmosphere, the negative results of dismissing the effect of global warming far outweigh the costs of preventing it. The largest source of emissions, currently, is the energy industry but the usage of electricity and heat is a vital part of modern day life that cannot be substituted....   [tags: hydropower plants, non-renewable resources]

Strong Essays
1207 words (3.4 pages)

The Devolution Of Northern Irish And Welsh Assemblies And The Scottish Parliament

- With the formation of Northern Irish and Welsh assemblies and the Scottish parliament, there are several major devolved powers in the three countries, including agriculture, education, environment, and health. This leaves other powers, known as reserved powers, in the hands of the United Kingdom government, like defense and national security, foreign policy, international relations, economic policy, and energy (BBC, 2010). The devolution of power in the United Kingdom has led to tension, especially over public spending....   [tags: United Kingdom, European Union]

Strong Essays
1221 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Comparing the Scottish Parliament and Welsh Assembly

- Comparing the Scottish Parliament and Welsh Assembly On the 1st of July 1999 the Scottish Parliament assumed its full powers and duties. This was a devolved government, where some legislative powers were transferred from Westminster to the Parliament in Scotland. The Scottish parliament was designed to embody the links between the people of Scotland, the members of the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Executive. The powers of duty are divided between the Scottish Executive (handles ministerial powers and duties) and the Secretary of State for Scotland (holds responsibilities relating to reserved matters)....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1247 words (3.6 pages)

New Labour Policies And The New Policies Essay

- This essay will address whether New Labour contained policies with which it wished to pursue, or was solely developed in order to win elections. It is important to realise whether a political party that held office for approximately 13 years only possessed the goal of winning elections, or promoted policies which it wished to pursue. If a party that held no substance was governing for 13 years, it would be unfair to the people. New Labour was designed to win elections, but still contained policies which it wished to pursue....   [tags: United Kingdom, Scottish Parliament]

Strong Essays
917 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Scottish Devolution

- Devolution is the transfer of powers from a central body to subordinate regional bodies. In Scotland, Devolution was set up to restore legitimacy to a system of government that reflected Scottish preferences. The reason behind the demand for Scottish self-government is that Scotland had the historic status of nationhood before the Union of 1707 and within the Union, has a different set of legal, educational and religious institutions that reinforce a Scottish identity. The Scottish National Party (SNP) was founded In 1934 and In 1960 was found oil in the North Sea, what changed the Scottish public opinion about the Union as the main cause to join it was economical; having oil would suppose e...   [tags: Government, Change, Social]

Strong Essays
1471 words (4.2 pages)

UK Political Devolution and Scottish Independence Essay

- Within this essay I am going to discuss, and evaluate the Scottish devolved political system. Devolution is the transfer of powers and since 1999 the UK has changed due to the devolution. This was introduced to try and give more power to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland which along with England make up the UK. The votes for devolution took place in Scotland and Wales in 1997 and 1998 in Ireland . This is why the the Scottish Parliament along with the National Assembly of Wales and the Northern Ireland Assembly was created however devolution did not mean all nations changed in the same way, devolution meant different things for each nation due to administrative and historical differenc...   [tags: British Politics, Government]

Strong Essays
2162 words (6.2 pages)

Essay about Scotland´s Devolved Parliament

- Devolution is an organised system where particular powers within a government are shared and put into operation by different parliaments within and around the surrounding countries, allowing for the establishment of local laws and legislation. When devolution happens, there is no loss of sovereignty or authority for the senior parliament, which still has the power to create and over rule any law in the country. Like many countries, Scotland’s plan for power sharing has been shaped by various historical and economical events, many of which are still very important in current politics....   [tags: powers, government, laws, legislation]

Strong Essays
1755 words (5 pages)

The Main Functions of Parliament Essays

- The Main Functions of Parliament Parliament has many functions. A political scientist, Philip Norton outlined these functions in to five categories. The five main functions of parliament are legislature, representation, recruitment, scrutiny and legitimacy. Each one is as important as the other however the main two functions of parliament are scrutiny and influence. The predominant role of parliament is scrutiny. Scrutiny is when parliament needs two look over, in detail, potential bills and laws....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
678 words (1.9 pages)

Charles' Falling Out with Parliament Essay

- Charles' Falling Out with Parliament There are a number of reasons why Charles fell out with Parliament. Some reasons are long term and were at the start of his reign. Some are medium term and developed during the "11 years tyranny". Finally there are the short-term events of the Long Parliament, which directly led to the outbreak of the war. From the star of his reign Charles had disagreed with Parliament in much the same way as his father had done. He disagreed with Parliament because he thought they were getting to powerful....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
471 words (1.3 pages)

Parliament's Loss of Sovereignty Essay

- Parliament's Loss of Sovereignty Parliamentary Sovereignty is defined in two terms. These are legal and political. The legal term means that Parliament can do what they want to for example making laws, which can’t be overruled by anyone, and that Parliament has unrestricted powers. There are three elements to the Parliamentary, which are the Commons, the Lords and the Monarch. Another thing about the legal term is that no parliament can pass a law which would affect successors....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
491 words (1.4 pages)