Essay on Science vs. Religion

Essay on Science vs. Religion

Length: 1300 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Religion versus science, the debates and conflicts have been on for centuries. For both religious and scientific ideals, the faith people have drives them. In this paper, I will examine the story of “The Eye of Apollo” by G.K. Chesterton, and the episode “House vs. God” of House, M.D., in order to question this conflict. The main character—Father Brown—in “The Eye of Apollo” combines his reasoning with his religious ideals and beliefs, or we can say his faith in God leads him to the truth of the crime. However, if we try to have a deeper look at the both the rational and religious sides of Father Brown, his perspectives on the immortality and justice are similar to Dr House, who interprets his rationality based on science. Thus both the beliefs and faith in religion and science in some way reflect the faith and way of thinking of people, and the two different ideals don’t necessarily conflict with each other.
In The Eye of Apollo, Father Brown solves the mystery of Pauline Stacey’s death. Father Brown is a Catholic priest and serves and a detective. The story begins with a debut of a new religion of Apollo and the New Priest of Apollo, Kalon. The new religion claims “it can cure all the physical diseases”. Pauline Stacey was blind who was heiress of great wealth and power and believed in the New Religion. When Father Brown and Flambeau were in the building, the tragedy happened—Pauline Stacey fell down onto the elevator and died. After a short investigation of the sisters’ office and observation, Father Brown starts questioning Kalon with doubts. But Kalon gives a long speech in defense of his religion and his innocence of the murder. He believes that Miss Stacey died of her faith in the new religion, which is not strong eno...


... middle of paper ...


...tionalism and makes Boyd blind over the truth. So either the Chesterton story or the episode emphasizes on the “real” faith people have, no matter what is the basis for their particular faiths. Similarly, when the way of thinking is considered in both stories, both Father Brown and Dr House can be concluded as reasoners who hold their doubts or distrusts and keep being skeptical of everything that is contradictory to their own beliefs.



Works Cited


Burns, Timothy. “The Rationalism of Father Brown”. Perspectives on Political Science 34.1 (2005): 37-46. Print.
Iannaccone Laurence R., Rodney Stark and Roger Finke. “Religion, Science and Rationality”. The American Economic Review 86.2 (1995): 433-37. Print.
Sappinton, A.A. “The Religion/Science Conflict”. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 30.1 (1991): 114-20. Print.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Epistemology - Are science and religion in conflict? Essays

- The relationship between science and religion is a difficult one and the two sides have tested each other and debated each other in many forums. Some believe there are major differences in science and religion and that the two can never coexist while others believe that science is in fact evidence that religious views are correct. To better understand and answer the question of whether the two sides really do conflict we will look at: my view on the subject, the definitions of both science and religion, basic arguments of both sides, scientific evolution, differing religions and religious views, the compatible versus incompatible argument, how religion has influenced science and views from t...   [tags: Science, Religion, Evolution]

Strong Essays
1818 words (5.2 pages)

Essay about Science Vs. Religion : Science And Religion

- The author, sociologist Elaine Howard Eckland, who studied at Rice University, interviewed 275 scientists and surveyed more than 1,700 scientists to get the more open point of views to the long debate “Science vs. Religion”. The author investigates the unexamined assumption that science and religion are irreconcilable. The reason she has done this research is to hear the voices that have been overlooked in the debates and that could have powerful contributions to the translation of information to a broader audience, specifically the religious audience....   [tags: Religion, Faith, Philosophy of religion, Science]

Strong Essays
701 words (2 pages)

Evolutionary Theory According to Science and Religion Essays

- Charles Darwin was a scientist and naturalist, primarily recognised as the first and most influential advocate of the evolutionary theory through natural selection. After the publication of his book in 1859, “On the Origin of Species”, people began to identify the foundations of humanity very differently. However, even though the scientific approval of his theory was close to becoming worldwide, there have been countless opposition groups, predominantly amongst the religious believers. (Darwin, 2008) According to Darwin, the relationship between science and religion is commonly represented as an issue that is irreconcilable where one side is claiming something, the other can’t accept;...   [tags: theory, natuarl, science, religion]

