Essay about Scotland´s Devolved Parliament

Essay about Scotland´s Devolved Parliament

Length: 1755 words (5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

Devolution is an organised system where particular powers within a government are shared and put into operation by different parliaments within and around the surrounding countries, allowing for the establishment of local laws and legislation. When devolution happens, there is no loss of sovereignty or authority for the senior parliament, which still has the power to create and over rule any law in the country. Like many countries, Scotland’s plan for power sharing has been shaped by various historical and economical events, many of which are still very important in current politics.

One of the first events that influenced Scotland to want a devolved parliament was when a Scotland bill was introduced into the House of Commons just before the 1979 referendum. The Scotland bill was established because Scotland had a particularly poor network of MP’s in place within the parliament, and during the passing of the legislation, Labour MP George Cunningham made a significant change, in that all proposals would be approved by not only the majority of Scottish voters, but also by 40 per cent of the Scottish electorate. This basically meant that those at home would be classed as no voters. However, although this bill enabled Scotland to have slightly more hope when voting was concerned, the Labour government was particularly unpopular due to the winter of discontent. The winter of discontent caused major economic and industrial concerns in Britain, and because of this, it was seen as a ridiculous idea to introduce any more policies involving the Labour party. The outcome of the election therefore resulted in a win for the Conservatives, the rise of the new Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher in 1979, and the establishment of a campaign called ...


... middle of paper ...


...ses representation for women and people from black and minority ethnic backgrounds. In Scotland, the number of women elected in 2011 was 45, resulting in the second lowest number of women MSPs in four Scottish Parliament elections at 35%, a slight improvement from the 2007 election (McCaffrey & Egerton, 2011).
However, on the downside, it is unfair and is not always proportional and distorts election results so no individual party can always form the government. For example, in 1997, Labour won 44.33 % of the vote, which was the equivalent of 419 seats in the House of Commons. This figure was then calculated as 63.58%, which is clearly not in proportion to the percentage of votes. The additional Member System also disenfranchises the numbers of voters who don’t support the winner within their constituency; therefore the votes are pretty much useless (Barkham, 2005).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Devolution Of Northern Irish And Welsh Assemblies And The Scottish Parliament

- With the formation of Northern Irish and Welsh assemblies and the Scottish parliament, there are several major devolved powers in the three countries, including agriculture, education, environment, and health. This leaves other powers, known as reserved powers, in the hands of the United Kingdom government, like defense and national security, foreign policy, international relations, economic policy, and energy (BBC, 2010). The devolution of power in the United Kingdom has led to tension, especially over public spending....   [tags: United Kingdom, European Union]

Term Papers
1221 words (3.5 pages)

Exploring To Which Extent the Parliament is Supreme Essay

- Exploring To Which Extent the Parliament is Supreme There are two sides to this argument, one obviously defending that Parliament is Supreme in the law making process, and has utmost authority, the other stating the constraints on Parliament and there it is not supreme. Within Britain, parliament is the supreme law making body. The idea behind this is that the people select parliament and, therefore, the people make the law. We describe this as PARLIAMENTARY SOVEREIGNITY, That is to say that Parliament is the highest power in the land, and shall not be challenged....   [tags: Papers]

Term Papers
1120 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Comparing the Scottish Parliament and Welsh Assembly

- Comparing the Scottish Parliament and Welsh Assembly On the 1st of July 1999 the Scottish Parliament assumed its full powers and duties. This was a devolved government, where some legislative powers were transferred from Westminster to the Parliament in Scotland. The Scottish parliament was designed to embody the links between the people of Scotland, the members of the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Executive. The powers of duty are divided between the Scottish Executive (handles ministerial powers and duties) and the Secretary of State for Scotland (holds responsibilities relating to reserved matters)....   [tags: Papers]

Term Papers
1247 words (3.6 pages)

The Parliament Essay

- The Parliament was an elected organization set up by the king to manage the country to save the King the effort. Although officially ruled by the King, Parliament was increasing it’s power so rapidly that by the 1600s it could no longer be relied on to do what the King wanted. King Charles 1st came into conflict with his Parliament in 1629 when he ordered Parliament to raise taxes and it refused. His response was to abolish Parliament and he ruled Parliament on his own for 11 years. However, the people didn’t support him and he ran short of money so he had to reinstate Parliament in 1640....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
738 words (2.1 pages)

The European Parliament Essay

- A. As it is known the European Union is a unique system that we never seen before, the European union based on many principle such as, free movement of goods, establishment, services, and workers and we can consider it a new legal order for three main reasons: - First of all the authority of the European Union law is independent form the states law, and individuals can appeal it. - Second, It’s a supranational origination setting above the states. The European Union has its own legal system, which becomes an permeable part of the legal system of the member states, and the court must apply the European Union law above the state law, when they conflict, European Union takes precedent over nati...   [tags: legislation, equal pay provisions]

Term Papers
659 words (1.9 pages)

The Scottish Parliament Essays

- For more than three hundred years, Scotland has been an active member of a union with Wales, England and Northern Ireland but recently this partnership has come under threat due to nationalist views from a group of deluded self-serving failed councillors better known as the SNP. The ideals of these individuals threaten the very fabric of this hub of culture and enterprise that we know and love as Scotland. With the tricentennial anniversary of union, the idea of Scottish independence has again come up for fierce debate....   [tags: Union, Governemnt, UK]

Term Papers
1104 words (3.2 pages)

Functions of the Parliament Essays

- Functions of the Parliament "Debates, Question Time, and Select Committees all give Parliament Teeth." I don't agree with this statement because in general I don't think that Parliament is able to complete one of its main functions, to scrutinise the Government - or get its teeth into Government - very effectively....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
1087 words (3.1 pages)

The Rump Parliament Essay

- The Rump Parliament That the Rump Parliament had absolutely no achievements at all to its name is a strong statement. As a governing body setup by the remnants of Pride's Purge, the MP's that remained were all wanted there originally, indeed by the very man that would eventually dissolve them -- Oliver Cromwell. So something had certainly led Cromwell to become increasingly disillusioned with the Parliament he in sense created. This essay will examine these reasons and just what achievements the Rump succeeded in....   [tags: Papers]

Term Papers
731 words (2.1 pages)

The British Parliament Essay

- The British Parliament The British parliament consists of the Queen and two chambers, the House of Commons and the House of Lords. The functions of the parliament are to pass laws, to provide taxes and to control the actions of the government. The Queen still plays a role, but only a formal one. In law, she is the head of the executive, a part of the legislative and the head of the judiciary. The house of commons The members of the house of commons are elected directly by general majority in geographically defined parliamentary constituencies.The minimum age for franchise is 18 since 1969....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
479 words (1.4 pages)

British Parliament Essay

- British Parliament Many of the political observers consider functions of the British Parliament as a constantly changing in accordance with public demands and political ambitions. In the 11th century for example when Parliament has had its origins, its main function was giving an advice to Saxon monarchs by assembly of the wise called "Witangemot"....   [tags: Papers]

Term Papers
944 words (2.7 pages)