The Scientific Account of Inductivism vs. Falsificationism: Is Science Objective?

The Scientific Account of Inductivism vs. Falsificationism: Is Science Objective?

Length: 931 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The following essay aims to discuss whether science is objective or subjective in light of two competing theories: inductivism and falsificationism. Addressing the main quote, I will state how Popper would respond to two of Chalmers’ core ideas, before providing my own opinions and justification on the matter.

Chalmers account of science is from an inductivist’s perspective. He believes that science is achieved through justifying universal statements from singular statements. (Chalmers, 1976) Thus, leading to believe that these statements can be proven. Falsificationists disagree with the view that scientific knowledge is proven knowledge. They reason that no number of observations will sufficiently prove a claim. On the contrary, it only requires one observation to sufficiently disprove a claim. Popper would respond that it is greater than probable that a claim will be false. He would conclude that scientific knowledge is not proven knowledge but rather the best justification of our understanding of the world at any given time.

I further this opinion of Popper; nothing in science can be seen as an unquestionable truth. It is illogical for any singular statement to be considered a universal statement. By analogy, it is illogical to presume all dogs are brown because, through observation, you’ve only ever seen brown dogs. This logic predisposes science for failure. An excellent example of such is the paradigm shift away from Newtonian physics in light of Einstein’s discoveries. Einstein presented a new context for motion that was otherwise not considered by Newton. The fact is that almost every scientific ‘truth’ to be presented throughout history has been falsified, which is an inherent flaw within the notion of induction.

...


... middle of paper ...


...r the charge of an electron was later shown to be within one-half of a percent of the currently accepted value. It can be concluded that observation cannot solely be relied upon, but rather science requires a certain amount of ingenuity in making further deductions.

In conclusion, investigating Chalmers core ideas, falsificationism was found to be far superior to induction. First, scientific knowledge is not proven knowledge. Second, science is not objective. Investigations into the place of speculative imaginings in science found that both Chalmers and Popper were conditionally correct. Investigating the question of whether science was objective or subjective found that due to limitations of observations by human kind, science is at best, subjective.



Works Cited

Chalmers, A. (1976). What is this thing called science? St. Lucia: University of Queensland Press.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Nature Of Scientific And Scientific Science Essay

- Science coming from the latin word scientia, meaning “knowledge”, is a systematic structure that builds and organizes knowledge from testable explanations and predictions about the universe. The nature of scientific progress and the rationality of scientific change lies between Karl Popper and Thomas Kuhn. The two influential philosophers of the 20th century had very different views of science which has caused countless debates because of it. One of them, which I believe is most interesting, was the idea of the scientific method and the idea of there even being one....   [tags: Scientific method, Theory, Science]

Better Essays
1007 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on The Scientific Method Of Science

- This book revolves around the idea that one does not have to be a scientist in order to use and appreciate the scientific method. The author, Carl Sagan uses the scientific method to debunk the very thought of demons, myths, gods, devils, and strange obsessions to the supernatural that he believes plagues humanity. Scientists explain this behavior in humans as an intellectual curiosity towards science, however it is pseudoscience. Pseudoscience is a collection of beliefs mistakenly regarded as being based on the scientific method....   [tags: Scientific method, Science, Theory, Carl Sagan]

Better Essays
1139 words (3.3 pages)

Essay about The Scientific Of Scientific Realism

- Scientific realism is defined in terms of the truth of empirically proven scientific theories. A scientific realist is someone who thinks that all scientific theories aim to describe the universe as it is. Scientific realists believe the claim that there is true progress in science and whether the unobservable entities explained by science can really be taken as truth. The distinction between observable and unobservable entities is reflected by the human senses. For instance, a scientific realist believes in the existence of electrons because of empirical data despite not being able to see an electron with human senses....   [tags: Scientific method, Science, Philosophy of science]

Better Essays
1685 words (4.8 pages)

