The Scientific Sherlock Holmes : Cracking The Case With Science And Forensics

The Scientific Sherlock Holmes : Cracking The Case With Science And Forensics

Length: 1031 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Scientific Sherlock Holmes: Cracking the Case with Science and Forensics
James O’Brien
Sherlock Holmes and his methods have been criticized since the beginning. A news article titled Every Man His Own Holmes was published in the New York Times in 1894 after the first Holmes story “A Study in Scarlet” swept the public away. In this piece this editor describes the epidemic Holmes has caused:
“Everyone knows the exasperating way in which Sherlock Holmes made what he called deductions. If he saw a man with muddy boots, he instantly deduced from that fact a long history of the man’s career, from his cradle to the moment when his boots became muddy. This was not sheer impudence. It was rather a species of madness, and like certain varieties of madness it had a great deal of method in it.” (The New York Times)
It was Doyle’s use of deductions and knowledge of sciences that allowed Sherlock Holmes to influence and inspire the use of science in real-life crime work. As we have advanced in the fields Holmes used to solve his crimes it only makes sense for modern day critics to continue the debunking tradition. Well one author took it upon himself to gather and review the Holmes’ use of science.
In The Scientific Sherlock Holmes James O’Brien evaluates the scientific validity of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s beloved character. We are taken through evaluating each science that is mentioned in the entirety of the Sherlock Holmes collection (or the CANON as fans would say). It reviews different aspects of forensic science including fingerprints, footprints, handwriting analysis, printed documents, cryptology, and chemistry. O’Brien’s book is only 180 pages including his reference pages. If we narrow it down even further to just the portions of ...


... middle of paper ...


...cryptology or the history of it. This section highlighted and praised one of Doyle’s influences Edgar Allen Poe because of Poe’s obsession with cryptograms. It was a missed opportunity for this author because he had the perfect segue to go from the case of the Zodiac Killer to the ciphering skills of Sherlock Holmes. This portion is ineffectual in reviewing Holmes’ use of cryptology.
Considering the topic of O’Brien’s case study is evaluating Sherlock Holmes and his use of science his content should be more focused and balanced. More history about the science Holmes used frequently as opposed to the topic with the easiest information to gather is more beneficial in supporting his topic. For example, Holmes used footprinting as one of his main tools and only mentioned fingerprinting in seven of the cases (most of which did not play a large role in solving the case).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Forensic Science And Forensics Science Essays

- Both computer forensic or forensic science and Biometrics sometimes may apply same identification methods; however, they do so for different purposes. Computer forensics or forensics science is based on history and a forensic investigator does not just pick a method in advance. In other words, forensics investigators are unaware of what they will find as evidence. In addition, the manner in which forensics tools and evidence are handled may have critical implications, which can make or break a case....   [tags: Forensic science, Computer forensics]

Better Essays
768 words (2.2 pages)

Essay about Sherlock Holmes : Father Of Scientific Crime Detection

- Berg, Stanton O. "Sherlock Holmes: Father of Scientific Crime Detection." The Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology, and Police Science: 446. Print. This journal covers a vast array of topics. Firstly, the journal speaks about the universal appeal of Sherlock Holmes. The journal speaks on how Sherlock Holmes appeals to the young and the old, the rich and the poor alike. It quickly goes over what other authors have had to say about Sherlock Holmes contributing to forensic science. Such as The Criminologist Ashton-Wolfe who stated that many of the methods invented by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle where in use at the time (1932.) It goes on to cover the greater significance of Sherlock Holmes as well...   [tags: Sherlock Holmes, Arthur Conan Doyle]

Better Essays
1072 words (3.1 pages)

The Nature Of Scientific And Scientific Science Essay

- Science coming from the latin word scientia, meaning “knowledge”, is a systematic structure that builds and organizes knowledge from testable explanations and predictions about the universe. The nature of scientific progress and the rationality of scientific change lies between Karl Popper and Thomas Kuhn. The two influential philosophers of the 20th century had very different views of science which has caused countless debates because of it. One of them, which I believe is most interesting, was the idea of the scientific method and the idea of there even being one....   [tags: Scientific method, Theory, Science]

Better Essays
1007 words (2.9 pages)