Strong Essays
1780 words (5.1 pages)

Life Begins: Understanding by Science and Religion Essay

- “A human being can’t survive unassisted on the moon absent the creation of an artificial atmosphere via technology. The same goes for the embryo on the fetus that are living in the womb” (Smith, 1). The different beliefs and opinions can determine how you answer a question. When life begins is answered differently based upon personal beliefs dealing with religion and science. Jewish people related they believes based on the Bible. Judaism lived by the rules of the Old Testament as well as the “rabbinical writings” (Human Life Begins, 3)....   [tags: beliefs, questions, science, religion]

Strong Essays
539 words (1.5 pages)

Galileo 's Views On Science And Religion Essay

- According to many philosophers science and religion provide the same kind of knowledge. In other words, the knowledge that is attained from science and religion is in direct competition with one another (Saucedo, n.d.). According to Galileo that is not the case. Galileo believed that the knowledge that science and religion provide us comes from two completely different realms. One has nothing to do with the other. Galileo believed in the heliocentric view. The belief that as humans we have the ability to understand things differently than how they might have been meant....   [tags: Scientific method, Science, Human, Religion]

Strong Essays
1545 words (4.4 pages)

Science And Religion By John F. Haught Essay example

- Science and Religion dialogue has been a bitter-sweet topic for many people over the years. The controversy is not only common between one sole community, but affects a variety. The beliefs held about these topics has the potential to personally effect an individual, whether it be positively or negatively. In the United States, we draw only a fine line between religion and science, often failing to realize that the two benefit each other in copious ways but are not meant to interpreted in the same way....   [tags: God, Theology, Religion, Religion and science]

Strong Essays
894 words (2.6 pages)

Science vs Religion Essay

- Title of Assignment Is science just another form of religion, with people like physicist Stephen Hawking among its high priests. Are science and religions simply both similar social constructions. In your response to this question, specifically consider how irrational social factors influence everything, including science and religion. Introduction One of today's most disputable and warmed issues is whether the clash between science and religion could be accommodated. The verbal confrontation between science and religion is never out of the news....   [tags: Science and Religion]

Strong Essays
1400 words (4 pages)

Essay on Science and Religion

- Science and religion have always been in conflict with one another because they each represent complete opposite ideals, science is about how nature controls how the universe works and religion is about how God controls how the universe works. In the five models on science and religion I believe that Conflict best describes the relationship between the two. Conflict tells how either science is completely right and religion is wrong or the other way around and that religion and science are completely different....   [tags: Science Religion Creation ]

Strong Essays
803 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on Religion Must Embrace Science

- In 1633, Galileo Galilei was placed on trial for suspicion of heresy by the Roman Catholic Church of the era. The trial was in response to Galileo’s publication of Dialogue, a book which propounded Copernicus’ theory of heliocentrism, or more simply known as the Earth’s movement around the sun. The church believed the common biblically founded view that the Earth could not be moved. Copernican theory is common knowledge these days, and Galileo’s efforts to prove the theory have earned him the title of father of science, but the Church’s opposition to science has remained largely unchanged....   [tags: Science and Religion]

Strong Essays
1252 words (3.6 pages)

Religion vs. Science Essay

- On The Origin Of Religion Over centuries, the epic battle between modern science and ancient religion rose to the level of wars, resulting in millions of deaths all over nations. Since the days of Galileo, religion has tried to kill any kind of scientific thinking, logic reasoning, or theories. Science is no innocent victim as it has always tried to wipe out any religious meanings and the existence of God, throughout contaminated evolution theories and philosophical thinking. However, scientists nowadays are more reasoning; believing that faith is a gift they haven’t yet received....   [tags: Science, Religion]

Strong Essays
1072 words (3.1 pages)