The Scientific Theory Of Scientific Theories Essay

- Are any scientific theories true. If so why. If not why do we rely on them. A scientific theory is an explanation that is well- substantiated explanation in regards to some aspect of the natural world that is attained through scientific method and is tested numerous times and usually confirmed through vigorous observation and experimentation. The term theory can be seen as a collection of laws which allow you to show some kind of phenomenon. The strength of a scientific theory associated with the diversity of phenomena can explain its elegance and simplicity....   [tags: Scientific method, Theory, Philosophy of science]

Better Essays
1950 words (5.6 pages)

Science Of Science And Science Essay

- Since the times of the Vienna Circle in the early twentieth century, most philosophers have defined science’s epistemic aims in the interlinked concepts of explanation and understanding, laws, unity of science, and causes (IIT). Most theories relating to the above four concepts emphasize generality’s importance in science’s epistemic significance (Nov 2nd handout). This notion of generalization is linked to the underlying belief that science is reducible, and the collective body of sciences aim to be unified and to discover the broad laws of nature (Neurath 306)....   [tags: Science, Scientific method, Philosophy of science]

Better Essays
1266 words (3.6 pages)

Scientific Investigation And Experimentation Of Scientific Objectivity Essay example

- In Search of Scientific Objectivity To speculate on objectivity is to question an abstract concept that humans invented to establish a common ground on which they could form knowledge. In the case of science, objectivity refers to the idea that scientific inquiry and experimentation is separated from opinion, which is the subject of debate since many facts are dependent on other pieces of scientific knowledge. Perhaps, in a perfect world, scientists would not take into account their own values before beginning experiments, or conducting research, but as Stemwedel points out, “So being objective in the sense of following good scientific methodology requires a commitment not to mislead” (Stem...   [tags: Scientific method, Science, Pseudoscience, Theory]

Better Essays
1389 words (4 pages)

Scientific Theories That Science Can Not Answer Essay

- Scientific theory M1 According to the oxford dictionary ‘’2008’’ scientific theory is ‘’ a well-substantiated explanation of some aspect of the natural world that is acquired through the scientific method and repeatedly tested and confirmed through observation and experimentation’’. In this essay I will be looking at three different types of theories. I will be looking at theories that science is still addressing, theories that science cannot answer yet and theories that science will never answer....   [tags: Theory, Scientific method, Ignaz Semmelweis]

Better Essays
1821 words (5.2 pages)

Essay about On Theory Change in Science

- On Theory Change in Science The inductivist account of science recognizes five steps which are essential to scientific progress. First, scientists compile a large body of facts from observation and experiment. Using the principle of induction, these facts can be generalized to form the basis for a theory or law. Then, once a theory has been developed, scientists can use the theory as part of a valid logical argument to make new predictions or explanations of phenomena. According to Chalmers, the inductivist account has “a certain appeal” to it, namely, that all of scientific progress can be seen as the result of five fundamental leaps of thought (54)....   [tags: Inductivist Philosopher Induction Essays]

Better Essays
1384 words (4 pages)

Essay on The Scientific Method

- The Scientific Method is the standardized procedure that scientists are supposed to follow when conducting experiments, in order to try to construct a reliable, consistent, and non-arbitrary representation of our surroundings. To follow the Scientific Method is to stick very tightly to a order of experimentation. First, the scientist must observe the phenomenon of interest. Next, the scientist must propose a hypothesis, or idea in which the experiments will be based around. Then, through repeated experimentation, the hypothesis can either be proven false or become a theory....   [tags: science scientific method]

Better Essays
1168 words (3.3 pages)

Scientific Method Essay

- Scientific method what comes to mind. Do we start thinking of some type of formal process that will answer all our scientific questions or problems. When I was in school many years ago, we were taught that scientists go through a series of steps to find a solution to a problem or find evidence to support or disprove a theory. It all seemed rather cold, and formal. Going back to school, school has taught me that science has undergone significant changes and has moved away from the rigidity of a fixed series of steps in what was formerly called the scientific method....   [tags: Education Scientific Method Science]

Better Essays
1166 words (3.3 pages)