Psychological Aspects Of Digital Forensics Essay examples

- M7A1 Essay: Psychological Aspects of Digital Forensics This paper will briefly identify and explain the psychological aspects of digital forensics. It will further examine the role of psychological profiling in digital forensic investigations. Lastly, it will examine the various stresses that digital crime investigations places on the digital forensics investigator. Digital forensics is almost like observing someone’s complete psyche, you see that person’s likes and dislikes. You are viewing their hates and loves; you are finding things they don’t want to share with anyone else in the entire world....   [tags: Forensic science, Computer forensics]

Better Essays
957 words (2.7 pages)

Digital Forensics : Potential For Miscarriages Of Justice Essay

- Digital Forensics: Potential for Miscarriages of Justice Madhavi Chandra Saladi 706630 ISYS90051 msaladi@student.unimelb.edu.au Introduction Digitisation has substantially transformed traditional forensic procedures including the way evidences are collected, preserved and produced in the court of Law. Electronic records from digital devices are being accepted in courts as proofs during trials and several digital forensic tools are employed for use by forensic practitioners on a day to day basis within military, law enforcement and government organisations....   [tags: Forensic science, Computer forensics, Conviction]

Better Essays
1184 words (3.4 pages)

Forensic Evidence Of Forensic Science Essay

- Forensic evidence can provide just outcomes in criminal matters. However, it is not yet an exact science as it can be flawed. It can be misrepresented through the reliability of the evidence, through nonstandard guidelines, and through public perception. Forensic science can be dangerously faulty without focus on the ‘science’ aspect. It can at times be just matching patterns based on an individual’s interpretations. This can lead to a miscarriage of justice and forever alter a person’s life due to a perceived “grey area” (Merritt C, 2010) resulting in a loss of confidence in the reliability of forensic evidence....   [tags: Forensic science, Fingerprint, CSI effect]

Better Essays
1204 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on The Scientific Method Of Science

- This book revolves around the idea that one does not have to be a scientist in order to use and appreciate the scientific method. The author, Carl Sagan uses the scientific method to debunk the very thought of demons, myths, gods, devils, and strange obsessions to the supernatural that he believes plagues humanity. Scientists explain this behavior in humans as an intellectual curiosity towards science, however it is pseudoscience. Pseudoscience is a collection of beliefs mistakenly regarded as being based on the scientific method....   [tags: Scientific method, Science, Theory, Carl Sagan]

Better Essays
1139 words (3.3 pages)

Building A Digital Forensics Laboratory Essay examples

- Technical. The expansion of this organization in the cybersecurity arena has established a necessity to construct a digital forensics laboratory to expand the organization’s evolution in the digital forensics field. To achieve this, Nelson, Steuart, and Phillips (2014) articulates that it is imperative to get an account of information systems and software utilized in the critical infrastructure sectors (p. 67). According to the Department of Homeland Security (2014), the nation’s critical infrastructure encompasses the subsequent sectors depicted in Table 1....   [tags: Forensic science, Computer forensics]

Better Essays
1005 words (2.9 pages)

Forensics Anthropology Essay

- Forensics Anthropology is the study that goes beyond the human skeleton. A forensics anthropologist can find out. How a person lived, the food that person ate, and the overall make-up of a human. The use of forensics has grown in recent years, it is used to solve crimes and locate missing persons. Snow, (1982) Forensics anthropology is not a new science. The first case forensics anthropology was used on was the Jezebel case, dating back to the nineteenth century. This case involved a person, who was thrown from a window....   [tags: scientific research]

Better Essays
882 words (2.5 pages)

Forensic Science Essay

- Forensic Science, also known as Forensics, is the application of science to law. It uses highly developed technology to uncover scientific evidence in a variety of fields. Modern forensic science has a broad range of applications. It is used in civil cases such as forgeries, fraud or negligence. The most common use of forensic science is to investigate criminal cases involving a victim, such as assault, robbery, kidnapping , rape, or murder.       Forensic science is also used in monitoring the compliance of various countries with such international agreements as the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty and the Chemical Weapons Convention and to learn whether a country is developing a secret...   [tags: Forensics essays research papers]

Better Essays
1613 words (4.6 pages)